Gransnet forums

News & politics

Governments First Budget

(565 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Wed 30-Oct-24 07:55:04

We won’t know too much until we can read tomorrows analysis , but we do know of this government’s intended direction of travel, and whether it meets with our expectations as voters and what we all voted for, which of course changes with each individual.

My vote and expectation was for

First and foremost to save our NHS and crumbling public services.

Second was to address the state of our environment, the polluted seas and rivers, and the lack of diversity.

Next -to address the fact that economic growth has been more or less stagnant since 2010. We need a Keynesian type budget for growth, that is imaginative and forward thinking to produce the revenue to invest in out country.

Personally I have never thought it possible to have this type of successful economy where citizens can be confident of a cradle to grave welfare state, where education is first class, health is free at the point of use and available within a very reasonable time limit, where public services are well run and invested in and care for all in need comes as a right, can be obtained by the tax payer on the cheap. This type of economy must be paid for and we will need to see tax at Scandinavian levels in order to achieve this.

Looking at the state the country is in, we knew in July that this would be a mighty task. Mighty tasks need research/planning and massive effort. They always start painfully slowly but momentum will gather as each year passes and we will gradually see the result of the effort put in to save our country from the ravages of 14 long years of economic blows our public services received.

Of course the right wing media - childlike - is insisting on jam today without spending any of their pocket money, but as wise parents we know that all jam does is rot your teeth. Instant gratification is only for the hard of thinking, the more intelligent know that time is the master.

So now looking back at the few short months Labour has been in government, i am pretty supportive of the direction of travel, and the achievements to date - which probably need listing to remind everyone - but not for this thread.

Some stuff has been announced but I think it best until we begin to see how it fits into the overall picture before we begin to comment.

It looks as if this is going to be a massive budget though - so hold onto your hats!

TakeThat7 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:15:19

I will not be able to buy it ever now and I've been homeless on the past because of a landlord who kicked everyone out so he could sell u he just changed the locks I'd been married at the time a few weeks and had a full time low paid job

Freya5 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:16:42

growstuff

Freya5

Allira

growstuff

Allira

Mollygo

Improving the life of my DGD will not immediately become apparent when her bus fare becomes £30pw. Easier if you live in an IGO area, but she doesn’t.

I was surprised that bus fares have to be paid for to attend FE College here; when I asked if DGD should get a pass, DS said no, they had enquired, even though the local schools have no sixth form.
Another expense for parents.

It's not just wherever you are. 16-18 year olds have to pay for transport everywhere.

Yet 16-18 year olds must remain in education or training.

Rather that than sat in their rooms on their ps5 or whatever, tik tok maybe !! Education and apprenticeships what is wrong with that.

It is compulsory to stay in some form of education until 18 these days. Even apprenticeships will involve some element of class based learning. In any case, many 16 year olds don't want the limitations of apprenticeships and aspire to Level 3 qualifications.

Yes I'm sure. A level 3 apprenticeship, also known as an advanced apprenticeship, a qualification combining academic study with on job training. Considered to be the equivalent to two A levels. So dont knock it. My Grandson qualified this way, and is now a highly paid Agricultural Mechanical Technician.
No limitations if there is aspiration.

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-24 19:20:35

I'm not knocking apprenticeships, but you seemed to be implying that apprenticeships were a way of not having to travel to college. Level 3 (and 4) apprenticeships are rightly valued, but they do involve travel to college, which has to be paid for. Apologies if I've misunderstood you.

Oldbat1 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:20:51

FriedGreenTomatoes2

I listened to Sunak's response to the budget and I have to say it was the best speech I've heard him make. He destroyed this Budget. Oh well, he’s yesterday’s man now.

You really rate his rant? Im honestly surprised as our household of 4 adults with different political views thought it very poor.

Shinamae Wed 30-Oct-24 19:23:58

Not being much of a political animal, I am pleased to hear that something is to be done about shoplifting.
Also the wild rumours about stopping the bus pass and stopping the single person supplement for one person in a house has not come to pass, another good thing
Finally, I am on minimum wage and have been for years as a carer in a care home so I am pleased to hear we are going to get a substantial rise.
All in all, I’m quite happy with it ..

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:29:42

Good to hear that from you Shinamae I’m glad to hear you’re happy with the Budget. Genuinely. You work hard and deserve some rewards.

