Gransnet forums

News & politics

What has Labour done in the first 100 days?

(432 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Sat 12-Oct-24 06:07:39

A round-up - curtesy of the Guardian.

Economy
One of Rachel Reeves’s first actions as chancellor was to stand in front of the Commons and accuse the previous government of leaving a £22bn hole in this year’s public accounts. Every year, government spending diverges slightly from what was budgeted, but this was an unusually large amount, driven both by the higher-than-expected costs of housing asylum seekers and public sector pay deals.
Reeves’s solution to this was to put an immediate halt to various projects, including the road tunnel under Stonehenge and the A27 Arundel bypass. Boris Johnson’s promise to build 40 new hospitals has also been placed under review, with the prime minister, Keir Starmer, accusing his predecessor of making the promise without allocating the money.

Energy
When Michael Gove was asked at Tory conference to name the most effective Labour cabinet ministers so far, one of those he listed was Ed Miliband. The energy secretary has returned to a post he last held 14 years ago with a flurry of activity.
On 8 July, the first Monday after winning the election, Miliband announced he was removing the previous government’s de facto ban on onshore wind power. A day later, Reeves, unveiled the national wealth fund, a £7.3bn scheme designed to invest in green infrastructure such as clean steel and carbon capture.
Later that month, Miliband brought forward a bill to set up Great British Energy, a nationally owned energy production company that the government has put at the heart of its net zero strategy. The bill gives the company power to produce and distribute clean energy and spend money on energy efficiency schemes.
Keir Starmer announced in his Labour conference speech that GBE would be based in Aberdeen.

Transport
The first bill to pass the Commons under the Labour government was the rail nationalisation bill. The bill automatically brings rail networks back under public control once their existing franchise contract is over, or earlier if they breach their contracts.
The transport secretary, Louise Haigh, has also passed a bill to set up a new company called Great British Railways to manage both the track and the trains service. Some have questioned, however, why the rolling stock is not also being brought under national control.
Last month, Haigh reversed another piece of privatisation in the transport sector, allowing local authorities across England to run their own bus services once more. The transport secretary has also said she wants to make it simpler and easier for local leaders to conduct the franchising process.

Education
Labour has promised that it will introduce free breakfast clubs in every primary school in England, but it is starting slowly. Reeves announced at the Labour conference that 750 English schools would be invited to be part of a pilot programme.

Housing
Labour has promised to liberalise the planning regime and began soon after taking over government, not only overturning the restrictions on onshore wind power but also reimposing population-based housing targets on local authorities.
The Conservatives had given local planners a series of loopholes to avoid meeting those targets, in a move that housebuilders said had hampered new development, pushing housing approvals to a 10-year low.

Other reforms are planned, including making it easier for public bodies to issue compulsory purchasing orders and making it easier to build on green belt land.
Meanwhile, Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, has introduced a package of renters’ reforms, which passed their second reading in parliament this week, despite the objections of the Conservatives. That package picks up on some of the ambitions originally championed by Gove when he was housing secretary, including bringing an immediate end to no-fault evictions and forcing landlords to make timely repairs to properties.
Campaigners, however, are unhappy that the Labour government has so far not enacted another package of protections for leaseholders, whom they worry are slipping down the government’s agenda. The government has promised to bring in a bill to restrict leasehold and boost the rights of tenants, but has so far not even enacted the measures passed through parliament under the last government.

Employment
Starmer promised that his government would bring forward a package of workers’ rights in his first 100 days, a deadline which was just about met when Angela Rayner, his deputy, published the employment rights bill on Thursday.
Her reforms include giving workers protection from unfair dismissal and paternity leave rights from the first day of their employment, rather than having to wait two years. The bill also bans employers from forcing workers to sign zero-hours contracts and stops them firing staff only to hire them back on lower pay, unless the company is threatened with bankruptcy.
While the bill was published in the first 100 days it will take another two years for it to come into force. Officials and ministers will spend that time consulting businesses and trade unions about the exact measures involved and how to police them.
Some of the pre-election promises have not made it into the bill. There will be no statutory right for workers to switch off outside their working hours, and the government will now consult on having a single status of worker. Unions have long campaigned for a single worker status to replace the distinction between those who are employed and self-employed, in part to tackle exploitation in the gig economy.

