Gransnet forums

News & politics

Do you think the UK will go extreme right like some of the other European countries?

(51 Posts)
nanna8 Sat 27-Jan-24 08:58:11

I was listening to YouTube about how The Telegraph seems to be shifting to the right ( only hearsay for me, we don’t read it and it is not available) . The commentator was saying there is a rise of extreme right wing politics and politicians. He wasn’t advocating this, just commentating and trying to predict trends.
It doesn’t seem to be happening here in Australia, if anything we seem to be going in the opposite direction but that seems to be how it goes. I read about the USA and Germany and Holland and wonder if there is a big movement to the right and if there is, why ?

Galaxy Sun 28-Jan-24 08:41:52

I dont think they will mess things up I think considering the scale of the issues it will be impossible to make any impact on those issues in the time they will be in office. I am cheery like that.

Freya5 Sun 28-Jan-24 08:36:27

Callistemon21

Grantanow

No because we are going to elect a Labour government.

😁

Not with my vote..

maddyone Sat 27-Jan-24 21:44:41

I think it’s unlikely. It’s more likely to veer towards the left.

flappergirl Sat 27-Jan-24 20:31:24

MaizieD

flappergirl

Nicenanny3

10:04flappergirl

The right in any country always promises to do all of these things and that is why a certain demographic, generally the old, the less educated and the disaffected are drawn to them and cling to them. That is what is happening at the moment

Perhaps Labour shouldn't count their chickens then you are describing a lot of Red Wall seat voters.

I believe they all voted Tory last time and the Red Wall crumbled.

I don't think they're going to make the same mistake again...

You wouldn't have thought so MaizieD. Fool me once and all that but who knows! If the working classes think that Tories are the answer, it makes you wonder what the question was.

MaizieD Sat 27-Jan-24 15:58:51

I'm not quite sure which graph you're looking at, Casdon. The one I posted, attitudes on race & immigration showed all age groups becoming more progressive apart from the 18 -29 r old men.

I really should go to the original article. I was just lifting images off twitter.

MayBee70 Sat 27-Jan-24 15:19:41

fancythat

I did hear a tv commentator say he thought Labour would get in. They would mess things up. Then a right wing conservative government, then a further to the right, conservative governement.

But since nowadays, no one seems able to predict things even to the end of a year, I rather took it all with a pinch of salt.

Labour can’t possibly mess things up the way the Conservative government have been doing for the past few years…

valdavi Sat 27-Jan-24 14:59:59

I was involved in setting up Independant Living for disabled people in Bristol At the time, it was costed as being cheaper than care in a residential home setting. It is worrying what standard of care is going to be provided in a residential setting if it's cheaper than the cost of PA's. (a lot of the admin that adds significantly to care staff costs is done by the disabled person themselves).If there really isn't the money for the most expensive Independant Living packages, then at least the people who have existing packages shoud be allowed to continue, with a change of care model only considered for new applicants or those with escalating care needs.

Callistemon21 Sat 27-Jan-24 14:46:20

petra

It’s sad to say, Jane but this has been spoken about for some time. The care system is broken ( I do speak from personal experience with a friend’s mother)
My friend was a manger in social services for some years, if she can’t get the help that’s needed then we are well and truely stuffed.
I know it’s awful what Bristol are proposing but what other options do they have 😥

If we apply logic to that, then it means that Labour and Green proposals are far-right, ergo Labour and Greens are now far-right?
🤔

Casdon Sat 27-Jan-24 14:42:16

MaizieD

petra

You only have to see how many young men follow Andrew Tate.

This thought struck, too, when I read Burn Murdoch's tweets.

He says:

Historically the views of men and women in the same generations have been very similar. This is still true for older age-groups, but a gap has opened between today’s young men and women.

His UK chart shows a strong divergence between men and women in the 18 -29 age group.

Will this eventually take the UK towards the extreme right, as per the question posed by the thread title?

Despite flappergirl's post showing advances women have made, men are still the dominant force in most areas of public life. As this 18 - 29 demographic becomes more active in public life will their 'conservative' views dominate?

And what about the generation coming along behind them?

Unless I’ve read it wrong, the graph still shows that the older you get the more right wing you are, and although there is a shift for men aged under 29 it’s not significant. It’s more likely to be a sign of the times they are experiencing at the moment, because the picture isn’t the same for women.