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-24 19:30:27

TakeThat7

I will not be able to buy it ever now and I've been homeless on the past because of a landlord who kicked everyone out so he could sell u he just changed the locks I'd been married at the time a few weeks and had a full time low paid job

I do sympathise with your situation. I've actually experienced some of it myself.

I was once a high earner. I had a mortgage when I was 28 in my own name as a single person. In my 40s, my marriage broke down, I had a catastrophic mental breakdown and later a heart attack. I ended up losing my job and my house. I was homeless, unemployed and with two young children.

I experienced being evicted by a landlord who wasn't paying his own mortgage (even though I paid my rent) and tried to sue me for so-called damages (I won). I've now lived in a privately rented house for 10 years and will never again own my own home. Not being a home owner isn't the end of the world. If you have a council property, at least you have security of tenure.

I'm all for anything which increases the amount of housing available, especially for low earners, but Right to Buy isn't the right way.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:31:54

TakeThat7

I will not be able to buy it ever now and I've been homeless on the past because of a landlord who kicked everyone out so he could sell u he just changed the locks I'd been married at the time a few weeks and had a full time low paid job

I am sorry for your disappointment, but social housing should never have been offered for sale, and certainly not at a reduced value. In my opinion the cash raised from the sale should have been used for building further social housing but councils were prevented doing so by the Tory government. Thus laying the foundations for the appalling housing crises we are facing today.

I do strongly believe that affordable houses should be available to people on a limited budget, which I believe this government is working towards. But none of this can be achieved over night . Meanwhile they have made a start on trying to protect tenants by repealing no- fault evictions and other measures.

I do hope that you are eventually able to buy your own property, if that is your ambition. I have grandchildren with the same ambition. It isn’t easy is it?

Whitewavemark2 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:33:08

Oldbat1

FriedGreenTomatoes2

I listened to Sunak's response to the budget and I have to say it was the best speech I've heard him make. He destroyed this Budget. Oh well, he’s yesterday’s man now.

You really rate his rant? Im honestly surprised as our household of 4 adults with different political views thought it very poor.

He wasn’t trying very hard as he was de-mob happy.

Primrose53 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:36:15

TakeThat7

I'm talking about them stopping right to buy

This government doesn’t want aspirational people. They don’t want people being able to buy their own homes or make a lot of money through sheer hard work.

They want to keep them under the thumb and dependent on them for miserly handouts. I believe they will only be happy when we are living in grey concrete boxes and marching about in Lenin caps and drab clothes.

David49 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:38:10

3 of my grandsons have gone to a nearby Agricultural College between 17&18 as residential students -it’s too far to travel. They do many rural based courses, students have work experience during that time, it’s a good grounding for all things rural, a very popular college. Lodging has to be paid for but tuition is free.

It’s not really an apprenticeship, some go on to university, others find work in their chosen field and qualify on the job.

Casdon Wed 30-Oct-24 19:40:19

That is errant nonsense Primrose53. The government wants more people to have access to affordable housing for rental. Do you not realise how many homeless and inadequately housed families there are?Reducing the subsidy on buying council houses is part of the way that will be achieved. People will still be able to get a discounted rate if they choose to buy, just not a giveaway.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:41:11

And for Scotland?
This just now in the Telegraph:

Alan Cochrane
30 October 2024 6:56pm GMT

There was a significant, if largely, unspoken sub-plot to Rachel Reeves’s Budget on Wednesday – but it was one that demonstrated how much the Labour Government is growing tired of the effects of one of the principal supposed “benefits” of devolution.

This is, of course, the fact that in spite of its record-breaking victory in the July 4 general election, much of what goes on in one part of the United Kingdom – Scotland – is out of its control.

However, it was clear from a number of Commons exchanges on Wednesday that Sir Keir Starmer is ready to increase its pressure on the SNP Government in Edinburgh and, if necessary, bypass it altogether to get a better deal for Scotland.

Central to this looming battle is the NHS, which the SNP runs – lock, stock and operating theatre – under the terms of the devolution settlement.

However, as has long been the case, this product of the likes of Gordon Brown and Tony Blair has taken on the aspect of an open sore ever since the SNP, under Alex Salmond, formed the Scottish government in 2007.

