Gransnet forums

News & politics

Vote once and never vote again

(108 Posts)
Macadia Sat 27-Jul-24 18:10:24

What a strange thing for Donald Trump to say at his Christian rally. He said if they vote for him, it will be fixed so they never vote again. Why would anyone vote for THAT ? Am I misunderstanding something here?

Macadia Tue 30-Jul-24 02:34:03

llizzie2

If he wins, it will because he has little vocabulary and his speeches are full of repetition and pausing to look for words.

This appeals to the ordinary Americans, who think Trump understands them because he is talking down to them.

His speeches are full of repetition because that is a marketing tactic commonly used; a rule of persuasion. You can look up this repetitive speech method. It has been used by dictators as well as in adverts.

llizzie2 Tue 30-Jul-24 01:39:43

If he wins, it will because he has little vocabulary and his speeches are full of repetition and pausing to look for words.

This appeals to the ordinary Americans, who think Trump understands them because he is talking down to them.

llizzie2 Tue 30-Jul-24 01:35:45

Is there of a Christian in Donald Trump? At his inaugural church service four years ago he was in the front pew and when the cross came into view in the procession of the cross, he leaned across and spoke to one of the clergy. In my life I have never seen a member of the congregation do such a thing.

Then when he lost the election to Biden, and the January 6 debacle took place, he stood and watched, waving the Holy Bible in his hand, taking the Lord's name in vain. 'Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord in vain is one of the Commandments which Moses gave to the people.

It was as though he was saying: ''Look, I have God in the palm of my hand''.

When he said that God saved his life, as unchristian as that might be, I wanted to shout :' The ruler of this world is Satan'. God helps us when we ask him for help and he deems it necessary. Trump seems to thing that whether he believes in Christ or not, God is following behind him to save his life because he is such a good soul. I don't think it works that way, but I may be wrong of course.

EEJit Mon 29-Jul-24 21:54:32

If he looses again this year, god help his blood pressure

MaggsMcG Mon 29-Jul-24 18:57:05

Voting for 16 year olds is ridiculous. Half of them aren't even allowed out of the house on their own. They are still referred to as children by most people. Hence the panic when they go walk about. More than half the 18 year olds didn't even bother to vote either.

Dickens Mon 29-Jul-24 17:48:08

PilgrimQuill

Trumps was addressing Christians at this rally. The sort of Christians who do not vote. The reason they do not vote is not because they have anything against democracy or are antagonistic in any way towards those who do vote, but because they have indeed cast their one vote already, when they accepted their Christian King. I think Trump may have got hold of this, twisted it to his own ends, declared that God saved him from being shot and therefore he will be in power by divine right or similar and that his rule will end all further ruling regimes because God is on his side. In other words, declaring that he is the Christian King.
He might have missed the bit in the Bible where God tells Nebuchadnezzar that the basest of men can be given a crown if it fits the ultimate plan ...
Most interesting, all of it...

I think your interpretation is probably nearer the mark - and Trump does sometimes speak in mysterious ways that presumably he believes his followers will understand.

I do wonder though how he reconciles God saving him from the would-be assassin's bullet with it hitting and killing one of his audience. Presumably that was also part of God's plan.

No matter (it seems) - As one American has it (according to the legend on his draped flag around his shoulders, "God is my Saviour, Trump is my President". Trump has now achieved cult-status. I think quite a few will see him as both Saviour and President, and American Christianity is on the path toward seriously right-wing theocratic authoritarianism.

PilgrimQuill Mon 29-Jul-24 16:52:40

Trumps was addressing Christians at this rally. The sort of Christians who do not vote. The reason they do not vote is not because they have anything against democracy or are antagonistic in any way towards those who do vote, but because they have indeed cast their one vote already, when they accepted their Christian King. I think Trump may have got hold of this, twisted it to his own ends, declared that God saved him from being shot and therefore he will be in power by divine right or similar and that his rule will end all further ruling regimes because God is on his side. In other words, declaring that he is the Christian King.
He might have missed the bit in the Bible where God tells Nebuchadnezzar that the basest of men can be given a crown if it fits the ultimate plan ...
Most interesting, all of it...

Chocolatelovinggran Mon 29-Jul-24 15:48:18

deanswaydolly- where are your children at school? Why is this establishment not adhering to the National Curriculum for PSHE?
I speak as a retired HT and school governor,
with a close group of friends who are current HT's so I do know that this a very strange interpretation of the Curriculum.
Are the Senior Leaders aware of this teaching? Are the governors?

