You seem to conveniently forget the cost of covid, the effect of the war in Ukraine- supporting people with fuel bills and the cost of living - and the cost of supporting Ukraine’s military.
Now if none of the above had happened … but they did. So easy to pretend that they didn’t, and that they were totally unexpected.
I’m not stupid either. I know the fragile fiscal basis on which Starmer’s ‘plan’ is predicated, but you choose not to acknowledge the fragility. It’s estimated that 26% of pupils will be removed from independent schools if VAT is imposed on fees, and some schools will be unable to survive that and the imposition of business rates - so that won’t pull in the money they expected. I don’t know where they will find the people to beef up border force and HMRC, but they will have to be paid; border force officials consider it won’t stop the boats, and I hope you (as a former HMRC employee) understand how long it takes to identify and investigate possible tax evasion, let alone to retrieve any money. So what exactly is going to pay for the ‘plan’ (especially with doctors still holding out for a 35% pay rise)? Promises, promises … undeliverable.