Hardly a day passes without furious complaints about how badly the NHS is being run and how run down its facilities in Scotland are – but as it is not in government in the country, there is precious little that Labour can do about the situation, except complain.

Greyisnotmycolour Wed 30-Oct-24 19:42:32

TakeThat7

I'm very pleased about the change to right to buy. You now have a permanent roof over your head, why would you want to deprived others of that benefit? There is nothing to stop you from buying any other property on the open market. If you are paying a substantially reduced rent, compared to the private rental market, it will allow you to save. Buying social housing property is an incredibly selfish thing to do. Since Thatcher introduced that policy, houses lost to buyers have not been replaced resulting in the current housing crisis.

MayBee70 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:42:42

Primrose53

TakeThat7

I'm talking about them stopping right to buy

This government doesn’t want aspirational people. They don’t want people being able to buy their own homes or make a lot of money through sheer hard work.

They want to keep them under the thumb and dependent on them for miserly handouts. I believe they will only be happy when we are living in grey concrete boxes and marching about in Lenin caps and drab clothes.

If they don’t want people to be aspirational how come they’re putting so much money into the state schools that the Conservative government neglected for 14 years?

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:42:56

Cont.

clear from the words of both Sir Keir and Rachel Reeves that their patience with the poor performance of the SNP – at the expense of Scottish voters – is wearing thin.

The SNP will be hard-pressed to claim austerity in the wake of the Chancellor pointing out that the extra cash she plans to spend on public services in England and Wales will result in a £3.4 billion handout for Scotland under the Barnett formula, which allocates cash to the other parts of the UK.

In announcing this not inconsiderable sum, which she said was the largest ever in real terms dished out to Scotland, she added that it “must” be spent on improving public services like the NHS.

Casdon Wed 30-Oct-24 19:45:23

Alan Cochrane, the Scottish editor of the Daily Telegraph. Pearls of wisdom fall daily from his lips.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:45:55

What the budget means for personal finances.

1. State pensions will go up by 4.1%
The chancellor confirmed that the triple lock on pensions will mean a 4.1% increase from April next year – increasing the full new state pension from £221.20 to £230.25 a week, or by £470.60 a year.

The standard minimum guarantee for single pensioners will go up from £218.15 a week in 2024-25 to £227.10. That means that those earning less than £11,809 a year will be eligible for pension credit. This is all the more important now universal winter fuel allowance has been scrapped and will only be paid to those on pension credit.

2. Other benefits will rise, too
Some of the other state benefits are linked to inflation – and the recent drop in the headline figure for the cost of living mean in April they will increase by just 1.7%.

Universal credit is the biggest. The standard allowance for a single person aged 25 or over is currently £393.45 a month – it will rise by £6.69. For a couple aged over 25 it will go up by £10.50 from £617.60.

Other inflation-linked benefits, such as child benefit, will go up by the same amount. For child benefit, that should take the rate for the first child up from £25.60 to £26 a week, and the rate for additional children from £16.95 to about £17.20 each. However, the government said it had scrapped plans to base the clawback of child benefit on household, rather than individual, incomes.

Carer’s allowance, which the Guardian has campaigned for an overhaul, will go up by £1.39 a week from £81.90. At the same time the earnings limit – the amount that carers can earn up to and still claim the benefit – will go up by £45.

3. Fiscal drag will end on incomes, but not inheritances
Thresholds for income tax were frozen in April 2021, and the previous government said they would stay the same until April 2028. There had been speculation that Reeves would extend that for two years, but she announced she had decided against it. From April 2028 the thresholds will rise in line with inflation.

Freezing tax thresholds leads to fiscal drag. If you get a pay rise, for example, more of your extra earnings fall into a higher tax band than would have been the case had the thresholds risen in line with inflation. You still have more money in your pocket, but not as much as you might have expected. Unfreezing the thresholds will mean you keep more of any rise.

The main inheritance tax (IHT) threshold has been frozen at £325,000 since April 2009, although an additional residence nil rate band was added in 2017. Reeves announced she would continue a freeze on the thresholds from 2028 already announced by the previous government to 2030. Rising house prices mean more estates are likely to face IHT as a result of this, although just 6% paid it this year, so it will remain a minority concern.

