Gransnet forums

News & politics

Trump and Vance attack womens health rights

(111 Posts)
Wyllow3 Sat 25-Jan-25 11:12:49

Trump and Vance backed anti-abortion activists in March for Life speeches yesterday.
There was a rally yesterday in Washington, it was the annual March for Life rally and the first chance to see what intentions as regards womens health are now the election is over.

Two points of interest: Firstly, there has been a Federal Act in place, the federal Free Access to Clinic Entrances Act, which

penalizes people who threaten, obstruct or injure someone who is trying to access a reproductive health clinic – or who vandalize a clinic.

Trupp/Vance are pardoning all those convicted under the act,
Trump dramatically declaring they were realising the "persecuted".

Secondly concerns about access to abortions and related aspects of womens health, including criminalising abortion. We know already its only possible in certain states

But there are changes which are not so obvious Mike Johnson, (house speaker) "did win big cheers from the marchers, though, when he mentioned a recent executive order that declared that people are divided into male and female “at conception”.

That language evokes the doctrine of fetal personhood, which holds that embryos and fetuses should be granted full legal rights and protections – and which, if fully enacted, would totally outlaw abortion as well as potentially criminalize abortion patients

Most of the marchers feel there should be no exceptions - ie no abortions at all - except for ectopic pregnancy.

"Human life starts at conception,” said Henry Cooper, an 18-year-old march attender from California. “An abortion is never medically necessary. Ectopic pregnancy is something else. That’s not considered an abortion. There’s always something you can do.”

“Besides ectopic pregnancies, there are no cases where abortion improves the likelihood of the mother surviving other than a non-abortion way would,” agreed Luc Lessard, 18, of Colorado. “There’s no real cause for it.”This is just ignorance.

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the pre-eminent membership organization for US ob-gyns, has repeatedly emphasized the medical need for abortion access. At least five women have reportedly died after abortion bans affected their medical care.

As of January 8, 2025, 12 states have banned abortion Alabama, Arkansas, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, and West Virginia.

Here is a state by state summary of restrictions. You'll see it's very widespread, complex, and punitive.

www.context.news/money-power-people/roe-v-wade-which-us-states-are-banning-abortion#

(Quotes on abortion rally from the Guardian)

imaround Tue 28-Jan-25 02:13:41

It is scary Dickens. And completely unfathomable to me that my children will have less rights then I did at their age.

Dickens Tue 28-Jan-25 01:51:13

You are right imaround...

It isn't just about abortion. It is about the rights of women. Abortion is just where it starts.

There are men, in other cultures, who also want to control women, deny them an education, keep them in the home to breed babies, silence their voices...

I hope the women who voted for the pussy-grabber are going to be happy when these red-blooded all-American alpha-males begin to wield power over their lives, and the lives of their daughters and grand daughters. And make America great again.

Dickens Tue 28-Jan-25 01:39:31

imaround

Trump himself has said he is proud to be responsible for sitting the judges that overturned Roe vs Wade.

www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trump-was-able-kill-roe-v-wade-rcna84897

Pregnant women who do not want abortions are dying because they can't get medical care when their pregnancies turn out to have complications.

The new alcoholic Fox News host who is charge of our military has gone on record saying he doesn't believe women should be in combat. He has paid tens of thousands of dollars to women who have accused him of sexual assault

An DeSantis appointee to a University in Florida has stated that he doesn't believe women should be getting higher education.

There are whispers from down ballot GOP and Trump appointees who wish to see the 19th Amendment overturned. While this is not happening right now, it gives you an idea of what is happening for women in the US.

Trumps overturning of the EEOC will slowly allow discrimination against women to seep back to the 1950s

It isn't just about abortion. It is about the rights of women. Abortion is just where it starts.

An DeSantis appointee to a University in Florida has stated that he doesn't believe women should be getting higher education.

... from Wiki...

Scott Yenor is a member of the Society for American Civic Renewal, a secretive, men-only Christian nationalist organization.