Immigration
As promised, Labour has ended the previous government’s Rwanda scheme, which had not sent a single asylum seeker to Rwanda but was already costing the government money. Scrapping it saved more than £2bn over two years.
In its place, Starmer and his home secretary, Yvette Cooper, have introduced a border security command to focus on people-smuggling gangs. However, the prime minister is still trying to sign returns agreements with European countries, agreements that might mean Britain having to accept migrants in return.
Since the election, nearly 12,000 people have crossed the Channel in small boats, slightly fewer than in the same period last year.
Justice
A week after the election, the justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, announced an early release scheme that would see some offenders who had committed less serious crimes leave prison after serving 40% of their sentence. Mahmood blamed the prisons crisis she inherited from the previous government, which had left jails in England and Wales almost entirely full.
The early release scheme was controversial, but its purpose was underlined later in the summer as riots engulfed parts of the country. Speaking to journalists from the Downing Street garden after the riots had subsided, the prime minister described the decisions he had had to make while they were unfolding.
“I shouldn’t be sitting in the Cobra room with a list of prison places across the country on a day-by-day basis, trying to work out how we deal with disorder,” he said. “But that’s the position I was put in.”

Health
If Starmer is to show progress in one public service by the time he goes into the next election, it will have to be the NHS. His health secretary, Wes Streeting, commissioned Ara Darzi, a former Labour minister, to outline the scale of the challenge. Lord Darzi’s report, which was published last month, found that long delays for hospital, GP and mental health services were leading to thousands of unnecessary deaths.
Darzi suggested a range of changes, including focusing more on prevention and making companies pay “health levies” for things such as alcohol and tobacco.

Casdon Thu 17-Oct-24 18:18:06

There were plenty of childminders in the 1980s ronib, my sister was one of them. My own daughter was born in the late eighties, and I had no difficulty in finding an excellent nursery for her - bearing in mind I live in a rural area. There was also a work based nursery in the hospital where I worked at the time.

The world you describe where people can take years off work and return to a job of the same status has never existed, and I don’t think it ever will. I do resent your assumption that caring has disappeared from today’s society, because in my experience that is very far from the truth. Good parents are as good as they ever were, because quality of parenting is was counts the most.

Mollygo Thu 17-Oct-24 18:13:31

Allira
Sure Start was different in that it involved the whole family, I think.
My impression too, that it was to give family support, not a nursery where you left your children although undoubtedly some may have had different experiences.

Most of my experience with them is via school or was support for my grandsons with ASC.
That was certainly true where we live. The role is now filled by other family support centres.

ronib Thu 17-Oct-24 17:54:52

Casdon no not a return to the 1950s. Even in the 1980s it was impossible to rely on childminders or nurseries as the first didn’t exist and nurseries offered very limited hours. The only alternative was a nanny.
Given the cost of childcare, I realise that at least £14 per hour for 2 children is the going rate around here. A nanny is £40k plus?
As mentioned, men will take paternal leave to care for children too. It’s the caring word that seems to be missing from today’s society. The birth rate here is declining fast so that probably suits everyone on this thread.
I always thought that a progressive society would allow parents time to nurture their young with the opportunity to retrain and return to work once family life became manageable. That’s true equality in my eyes.

DiamondLily Thu 17-Oct-24 17:53:38

At 9 months, I think a known and trusted childminder is better than a nursery.

I always worked, but I was careful about childcare.

ronib Thu 17-Oct-24 17:38:12

Wwm2 I don’t believe that babies from 9 months should be looked after in an institutional setting with fairly random staff. Childminders working from their own homes are more easily identified and known to parents before starting a placement. It’s impossible to know in advance who will be caring for your child in a nursery and staff rotas change.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 17-Oct-24 17:35:21

Casdon

I think ronib is arguing for a return to 1950s parenting. Those children are now the Gransnetters generation, so perhaps we are to blame for overly liberal attitudes in bringing up our daughters to believe that they were equal to men and have the right to a career if they want one, because that means that the majority of them now don’t want to be stay at home mothers.