4. Pensions will attract inheritance tax
Several types of asset are free from IHT meaning they can be left without the beneficiaries paying a penny. The chancellor closed some of the loopholes – typically only used by wealthy.

Currently you can leave your unspent pension fund to anyone without them paying IHT. From April 2027 this will change. You will still be able to leave the money to a spouse or civil partner without them paying the tax – there’s no limit on how much you can leave them – but if you leave it to someone else, they may need to pay. IHT is 40% on anything over the £325,000 threshold.

Agricultural land and business property can also currently be left without an IHT bill. That will start to change in April 2026, although there will be an allowance to pass on up to £1m worth of these assets tax-free.

5. Stamp duty on second homes will rise
People who want to buy a second home will be hit with additional stamp duty charges in a move the government claims will benefit first-time buyers.

From 31 October the higher rates for additional dwellings (HRAD) surcharge will go up from 3% to 5% – it is paid by anyone who already owns a home and is charged on top of the main stamp duty rate. On a property costing £300,000, it means an extra £6,000 in tax.
It could result in a reduction in demand from second-home buyers and investors – Reeves said that over five years it would result in another 130,000 property transactions for first-time buyers and people buying a primary home.

6. Capital gains tax on shares will rise
The tax charged on gains from shares has gone up, with immediate effect. For investors whose income is taxed at 40%, the capital gains tax (CGT) they may pay on shares has increased from 20% to 24%. For basic-rate (20%) taxpayers, the rate has gone up from 10% to 18%.

This brings it in line with the rate that would be charged on profits from an investment property.

However, you can still make a gain of £3,000 a year before paying the tax, and the Isa investment limit has been left at £20,000 a year until 2030, so many small investors will not pay CGT.

7. The minimum wage is rising
Low earners are to get a pay rise in April as the “national minimum wage” is increased by 6.7%. After the rise employers will need to pay workers aged 21 and over at least £12.21 an hour. This will move the minimum annual salary for working a 35-hour week from £20,820.80 to £22,222.20 – an increase of just over £1,400.

Workers aged 18 to 20 will see their wages go from £8.60 to £10 an hour, giving them an extra £2,500 if they work full-time. Apprentices and under-18s will get a £1.15 an hour increase, taking them to £7.55.

The minimum hourly wage for an apprentice is also increased next year, with an 18-year-old apprentice in an industry such as construction seeing their minimum hourly pay increase by 18.0%, a pay bump from £6.40 to £7.55 an hour. 

These figures are all before tax, and the freezing of personal allowances means that workers will pay more income tax than if their those allowances had moved up in line with inflation. They will, however, still be better off as a result.

As well as take-home pay, the rise in the minimum wage also has an impact on pension contributions, as they are linked to earnings. The pensions firm Aegon says a worker earning £12.21 an hour who is auto-enrolled into a workplace pension will benefit from a total annual pension contribution of £1,278 a year, made up of their own and their employer’s pension contributions – £112 more than this year.

8. Tax on petrol won’t go up
In a surprise move, Reeves announced that the freeze on fuel duty would remain – had it not, she said the cost of petrol would have gone up by 7p a litre. For a Ford Focus with a 55-litre tank, that means the cost of filling up is £3.85 less than had the change been made.

paddyann54 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:56:29

That’s a 3.4 billion “grant” when they have dropped our budget by 6BILLION …of our own money The Barnett formula is not a GRANT it’s a small portion of the money we hand over to WM every year .It has always been this way.WM coins it in from Scotland ..hundreds of billions from OIL in the past 40 years now they,ve got their thriving mitts on our energy ,over one billion pounds worth A DAY to be transferred to England by 2030 !!Yet we pay more here for the energy we supply .
Please check FACTS fried green tomatoes media propaganda isn,t true .THE Scottish NHS is the best performing of the 4 nations our alcohol deaths while unacceptably high at 610 per 100000 is lower than Englands at 660 per 100,000 and as for other issues with WM banning us from making changes to drug law or even something simple like glass recycling …we can’t get our system up and running because WM haven,t got theirs in place.
We,re not second class citizens we,re a colony …in all but name!!

