Gransnet forums

News & politics

Ban on corporal punishment towards children

(129 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Sun 20-Oct-24 10:24:48

Smacking is a violent act - however you look at it.

Neither of my children and in turn my grandchildren have ever been smacked.

All kind, gentle and model citizens.

LizzieDrip Sun 20-Oct-24 10:22:09

Hear, hear WW. Couldn’t agree more👏👏👏

maddyfour Sun 20-Oct-24 10:21:38

I think it’s the right way to go, but I’m not naive enough to think that banning smacking will make any difference to cases such as the horrendous case of little Sara Sharif. We’ve heard about some particularly dreadful cases recently (lockdown?) but this case seems to be even worse. It’s already illegal to ‘beat’ children or babies Whitewave as it’s illegal to ‘beat’ anyone, and also animals. Sadly the law will never stop these sorts of crimes, but I still think smacking children should be illegal as it is illegal to hit anyone else.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 20-Oct-24 10:07:13

Ministers must ban smacking now, the children’s commissioner for England has said, in her strongest intervention yet on child safety.
Rachel de Souza said that banning smacking was “a necessary step” to keep children safe, and that bans in Scotland and Wales had “taught us we need to take that step in England too”, adding “now is the time to go further”.
The commissioner made her comments to the Observer after the start last week of the trial of three relatives for the murder of Sara Sharif, the 10-year-old who died after allegedly suffering two years of abuse by her father, stepmother and uncle.
The Scottish parliament made it illegal to use corporal punishment against children in November 2020, and the Welsh assembly introduced a similar ban, giving children equal protection to adults, in March 2022.

I absolutely approve of this. There isn’t a single person in the U.K. where corporal punishment is allowed - in fact it is a criminal offence - only babies and children can be beaten. How utterly inhumane!