Gransnet forums

News & politics

200k people wrongly investigated over faulty government algorithm!

(9 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

CvD66 Sun 23-Jun-24 19:35:33

Yet another IT scandal causing untold stress and distress to claimants as it has been established 200,000 people have been investigated for potential housing fraud due to a faulty government algorithm over the last 3 yrs. Over 2/3rds have been cleared but that cost the taxpayer £4.4m in inspectors!
Why is this government so occupied with investigating those in need and at a huge cost to the British taxpayer?
Before our usual Tory fans claim, there would be no problem if these people stopped claiming, please recognise schemes exist due to the appalling actions of the current government which has resulted in increase poverty in UK today.
Obviously this last comment will bring out the trolls desperate to claim it’s all the fault of those too lazy to work. It must be lovely to throw insults from your ivory tower in the face of further inadequate Tory reliance on computer driven incompetence. It’s the Post Office all over again!

AGAA4 Sun 23-Jun-24 19:46:35

I was interested in your post until you started insulting other posters. Calling people trolls and in their ivory towers was very unpleasant.

Opal Sun 23-Jun-24 20:12:01

You had me onside until you started banging your drum - of course the algorithm should be changed if a large majority of the people identified are subsequently being cleared. However, it must have correctly identified tens of thousands of people who were guilty of fraud - I hope they were severely dealt with. I can assure you my husband and I have worked bloody hard all our lives for our "ivory tower" - a standard 3 bedroom detached house in a pleasant rural area - and it really pisses me off when we are seen as the bad guys, having paid our taxes, raised our family, put our children through university and having never resorted to criminality to get where we are and have what we have. Oh, and we have never inherited a penny! But hey, we're just the working class that shoulder the burden of the benefits system. Yes, of course the system should be in place for those who need and deserve it, but I reserve the right to call out the scroungers - and there are plenty.

Doodledog Sun 23-Jun-24 20:21:12

Can we have a source for this please, OP?

Elegran Sun 23-Jun-24 20:42:33

The figure of 200,000 claims is mentioned in the Govt. publication www.gov.uk/government/publications/fighting-fraud-in-the-welfare-system/fighting-fraud-in-the-welfare-system-going-further.

"This year we have reviewed over 200,000 claims, finding and putting right incorrect declarations on almost 50,000 claims, and stopping individuals from building up debts. This has included finding unreported capital of over £16,000, wrongly declared self-employment expenses, and undisclosed second homes."

That is a small part of the publication.

There are also some case studies. One of them is -

" Case Study: Economic, Serious and Organised Crime - Operation Volcanic

Five members of an organised gang pleaded guilty in court in April 2024 after Economic, Serious & Organised Crime investigators identified an organised attack on our benefits system involving fabricated claims resulting in more than £50 million being overpaid. This is DWP’s largest benefit fraud case to date and involved conspiracy and money laundering crimes.

The investigation uncovered:

Production and supply of fake tenancy agreements and employment claims, counterfeit payslips, and GP notes
Creation of shell companies for false employment
‘Benefit factories’ which appeared to be legitimate businesses
Money laundering from the false benefit claims
Sharing of forged documents via WhatsApp
‘Claim packs’ at the benefit factories and suspects’ houses.

All five defendants pleaded guilty before the trial was due to commence and they will be sentenced in May 2024.
Specialist Financial investigators will continue their work to identify assets and recover stolen monies.

I wonder whether any of the defendants in that case were the same people who sometimes post on GN with a list of the fake documents they can provide?

Dinahmo Mon 24-Jun-24 10:47:28

The answer is simple. It's much easier to go after those who are poor and possibly inadequate in their dealings with the authorities. Similarly it is easier for HMRC to go after those who owe small amounts of tax or who don't declare their cash in hand income than it is to go after the Mrs Sunak of the world. ie non doms who are in fact doms.

Sarnia Mon 24-Jun-24 10:51:25

AGAA4

I was interested in your post until you started insulting other posters. Calling people trolls and in their ivory towers was very unpleasant.

Same here. We are all entitled to our opinion and those who don't follow the OP's beliefs and opinions should not be insulted because of it.

nanna8 Mon 24-Jun-24 10:55:04

My comment back to the nasty comment about trolls is that it takes one to know one ! We don’t get many on here and if we did I would leave and I think others would as well.

LilyGransnet (GNHQ) Mon 24-Jun-24 15:28:38

Hi OP,

We don't allow troll hunting on Gransnet, and we don't think that starting a thread that accuses others of being trolls is set up for civil discussion.

We'll be removing your thread shortly.