Gransnet forums

News & politics

Who should lead the Tories now?

(130 Posts)
kittylester Sat 06-Jul-24 07:48:18

Just that really.

Any suggestions and reasons why?

Casdon Sun 07-Jul-24 18:56:19

David Davis is still there I think, he’s got a lot of experience that could be called on, although he must be too old to bid for leadership I would guess?

growstuff Sun 07-Jul-24 18:47:44

I looked at the list of surviving Conservative MPs - to be honest I hadn't heard of most of them, so I don't know what their opinions are, but if one of those becomes leader, I wonder if there are enough others with similar views to form a shadow cabinet.

David49 Sun 07-Jul-24 18:39:41

growstuff

Good grief! If Johnson is the best they can come up with, the Conservatives really are in a mess.

Johnson, Braverman, Badenoch, Patel, all very right wing, Boris we don’t have to concern ourselves he’s not an MP, be worried about the others

growstuff Sun 07-Jul-24 18:30:35

Good grief! If Johnson is the best they can come up with, the Conservatives really are in a mess.

David49 Sun 07-Jul-24 18:21:33

Romola

The membership of the Conservative Party, not just MPs, vote for the leader. That's how we got Liz Truss. Perhaps the Conservatives should think again about giving their membership too much say. Or maybe they've joined Reform anyway.
Incidentally, the Electoral Reform Society has shown on its website a diagram mapping MPs elected by proportional representation (system unspecified). Labour plus Lib Dem do outnumber Conservative plus Reform, but not by much.

Given the opportunity the Conservative Party Members would vote Johnson back in as leader, they think he was very unjustly deposed

Romola Sun 07-Jul-24 17:28:53

The membership of the Conservative Party, not just MPs, vote for the leader. That's how we got Liz Truss. Perhaps the Conservatives should think again about giving their membership too much say. Or maybe they've joined Reform anyway.
Incidentally, the Electoral Reform Society has shown on its website a diagram mapping MPs elected by proportional representation (system unspecified). Labour plus Lib Dem do outnumber Conservative plus Reform, but not by much.

Oldbat1 Sun 07-Jul-24 17:21:07

Galaxy

It wouldnt be a good idea to bring Johnson back but they would have been in a better position if they had stuck with him. The question isnt who we like or who is a good man/woman, its who should lead the Tories, and I assume the aim of that leadership would be to gain power.

Oh yes bring back a proven liar. I cannot understand folk who would even contemplate that. I really really cant stand the buffoon and his “entitlement”.

BigMamma Sun 07-Jul-24 16:32:23

Magsymoo

What a good idea. Let’s bring back a disgraced former PM. A man who has lied and cheated in his personal and professional life for personal gain over and over again. A man who has contributed massively to a decline in standards in public life which has spilled out into ordinary life. Yes, that’s just what the country needs!

Better the devil you know I suppose.

Galaxy Sun 07-Jul-24 16:29:16

In the last half hour my dog has thrown himself down some rapids, got stuck in some sort of mud bank, and vomited twice. I do have some reservations about pets as world leaders.

Grantanow Sun 07-Jul-24 15:43:54

Larry the cat couldn't do much worse than the last five and a whole lot better than Truss.

Casdon Sat 06-Jul-24 16:50:27

I agree Galaxy, it’s a real melting pot at the moment. Trying to meet the wants and wishes of an electorate with such different values is very difficult.

Galaxy Sat 06-Jul-24 16:29:42

I dont know Casdon. They tend to go absolutely bonkers when they fail, look at the ineffective leaders they had after Major. I think politics is changing completely, no longer are you a labour voter or a Tory voter because your family has always voted that way. The influence of the press is also disappearing, interesting times. But I don't want the 'left' unchecked by opposition in the same way I dont want the right unchallenged.

Whitewavemark2 Sat 06-Jul-24 16:26:35

The majority of voters voted for the more centre left progressive parties. Only the minority voted for the right or far right.