Yenor's anti-feminist rhetoric has been the source of controversy.[3] In a speech at the 2021 National Conservatism Conference, Yenor declared: "If we want a great nation, we should be preparing young women to become mothers ... Every effort must be made not to recruit women into" medicine, law, engineering and "every trade", instead "recruit and demand more of men" in these occupations; Yenor went on: "If every Nobel Prize winner is a man, that’s not a failure. It’s kind of a cause for celebration". Yenor referred to career-oriented women as "medicated, meddlesome and quarrelsome". He said that higher educational institutions were undermining the traditional family, declaring them "citadels of our gynecocracy".

Yenor anonymously founded the far-right website Action Idaho in 2021. The platform published commentary critical of Idaho Republicans deemed insufficiently right-wing and hateful disinformation related to LGBTQ+ groups. Yenor received funding for the endeavor from Claremont Institute chairman Thomas Klingenstein. His authorship of the website was uncovered in 2024.
--------------

Trump has opened Pandora's box. Perhaps Gilead wasn't so far-fetched after all.

nanna8 Mon 27-Jan-25 22:21:56

I don’t agree with demos against abortions at the clinics. Those women have enough stress without having that to look at on their way in. Broadly I don’t like abortions and would never have had one but there are many, many different reasons for them and that should be respected. Late term abortions are murder,though, as far as I’m concerned.

Galaxy Mon 27-Jan-25 22:16:23

I dont know what I feel about that to be honest, I think I am in agreement with buffer zones, but I know a number of people scared to go to parts of London when the marches are on, they feel intimidated and pressured, what do we do about that.

Casdon Mon 27-Jan-25 22:12:19

It’s not fine in my eyes for people to stand outside abortion clinics protesting and putting pressure on clients and staff.

Galaxy Mon 27-Jan-25 22:07:07

It is fine to have demos about abortions, the alternative is something I would find really scary. There are many different ways to limit freedom.

Wyllow3 Mon 27-Jan-25 21:59:53

The number of weeks limit is a valid debate.

My concerns lie more around those groups who seek to stop women having access to clinics by any means at their disposal whether in the states its fire bombing them,

or in the UK demonstrations, "shaming' women, handing out anti abortion leaflets, trying to push an agenda with politicians to change the law by joint US/UK organisations.

BTW, it's not just the UK, the US extreme anti abortion groups operate on other countries in purpose as well.

imaround Mon 27-Jan-25 21:47:42

Trump himself has said he is proud to be responsible for sitting the judges that overturned Roe vs Wade.

www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trump-was-able-kill-roe-v-wade-rcna84897

Pregnant women who do not want abortions are dying because they can't get medical care when their pregnancies turn out to have complications.

The new alcoholic Fox News host who is charge of our military has gone on record saying he doesn't believe women should be in combat. He has paid tens of thousands of dollars to women who have accused him of sexual assault

An DeSantis appointee to a University in Florida has stated that he doesn't believe women should be getting higher education.

There are whispers from down ballot GOP and Trump appointees who wish to see the 19th Amendment overturned. While this is not happening right now, it gives you an idea of what is happening for women in the US.

Trumps overturning of the EEOC will slowly allow discrimination against women to seep back to the 1950s

It isn't just about abortion. It is about the rights of women. Abortion is just where it starts.

Galaxy Mon 27-Jan-25 21:46:54

But that is the point I am making. Farage is perfectly entitled to express the views described in that article. It works both ways.

Casdon Mon 27-Jan-25 21:41:36

You have some interesting views Galaxy. However, other people don’t always share them, and it is quite valid for them to say what they think too.

Galaxy Mon 27-Jan-25 21:38:04

I dont mean to be funny but it's perfectly within reason to ask questions about the abortion limit, I may not agree but people are entitled to debate it.
There is in my view no threat to the right to have an abortion in this country, I personally think this kind of reaction helps Reform not hinders them.

Casdon Mon 27-Jan-25 21:29:00

The Independent’s version.
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/nigel-farage-abortion-debate-trump-b2661900.html

Galaxy Mon 27-Jan-25 21:26:14

Sorry but that is a terrible piece of journalism. It is cobbled together quotes of Farage on free speech and abortion.