Ah! Back in time. What fun😏.

I couldn’t repeat what my AC would say about that idea!

MaizieD Thu 17-Oct-24 17:27:55

ronib

MaizieD so how do you rate Archimedes?

A great deal higher than I rate Bowlby.

Casdon Thu 17-Oct-24 17:27:14

I think ronib is arguing for a return to 1950s parenting. Those children are now the Gransnetters generation, so perhaps we are to blame for overly liberal attitudes in bringing up our daughters to believe that they were equal to men and have the right to a career if they want one, because that means that the majority of them now don’t want to be stay at home mothers.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 17-Oct-24 17:20:11

Nobody is forcing families into work. But the point is that we must all make a living one way or another, and that usually means working for a wage. The fact is that the cost of living for many is such that there is no alternative to both parents working.

The government is therefore responsible imo to ensure that children are cared for from the cradle.

What is wrong with attaching nurseries to primary schools? This has been happening for at least 20 years to my knowledge, although funding was certainly an issue over the past 14 years.

ronib Thu 17-Oct-24 16:56:34

Wwm2 As a young school girl, I spent time helping in the local orphanage run by nuns. The children were left in cots for long stretches of time and I remember trying to play with them. These children did not have a significant other as far as I remember. I have no idea how they fared.
If we had the mentally healthiest population, I would agree that we were getting socialisation right. But we aren’t. I genuinely believe that Labour’s policies could damage an already weakened society by forcing families into work when children are very young.
I am aware that different societies have different ways of bringing up children but it seems beyond crazy to say that small children don’t need firm emotional bonds with parents and the wider family and caring parental substitutes. I honestly worry that attaching nurseries onto schools might not be the best solution for very young children.

Allira Thu 17-Oct-24 16:52:08

Mollygo

Nurseries staffed by teachers- depends what/how the children are taught and whether they are aware of EYFS.
Parents often expect children to start more formal work early if they are at a school nursery.

My youngest went to a nursery attached to a primary school from age 3. It was excellent, the person in charge was a qualified primary school teacher, assisted by two nursery nurses. The sessions were 2.5 hours per day. Although it was our catchment area, it was 15 minutes away.
Wonderful for the children, but no use for anyone who might have wanted to work.

This was before EYFS. There was structure but they learnt through play. Every child was expected to be toilet trained back then, except for the couple of SEND children and in fact they were too.

Sure Start was different in that it involved the whole family, I think.

Casdon Thu 17-Oct-24 16:43:23

As you say, that’s your view though Oreo, not an evidenced fact. There are so many variables, but what I’m sure of is that for the children of neglectful parents, a good nursery can be their salvation, and that good parenting is as much about quality as it about quantity.

Galaxy Thu 17-Oct-24 16:42:43

I think it's a more complex picture, nurseries are frequently used as a way of safeguarding children, and can be very effective in this role. However currently there is a recruitment problem in early years, and retention issues. The hours in private nurseries are long and wages not great. It's understandable that staff do not stay in these roles.

ronib Thu 17-Oct-24 16:42:35

MaizieD so how do you rate Archimedes?

Oreo Thu 17-Oct-24 16:36:48

Galaxy

I work in early years and have done for the last ten years. Nurseries attached to schools are generally ok. Private nurseries frequently are not. I would say in many cases they are not the optimum care particularly for children under 3. This isnt a criticism of parents, (I returned to work when my first was 6 months old) it should be possible to have discussions about childrens early years and quality of provision without it being seen as a personal affront to those who use nurseries. Phrases such as dumping on strangers dont help to have this discussion either!

In my view there’s no substitute for a loving parent to take care of a young child until school age, particularly as school age is now only four years old.
I had to leave my twins somewhere for two mornings a week when they were three years old but if I hadn’t had to then I wouldn’t.
There are babies left in nurseries all week, and I shudder to think how often or not they are interacted with by disinterested staff.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 17-Oct-24 16:31:06

ronib

Wwm2 I think you are missing the point. I don’t think there’s much to be gained from talking about how brilliant our children are in their respective fields.
I notice you have avoided Bowlby and attachment theory.
The nursery was ofsted outstanding and dreadful.
I would like to point out that this country has a massive problem with mental health. I can only assume that it isn’t going to improve any time fast.

