Gransnet forums

News & politics

Musk’s salute.

(248 Posts)
Nandalot Mon 20-Jan-25 22:27:59

I found this very disturbing, especially the look on his face with the first one.

escaped Tue 21-Jan-25 10:43:01

And during the French Revolution. I think there are some famous French Neo Classical paintings where they all raise their arms when oaths are signed.

Allira Tue 21-Jan-25 10:34:11

Whitewavemark2

It was a Roman salute

Saluto Romano

Wasn't that adopted by the Fascists in Italy then Germany (each slightly modified?).

Allira Tue 21-Jan-25 10:31:53

Whitewavemark2

It was a Roman salute

Hail to the Emperor!!

Allira Tue 21-Jan-25 10:31:11

mae13

And Musk needs to brush up on world history: America planted the flag on the moon in 1969, and is that not a planet?
Tough Musky, Neil Armstrong beat you to it.

No, the moon is a moon not a planet.
A moon is a satellite of a planet.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 21-Jan-25 10:30:38

It was a Roman salute

Allira Tue 21-Jan-25 10:28:43

escaped

And who calls a waiter with their arm aloft?
How rude.

You just put your hand up slightly and try to catch their eye with an expectant look on your face!

Now, are we to believe that Musk was
a) a bit peckish and wanted to order a hamburger
b) thirsty ' watercplease
or
c) had had enough and was hailing a taxi

No. It looked more like his version of Hail to the Chief.

Cossy Tue 21-Jan-25 09:48:29

Louella12

Oh dear. I'm finding it hard to believe that anyone would say this was a Nazi salute.

He is indeed, a very unusual character. But please, don't be so predictable. The left do open themselves up to ridicule.

Goodness! What a strange comment!

escaped Tue 21-Jan-25 09:36:03

And who calls a waiter with their arm aloft?
How rude.

Rosie51 Tue 21-Jan-25 09:32:08

Parsley3

A visual aid for anyone who is prone to making unwise hand gestures.

www.google.com/search?sca_esv=508060710feda40c&q=hailing+a+taxi&udm=2&fbs=AEQNm0Aa4sjWe7Rqy32pFwRj0UkWd8nbOJfsBGGB5IQQO6L3JyJJclJuzBPl12qJyPx7ESJehObpS5jg6J88CCM-

Some google images of people hailing taxis. Sorry Parsley3 that image is just silly.

Musk's salute however is not, that's very concerning.

escaped Tue 21-Jan-25 09:19:04

Parsley3

A visual aid for anyone who is prone to making unwise hand gestures.

That visual aid isn't totally correct. I'm a Londoner, and we hail taxis with our arms raised both high and horizontally.

foxie48 Tue 21-Jan-25 09:08:44

I've been listening to the rest is history series on Hitler, so many parallels with politics in the US. It's very worrying and Musk's support of far right parties in Europe is only part of it.

Parsley3 Tue 21-Jan-25 09:07:04

A visual aid for anyone who is prone to making unwise hand gestures.

Cossy Tue 21-Jan-25 08:45:25

Whitewavemark2

He supports the AfD a Nazi political party.

So the salute is neither surprising nor innocent.

Musk could be very dangerous if he isn’t reigned in.

Sadly I agree. The richest man on the planet linked up to the POTUS, is dangerous on its own, but when the POTUS is Trump, scary beyond belief!

Grandmafrench Tue 21-Jan-25 08:45:04

Galaxy

I sort of agree Dickens, but it was bizarre.
I think he is not neurotypical, but obviously am diagnosing a stranger on the internet which is not acceptable!

He makes no secret of the fact that he’s on the spectrum and has, in the past, discussed his Asperger’s. It’s therefore likely that some of his social actions/reactions are going to appear ‘bizarre’, to put it mildly!

ViceVersa Tue 21-Jan-25 08:30:45

I agree. He knew exactly what he was doing. Anyone who has been on Twitter (X) for any length of time will have seen his tweets and know.

keepingquiet Tue 21-Jan-25 08:06:27

Louella12

Oh dear. I'm finding it hard to believe that anyone would say this was a Nazi salute.

He is indeed, a very unusual character. But please, don't be so predictable. The left do open themselves up to ridicule.

You need to believe it- it was deliberate and repeated more than once.

An 'unusual character' well, so are many people. If someone walked down your street doing this would you think they were unusual?

Why is recognising this for what it is predictable?

Why does recognising this make you from the left, and therefore ridiculous?

Please don't defend the indefencible.

Casdon Tue 21-Jan-25 07:56:53

I tend to give credit to reports on mainstream media, rather than a personal opinion from somebody who clearly didn’t watch the immediate reactions of the news anchors in USA Louella12. The world knows what he meant.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 21-Jan-25 07:52:12

Louella12

Oh dear. I'm finding it hard to believe that anyone would say this was a Nazi salute.

He is indeed, a very unusual character. But please, don't be so predictable. The left do open themselves up to ridicule.

If you can deny Musks support of the AfD, and Austrias Freedom Party, then I think your post can be taken seriously, but until then, people will be sensible to distrust Musk and his actions.

Louella12 Tue 21-Jan-25 07:44:59

Oh dear. I'm finding it hard to believe that anyone would say this was a Nazi salute.

He is indeed, a very unusual character. But please, don't be so predictable. The left do open themselves up to ridicule.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 21-Jan-25 07:39:20

Oops no picture of a frog either.

I assume he changes his profile when the mood takes him.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 21-Jan-25 07:38:20

imaround

From the article Wyllow3 posted:

"On top of that, Musk also recently signaled further support for the far-right when he changed his X username to “Kekius Maximus” and updated his profile to an edited picture of “Pepe the Frog,” a meme that had been co-opted by the alt-right and white supremacists in online spaces such as 4chan. And just a week ago, Musk — who has relentlessly promoted imprisoned far-right extremist Tommy Robinson while injecting himself into British politics — criticized the prison sentencing of a neo-Nazi who helped incited riots in the UK."

When someone tells you who they are, believe them.

Elon Musk is on X as

ElonMusk@elonmusk

I have just checked on X

Babs03 Tue 21-Jan-25 06:10:21

Well if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck……..
I think we all know what we have seen here.

Allsorts Tue 21-Jan-25 05:34:25

If you look at his eyes he is manic, he literally thrives on conflict. It would be interesting to know if he has
had any long term relationships. He will have a book in him when it goes pear shaped with Trump, two big ego’s.

escaped Tue 21-Jan-25 05:30:47

I'm not at all comfortable with this.

mae13 Tue 21-Jan-25 05:21:53

And Musk needs to brush up on world history: America planted the flag on the moon in 1969, and is that not a planet?
Tough Musky, Neil Armstrong beat you to it.