Gillycats Sat 27-Jan-24 14:40:12

We should all be concerned at the rise in Right Wing politics in Europe. That includes Poland where the right wing party lost its majority but still had the most votes. I think some of it is because of immigration. If people from other countries are prepared to work for peanuts it drives down wages, and in some countries they are housed over the heads of locals. It creates ill feeling. Not everyone wants to see their cultures diminished either. I’m not saying I agree or disagree but that, misogyny, bravado and this awful sense of entitlement that’s increasingly evident I believe are a big part of the problem.

valdavi Sat 27-Jan-24 14:21:45

Telegraph is extremely R wing at the moment.They're gunning for Sunak, gunning for the assisted dying campaign. They are getting behind Reform UK for the next election. Some of the editorial is just a joke, as they twist arguments to try & make it fit their political agenda And the comments by readership are frequently offensively racist. I got a very cheap online subscription, I like obits and letters and crosswords and recipes / holidays, but I get very indignant on a daily basis, luckily don't think I have long left on my subs. I think the UK is becoming more R wing, I'm not sure why. Labour /left-leaning didn't used to be a joke / dirty word did it?It's a similar beleaguered feeling to that which some practising C of E adherents must feel.

MaizieD Sat 27-Jan-24 14:11:51

Louella12

But it's not just in the Telegraph or Mail

*European elections in June will see a
'sharp turn to the right," in the
European Parliament in continuatior
of a political trend emerging across
Europe, according to a new study
released by the European Council
on Foreign Relations (ECFR). The
study relied on poling data from the
European Union's 27 member
states.**

Well, Poland drew back from the far right in their recent elections.

As I understand it Donald Tusk is now determinedly working to reverse the former Premier's moves to autocracy.

Is this a good omen for the future or a finger in a nearly overwhelmed dam?

Louella12 Sat 27-Jan-24 14:03:41

But it's not just in the Telegraph or Mail

*European elections in June will see a
'sharp turn to the right," in the
European Parliament in continuatior
of a political trend emerging across
Europe, according to a new study
released by the European Council
on Foreign Relations (ECFR). The
study relied on poling data from the
European Union's 27 member
states.**

MaizieD Sat 27-Jan-24 13:53:18

Oh, I meant to post the chart

MaizieD Sat 27-Jan-24 13:52:15

petra

You only have to see how many young men follow Andrew Tate.

This thought struck, too, when I read Burn Murdoch's tweets.

He says:

Historically the views of men and women in the same generations have been very similar. This is still true for older age-groups, but a gap has opened between today’s young men and women.

His UK chart shows a strong divergence between men and women in the 18 -29 age group.

Will this eventually take the UK towards the extreme right, as per the question posed by the thread title?

Despite flappergirl's post showing advances women have made, men are still the dominant force in most areas of public life. As this 18 - 29 demographic becomes more active in public life will their 'conservative' views dominate?

And what about the generation coming along behind them?

petra Sat 27-Jan-24 12:56:58

You only have to see how many young men follow Andrew Tate.

petra Sat 27-Jan-24 12:55:15

It’s sad to say, Jane but this has been spoken about for some time. The care system is broken ( I do speak from personal experience with a friend’s mother)
My friend was a manger in social services for some years, if she can’t get the help that’s needed then we are well and truely stuffed.
I know it’s awful what Bristol are proposing but what other options do they have 😥

flappergirl Sat 27-Jan-24 12:54:09

JaneJudge

It's very true that uneducated white men are more likely to be right wing and actually they have every reason to be worried.

Agencies such as the Police and Fire Service are being exposed as the worst extremes of mysogyny and in some cases heinous criminality.

Women now have greater autonomy over their own lives and hold positions of hierarchy as never before.

The MeToo Movement continues to call out sexual harrassment, dogma and bullying and has made it much harder for men to act with impunity.

The old order is under threat.

HousePlantQueen Sat 27-Jan-24 12:52:33

Good post flappergirl. As to the OP; the Torygraph has always been a right leaning newspaper, owned for many years by the non domiciled Barclay brothers, now up for sale along with its sister publication The Spectator.

JaneJudge Sat 27-Jan-24 12:43:52

This is the story if anyone is interested

amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/jan/25/warehouse-disabled-people-bristol-city-council

Whitewavemark2 Sat 27-Jan-24 12:36:28

What I have learned this past decade is that anything is possible - even the unthinkable.

JaneJudge Sat 27-Jan-24 12:05:41

It is a far right proposal though 🤷‍♀️

Callistemon21 Sat 27-Jan-24 12:01:34

JaneJudge

To be clear, I do not care the affiliation of the council. I care about what is being proposed

But you thought it was probably a far-right proposal.
It isn't.
Bristol Council has been Labour for years, now Labour/Green.
According to many reports, they have been failing people with disabilities for years.

JaneJudge Sat 27-Jan-24 11:57:04

To be clear, I do not care the affiliation of the council. I care about what is being proposed

Callistemon21 Sat 27-Jan-24 11:56:04

Ps Bristol has a Labour Mayor too.