Rosie51 Wed 30-Oct-24 19:58:05

Greyisnotmycolour

TakeThat7

I'm very pleased about the change to right to buy. You now have a permanent roof over your head, why would you want to deprived others of that benefit? There is nothing to stop you from buying any other property on the open market. If you are paying a substantially reduced rent, compared to the private rental market, it will allow you to save. Buying social housing property is an incredibly selfish thing to do. Since Thatcher introduced that policy, houses lost to buyers have not been replaced resulting in the current housing crisis.

While you're berating TakeThat7 any comment on those like Angela Rayner who bought a council house in the past? Would you tell her she is an incredibly selfish person?

Whitewavemark2 Wed 30-Oct-24 20:01:31

Key points in Budget

National insurance
Employees will not pay more directly, Reeves says, but she will raise employers’ national insurance contributions by 1.2 percentage points to 15% from April 2025.
The government will also reduce a secondary threshold when contributions are due from £9,100 to £5,000.
Those measures will raise £25bn a year by the end of the forecast period, the biggest single tax raising measure in the budget.

Income tax
Reeves says the government will increase personal tax thresholds on income tax and national insurance in line with inflation from 2028-29, something that had been floated as a possibility. This avoids dragging people into higher tax bands.

Capital gains and inheritance tax
Capital gains tax will be increased. The lower rate will be raised from 10% to 18%, and the higher rate from 20% to 24%. There will, however, be no increase on the 18% and 24% capital gains rate imposed on the sale second homes.
The government will extend a freeze on the threshold for inheritance tax to 2030, allowing £325,000 to be inherited tax free. From 2027 inherited pension pots will also be subject to the tax.
Reliefs will be reformed for business and agricultural assets. After £1m, those assets will attract inheritance tax of 20%.

The minimum wage
Reeves confirms that the “national living wage”, the legal minimum for over-21s, will increase by 6.7% to £12.21, equivalent to £1,400 a year for an eligible full-time worker.
There will be a single-adult rate phased in over time to eventually equalise pay for under-21s.

Tobacco and alcohol
The government will implement a levy on vapes, which will be increased in line with tobacco.
Tobacco taxes will rise by 2% above retail prices index (RPI) measure of inflation for the rest of this parliament, and tax on hand-rolling tobacco will increase by 10%.
Taxes on alcohol will rise in line with the RPI, but Reeves announces a cut in draught duty by 1.7%, which she says is a penny off a pint in the pub.

Fuel duty
Reeves says increasing fuel duty next year would be wrong, so she extends the freeze for a year and maintains the last government’s 5p cut.
Fuel duty was frozen between 2011 and 2022, and cut by 5p in March 2022 after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

Private school fees
VAT will be brought in on private school fees from January 2025.

Schools and education
Reeves says the Department for Education will receive £6.7bn of capital investment, a 19% real-terms increase. That includes £1.4bn to rebuild more than 500 schools in the greatest need.
The schools budget will increase by £2.3bn to support the hiring of teachers.
There will be £2.1bn for school maintenance, a £300m increase.
Reeves announces a £1bn increase in funding for special educational needs.
There will be another £300m for higher education.

NHS
Reeves promises a 10-year plan for the NHS in the spring, targeting 2% productivity growth next year.
She announces a £22.6bn increase in the day-to-day health budget, and £3.1bn increase in the capital budget. That includes £1bn for repairs and upgrades, and £1.5bn for new beds in hospitals and testing capacity.

Housing
The government will spend £5bn on housing investment in 2025-26, including increasing the supply of affordable housing.
The government will reduce right-to-buy discounts, and local governments will retain the earnings from council housing sales to allow them to reinvest.
The government will hire “hundreds of new planning officers” to accelerate housebuilding.

Transport
Reeves commits to the Transpennine Route Upgrade, improving capacity at Manchester Victoria and electrifying the Wigan to Bolton route. She also promises to support east-west rail links between Oxford and Cambridge.
Reeves confirms the government will fund tunnelling of HS2 to London Euston.
There will be a £500m increase in the roads budget next year to target potholes.

Energy
Reeves announces £3.4bn for the warm homes plan to upgrade buildings, lowering energy bills.
The government will fund Great British Energy, a new body to be based in Aberdeen.
Public spending
There will be a 1.5% increase in real spending on government departments, and 1.7% when including capital spending.
Defence
Reeves announces a £2.9bn increase in military spending next year, as well as funding for second world war commemorations next year.
Local government
There will be £1.3bn for additional grant funding for local government, including £600m for social care.
Greater Manchester and the West Midlands will get integrated settlements next year, allowing them to take more control of their spending.