Annma Mon 29-Jul-24 15:02:55

God help the world if this lying,cheating horrible man becomes President.

Mojack26 Mon 29-Jul-24 14:25:50

Trump IS the US version of Putin! I fear he will get another term in office though.

Milest0ne Mon 29-Jul-24 13:45:20

Last time I was in US some said “ I love your accent. Where are you from?” I said “ England” She said “where is that?”
Some Americans think the King rules UK , they can’t understand that he just reigns.

Wyllow3 Mon 29-Jul-24 13:43:10

A lot of the plans to change the democracy is of course in Project 25, which we know has close links with Republican leaders.

Trump is claiming he has nothing to do with it/has no knowledge of but issued the statement,

"“I have nothing to do with, and know nothing about, Project 25.

The fact that I do is merely disinformation put out by the Radical Left Democrat Thugs. Do not believe them!” DJT.

sandelf Mon 29-Jul-24 13:42:17

I don't think you are misunderstanding it at all. Classic Troskyism - once 'the party' achieves power, no further reference to the people is ever needed - as the right people are in power. Elections can be so awkward - Mr P knows all about the tedium of 'fixing' the vote.

suelld Mon 29-Jul-24 12:45:03

* Supreme Court

suelld Mon 29-Jul-24 12:44:18

paddyann54

He wants to be King of America and give his children the right to inherit the position.Why not?We still have that archaic system surely it’s good enough for the USA. Maybe he forgot the American war to rid themselves of monarchy. Someone should remind him

Our Monarchy don’t have much power to do anything other than be figureheads, the same with most Monarchys nowadays.
Trump intends to be President and remain there - which does come with POWER. He has already fixed the Sipreme Court to give him immunity for most things recently!
He would be a Nightmare! And with Global consequences! He’s an Isolationist! In policy and in his life…everything for HIM!

Norah Mon 29-Jul-24 12:43:40

The explanations are just weird.

Quote Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) said Sunday that President Trump was “obviously making a joke” when he urged Christian voters to vote for him in November and that, if they do, they “won’t have to vote anymore” because “everything” will be “fixed.”

“I think he’s obviously making a joke about how bad things had been under Joe Biden, and how good they’ll be if we send President Trump back to the White House so we can turn the country around,” Cotton said in an interview on CNN’s “State of the Union.”

“And that’s what the American people know,” he continued. “For four years, things were good with President Trump. We had stable prices, a growing economy, peace and stability around the world.”

Trump spoke at an event Friday hosted by the conservative Christian group Turning Point Action and urged Christians to vote for him in November.

“You won’t have to do it anymore. Four more years, you know what, it will be fixed, it will be fine, you won’t have to vote anymore, my beautiful Christians,” Trump said Friday.

Cossy Mon 29-Jul-24 12:35:46

deanswaydolly

Oh Dickens do you currently have school age children? I could write all day about the things they come home saying...including the 50 odd genders they are taught at 8 years old and that only white people are racist..
As my 9 year old grandchild said " well, that's my childhood ruined....I can never unknow that now"

I’m pretty much staggered by this as I have a daughter, still living at home, who is a Primary School teacher and last academic year taught year 3, 8&9 year old I believe, she certainly didn’t teach anything about 50 genders nor that only white people are racist. She was too busy following the national curriculum
and ensuring her pupils were reading and writing well, checking they’d eaten their lunches and running her after school club.

suelld Mon 29-Jul-24 12:34:15

Amalegra

Apparently, I have read, there are groups of Christians in the US who do not like to vote. In the ‘vote once’ speech he was appealing to them in the context of ‘electoral fraud’ which, existing or not, he claims he will ‘fix’. So dormant Republicans who do not vote will have no need to in the future as the system will be without fault. Just vote this time to fix all ills and the GOP, will consistently win every election! I don’t know about the fraud, I’m not a US citizen, but obviously this is the kind of naive rhetoric that every politician uses while campaigning, ours too. It’s a pity that this one, rather foolsh utterance, is being used to accuse Trump of wanting a dictatorship. I don’t like Trump but find the media in this country automatically biased against him, as they were/are about Reform. A shame, I thought grown up debate was a hallmark of a civilised society.

He said to all previously that he WOULD be “a Dictator on Day One” of his Presidency!
Don’t be taken in … the media likes the controversy , Trump sells papers/ makes news, but I don’t think that telling the TRUTH about him is being biased! As for debate…
He’s now backing out of debating Kamala Harris… he’s running scared!

suelld Mon 29-Jul-24 12:28:15

Macadia

What a strange thing for Donald Trump to say at his Christian rally. He said if they vote for him, it will be fixed so they never vote again. Why would anyone vote for THAT ? Am I misunderstanding something here?