Perhaps it would make more sense for the Tories to pull back to the centre right?

winterwhite Sat 06-Jul-24 16:22:24

The Times today has a detailed list of the results in all seats. It shows that in the majority of seats that changed hands the Tory plus Reform votes totalled more than those of the winning candidate. Many of the Reform voters would prob otherwise have stayed at home but this does show the now nationwide spread of the angry, unsophisticated and susceptible electorate on which reform preys.

The Tory need to take a very long spoon if they are going to sup hwith Reform.

Casdon Sat 06-Jul-24 16:21:41

Galaxy

That's why they should ignore people who will never vote for them.

Do you think an internal divorce is on the way within the party Galaxy?

Galaxy Sat 06-Jul-24 16:18:08

That's why they should ignore people who will never vote for them.

LizzieDrip Sat 06-Jul-24 16:15:54

If Kemi Badenoch becomes leader and is as unpopular with the country as she is with her constituents (who would historically have voted for a donkey with a blue rosette), the Conservatives really will be unelectable

Badenoch gets my vote then - not that I’ll have a vote in that particular bun fight😉

chickkygran Sat 06-Jul-24 16:03:32

I would have said Penny Mordant if she had regained her seat. No one is inspiring confidence atm

growstuff Sat 06-Jul-24 15:55:44

If Kemi Badenoch becomes leader and is as unpopular with the country as she is with her constituents (who would historically have voted for a donkey with a blue rosette), the Conservatives really will be unelectable.

Grantanow Sat 06-Jul-24 15:44:38

The Buffoon got rid of some of the most able Tory MPs like David Gauke. Most of those now elected seem to be Right wing so I guess they'll want a Right-winger like Badenoch. That probably means they will stay in fantasy land and be unelectable.

Oreo Sat 06-Jul-24 13:45:41

I think Tom Tugenhat would be a good bet for the new LOTO.

Casdon Sat 06-Jul-24 13:39:00

Anniebach

Jeremy Hunt is reported to hsve said he will not stand, SKYnews

Yes, I was thinking purely of the interim Anniebach, if he takes himself out of the game by saying he doesn’t want to be the leader on a permanent basis perhaps he could hold it all together while they decide, and be a strong opposition to Labour? I can’t think of anybody else, other than David Cameron who would be as capable in the short term.

growstuff Sat 06-Jul-24 12:28:46

Interesting times! If the Conservatives choose somebody like Patel, Braveman or Badenoch, they're putting a marker down about the direction they're going in. They might bring back some Reform voters back into the fold, but I doubt if they'd attract "traditional" Conservative voters. If you look at a map of the results, much of the south west and south has voted for the LibDems, which presumably means they reject the hard-line Conservative approach to issues such as immigration.

Reform is strong in what used to be "traditional" Labour areas and some coastal enclaves. I wonder if we'd end up with Conservatives in Labour areas and something else (LibDems or even a rightish Labour Party) in more affluent areas. It could mean that the parties swap their voters.

I haven't done the sums, but I wonder how many votes in total Reform and Conservatives received because that would give some indication of how successful a Conservative Party with a Reform agenda would be. The Conservatives lost votes to both Reform and LibDems, so they might need to look at how many votes they would receive if they headed towards a more "one nation" approach. The trouble with this last election is that there was so much tactical voting that it's difficult to know whether people really voted for the party they preferred.

I have no idea what they'll decide, but it will be interesting to watch.

Anniebach Sat 06-Jul-24 12:27:06

Jeremy Hunt is reported to hsve said he will not stand, SKYnews

Casdon Sat 06-Jul-24 12:11:32

That’s a big ask though I think M0nica. I feel sorry for him if that’s the expectation because he must be very bruised after the last few weeks. It would be much better if they appointed an interim leader from the last cabinet to carry them through the next couple of weeks until the recess at least. Maybe Jeremy Hunt, he’s a tough and experienced cookie, who could handle it.