Public investment
Reeves says more public investment is needed in the UK. A new rule will target debt falling as a share of the economy. She confirms that debt will be measured as public sector net financial liabilities, recognising benefits from investments.
The rule will apply in 2029-30, and then net financial debt will fall by the third year of every forecast.
There will be regular reports on government investments from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR).
She says the government will invest £1bn in aerospace, £2bn in automotive to support electric vehicles, and £500m for life sciences.
Government research and development spending will reach £20.4bn in 2025-26, including £6.1bn in sectors such as engineering, biotechnology and medical science.

Planes and private jets
Air passenger duty will increase by up to £2 for each economy short-haul flight, Reeves says.
Private jets will attract an extra 50% air passenger duty, up to £450 per passenger for a flight.

Business taxes and non-doms
The government will introduce permanently lower business rates for retail, hospitality and leisure businesses from 2026-27. Until then they will receive 40% relief on business rates up to a cap of £110,000.
Employment allowance will be increased from £5,000 to £10,500, reducing national insurance for smaller businesses.
Taxes on carried interest, generally paid by private equity managers, will rise from 28% to 32% from April.
Reeves confirms the oil profits levy will be increased to 38% and extended.
The concept of non-domicile residents will be abolished from April.
Compensation schemes
Reeves says the government will compensate victims of the infected blood scandal with £11.8bn, and there will be another £1.8bn for victims of the Post Office Horizon IT scandal.

Other measures
Reeves says the government will raise £6.5bn through targeting tax avoidance, including by umbrella companies.
OBR
Reeves says Labour inherited a £22bn “black hole” with allegedly unfunded pledges by the Conservative government.
The OBR, the government’s budget watchdog, has published a review saying that the previous government did not disclose details of spending. Those details would have made forecasts materially different, Reeves says.
Reeves says the government will implement 10 recommendations from the OBR’s review.

nflation and growth forecasts
The chancellor will maintain the Bank of England’s 2% target for inflation.
Inflation will average 2.5% in 2024, rising to 2.6% in 2025, before gradually dropping to 2% in 2029, according to OBR forecasts. Inflation was at 1.7% in September, below the Bank of England’s 2% target, and down from 11% in October 2022.
The OBR slightly upgrades its growth forecast for this year and next, but adjusts them down in later years. GDP growth is forecast to be 1.1% in 2024, then 2%, 1.8%, 1.5%, 1.5%, and 1.6% in 2030, Reeves says. At the spring budget under the then Conservative chancellor Jeremy Hunt the OBR had forecast 0.8% growth this year, 1.9% in 2025, and 2% in 2026.

Government borrowing
Reeves announces new rules to not borrow for day-to-day spending. The current budget will be balanced within three years of forecasts.
The government will run a deficit of £26.2bn in 2026, but will achieve a surplus of £10.9bn in 2027-28, £9.3bn in 2028-29 and £9.9bn in 2029-30.
Public sector net debt will fall from £127bn in 2024-25, falling gradually to £70.6bn by 2029-20.”

This was a massive amount to take in, and I think that it will take a few days for the full details and implications to emerge.

Casdon Wed 30-Oct-24 20:03:18

Angela Rayner bought her council house before the heavily discounted rate was introduced. People will still be able to buy their council houses under similar terms to hers.

Shinamae Wed 30-Oct-24 20:11:16

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Good to hear that from you Shinamae I’m glad to hear you’re happy with the Budget. Genuinely. You work hard and deserve some rewards.

Very kind, thank you so much 🦋

Rosie51 Wed 30-Oct-24 20:11:38

Casdon

Angela Rayner bought her council house before the heavily discounted rate was introduced. People will still be able to buy their council houses under similar terms to hers.

I don't dispute that Casdon, but Greyisnotmycolour, has called TakeThat7 incredibly selfish for wanting to buy her council house. Discounts aside, the taking a council house out of public ownership is exactly the same.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 30-Oct-24 20:15:13

Imo council housing should remain exactly that. I also think that the rent charged should reflect people’s ability to pay. It may do so I don’t actually know how the poorest are assisted?