I read that as a continuation of him staying in power and fixing things so he remains there like Putin!
But yes odd for him to say it out loud… probably inProject 2025 which he is backpeddling now denying knowing about it despite all his ally’s being involved and his VP pick Vance writing the foreword/ introduction/ preface.!!
He really wants to be ‘King’ , but more than that if he remains in power he can’t be tried in many of those criminal cases he faces! Horrible human!

Dickens Mon 29-Jul-24 12:10:10

deanswaydolly

Oh Dickens do you currently have school age children? I could write all day about the things they come home saying...including the 50 odd genders they are taught at 8 years old and that only white people are racist..
As my 9 year old grandchild said " well, that's my childhood ruined....I can never unknow that now"

Oh Dickens do you currently have school age children?

I have school age grandchildren.

The eldest, 16, is currently studying political science and is aiming to get 'into' politics as a career. He temporarily lives in South Africa but came over here on holiday for the election so that he could campaign for his chosen party.

The second eldest is 13, and currently studying Lego - and how and where to buy it as cheaply as possible, as he has plans to build himself a 'Lego' house. grin

PamQS Mon 29-Jul-24 12:09:28

I thought America was proud of being a democracy! Why should anyone think it was an advantage not to have to vote?

Maybe he thinks his supporters want him to rule America forever, and he said it to reach out to anyone who thinks that would be a good idea?

Applegran Mon 29-Jul-24 12:07:53

I have read that Trump has said he wants to be a dictator. Biden was right to say Trump is an existential threat to democracy.

Amalegra Mon 29-Jul-24 12:04:28

Apparently, I have read, there are groups of Christians in the US who do not like to vote. In the ‘vote once’ speech he was appealing to them in the context of ‘electoral fraud’ which, existing or not, he claims he will ‘fix’. So dormant Republicans who do not vote will have no need to in the future as the system will be without fault. Just vote this time to fix all ills and the GOP, will consistently win every election! I don’t know about the fraud, I’m not a US citizen, but obviously this is the kind of naive rhetoric that every politician uses while campaigning, ours too. It’s a pity that this one, rather foolsh utterance, is being used to accuse Trump of wanting a dictatorship. I don’t like Trump but find the media in this country automatically biased against him, as they were/are about Reform. A shame, I thought grown up debate was a hallmark of a civilised society.

muffinthemoo Mon 29-Jul-24 12:03:57

The guy talks absolute most of the time. He only looked less unhinged compared to poor Joe Biden who clearly has some sort of a cognitive issue.

Dickens Mon 29-Jul-24 12:03:10

Siope

I want to add something

Re Part A deductibles/excess costs. There are no limits to the number of benefit periods in a year. So if you were in hospital three times, for even two days each time, you’d pay close $5000 just for being there.

Thanks Siope for those informative posts on Medicare.

So if you were in hospital three times, for even two days each time, you’d pay close $5000 just for being there.

The layers of admin necessary to process all these co-pays, deductibles, extra costs, must be quite heavy - not least for the individual.

So what happens if, for example, someone's income is so low that it is accounted for the moment it arrives in the bank account and there is no $5000 that can be spared to cover these hospital admissions?

I think I now understand the collective 'American' attitude towards healthcare (obviously excluding those who don't subscribe to it) which is so different to ours here in the UK.

Chatting to an American work colleague many years ago whilst he was on a visit to the company I worked for, when this subject came up in conversation - he said that healthcare was a privilege not a right. Further discussion revealed he believed that if you couldn't afford it then, like any other commodity, you couldn't have it. And he thought that was quite fair. I think that is the difference in our cultures regarding healthcare, and why so many Americans are horrified at the concept of it being "socialised".

A couple of years before he was convicted of securities fraud, Martin Shkreli was the chief executive of a pharmaceutical company that acquired the rights to Daraprim, a lifesaving antiparasitic drug. Previously the drug cost $13.50 a pill, but in Shkreli’s hands, the price quickly increased by a factor of 56, to $750 a pill. At a health care conference, Shkreli told the audience that he should have raised the price even higher. “No one wants to say it, no one’s proud of it,” he explained. “But this is a capitalist society, a capitalist system and capitalist rules.”
(from an editorial in The New York Times)

(Martin Shkreli is an American investor and businessman. He was convicted of financial crimes for which he served over six years in federal prison and was fined over 70 million dollars.)
(from Wiki)

American Capitalism is pretty brutal.