And 40 children?

I haven’t commented on Bowlby because you will be aware of the fact that he has been heavily criticised by other psychoanalysts- not least because he placed so much (sole) emphasis on the mother and completely failed to take other cultures and their childcare arrangements into account. Things have moved on since then so of course the nature/nurture issue was not addressed.

What evidence can you point to, to support your suggestion that the current mental health crises is related to the way children are cared for in early years at nursery?

Galaxy Thu 17-Oct-24 16:26:37

I work in early years and have done for the last ten years. Nurseries attached to schools are generally ok. Private nurseries frequently are not. I would say in many cases they are not the optimum care particularly for children under 3. This isnt a criticism of parents, (I returned to work when my first was 6 months old) it should be possible to have discussions about childrens early years and quality of provision without it being seen as a personal affront to those who use nurseries. Phrases such as dumping on strangers dont help to have this discussion either!

Iam64 Thu 17-Oct-24 16:25:45

ronib - where would you find 40 toddlers in one room with poorly trained staff?
I had a lot of contact with local authority nuerseries/family centres and never experienced that. My four younger grandchildren all went to private nursery before state nursery school at 3 years. Again, excellent care, named key worker. In Early Years it’s one adult for every three children under 2 years old.
One adult for every four children aged two. One adult for every 8 children aged 3 and over

MaizieD Thu 17-Oct-24 16:23:31

Bowlby?

70 year old theory informs current childcare practice?

Oreo Thu 17-Oct-24 16:18:14

ronib I agree that putting a toddler or young child in a big nursery can be a very scary thing for them, my twin DD’s shrieked and cried at nursery so I quickly found a very small one, with two carers in a normal house, and they loved that, there were four other kids aged 3 and they all seemed so happy and did all kinds of crafts.

ronib Thu 17-Oct-24 16:15:50

Wwm2 I think you are missing the point. I don’t think there’s much to be gained from talking about how brilliant our children are in their respective fields.
I notice you have avoided Bowlby and attachment theory.
The nursery was ofsted outstanding and dreadful.
I would like to point out that this country has a massive problem with mental health. I can only assume that it isn’t going to improve any time fast.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 17-Oct-24 16:03:16

If your grandson was in a room with 40 other toddlers, then the nursery should have been reported for breaking the law.

Didn’t they have an ofsted visit?

My DD would object very strongly to be called a “so-called” scientist. No-one else apart from a genetic engineer could do the work she does, neither could anyone not trained in environmental scientists deal with certain issues- unlike my son.

Are you sure you quite mean that dismissive sentence? Only it doesn’t sound terribly bright tbh.

ronib Thu 17-Oct-24 14:54:25

Whitewavemark2

ronib I suspect that the scientist expert in genetics and psychology etc know a great deal more than thee and me.

My GSs partner for one.

Wwm2 you have read Bowlby?
Of course as anyone knows science is a very faddish affair. I almost think that it’s designed to fit in with the social mores of the period.
I will always respect the rights of individuals over the theoretical sound bites of so called scientists.
FYI my grandson did not thrive at all in his first nursery school and was much more content with a homely carer. In fact I believe that putting a two year old in a room with 40 other children plus poor nursery staff is not the best idea. Of course rich parents can afford premium care.

Mollygo Thu 17-Oct-24 13:27:13

Nurseries staffed by teachers- depends what/how the children are taught and whether they are aware of EYFS.
Parents often expect children to start more formal work early if they are at a school nursery.

Wyllow3 Thu 17-Oct-24 13:25:52

Allira

It is good that there is choice now.

However, I either parent thinks it is important to stay at home with their children in the early years, I don't think they should be guilt-tripped into going to work if they can possibly afford not to.

How are parents being guilt tripped?

Yes if the family can afford it, its their choice.