Wyllow3 Mon 27-Jan-25 21:13:41

here it is

bylinetimes.com/2024/11/29/nigel-farage-teams-up-with-extreme-anti-abortion-group-and-calls-for-debate-on-restricting-abortion-rights-in-uk/

Very specific links with Farage and the group outlined (also Braverman), and the issues it was all about,

which is the so called "right" to demonstrate outside UK clinics which offer services that include abortion

eg

"ADF International (UK) backed a recent National Conservatism (NatCon) event in Brussels, which included Nigel Farage and former Home Secretary Suella Braverman as speakers. After it was shut down by local authorities, the ADF backed an emergency legal challenge to the closure, and the event later resumed. "

HousePlantQueen Mon 27-Jan-25 20:43:57

There are reports on Byeline Times that Nigel Farage has been getting involved with this group. I will try to post a reference but I am on my phone.

suelld Mon 27-Jan-25 20:31:16

If his MAGA followers and the Trump voters were FOR Abortion, Trump and Vance would immediately switch their position …he has NO ETHICS or Morals… The Worst person Americans could ever have voted for! Corrupt to the core.

Dickens Mon 27-Jan-25 19:52:50

undines

I am not sure that our finest right as women is to be able to murder the life within us. Many cultures believe that the soul enters the body at a certain point, at about six weeks of pregnancy, and I think they may be right. People have a right to pray for these unborn souls, outside abortion clinics. If our whole culture were turned upside down and motherhood were given the status it should have, fewer women would want terminations. The trend, which is apparently taking place in some areas, to abort later and later in pregnancy I find disgusting. I think we need to widen the discussion, respectfully and sensitively. Promiscuity and serial abortions are not a lifestyle choice to be encouraged. Many women are emotionally scarred for life by abortion. I am also wondering where the 'morning after' pill comes in all of this? Can't young women be encouraged to respect their bodies a bit more, and get sensibly prepared? Personally, I do not believe in abortion after the placenta has taken over, at about 14 weeks. There are times in life when you make a mistake and you have to live with it, and I've never heard anyone say they regret having a child (although I cannot know what they think) whereas many regret the abortion.

It's not a question of our "finest" right is it, it's the removal of a woman's autonomy over her reproductive and sexual health - there are those who would ban abortion even in cases of rape and incest, even if the victim was a minor. Just how much power and control should a state or a government have over a woman's, or a girl's body?

There is also the question of paternity rights - it's been suggested that rapists and those men who indulge in incest might well have legal rights, if they want them, over a child that a woman has been forced to bear.

... perhaps it would be easier if we assume that women actually have no rights, no autonomy - and start from that premise, do you think?

Many cultures may well believe that the soul enters the body at a certain point - they can believe what they wish, that is a private matter and not one to legislate on. And neither does that belief give them the right to pray outside an abortion clinic - or they could pray outside at night when it's closed, or even in their own homes. If abortion clinics exist legally, then women have an equal right not to be intimidated on what is a private matter between them, their doctor and their God and / or their conscience.

Promiscuity is a moral debate - and it should include men -the men involved in the sex / porn industry, who profit from the exploitation of women on every level. The men who lurk the streets looking for prostitutes; the men who frequent clubs and bars at weekends hoping to 'get lucky' and who not infrequently spike a woman's drink so they do.

Why do women have to carry the burden of, and be also responsible for, the behaviour of men?

There are times in life when you make a mistake and you have to live with it.

Words fail me.

Mojack26 Mon 27-Jan-25 19:10:28

It does not list all states.

wibblywobblywobblebottom Mon 27-Jan-25 15:49:28

Surprise surprise.

madeleine45 Mon 27-Jan-25 14:13:00

what do you expect when y ou vote in Trump? It was obvious from day one what trump is le and his cronies too. I usually try to believe in the good of people until they prove otherwise, but have felt for many years that north americans take the buscuit, and doesnt what they have done now prove it. Who but another lunatic would choose to have a president who is a liar, cheat, encourages people to behave against the law , when he doesnt get his own way. He has the look of a two year old in a temper tantrum. What a pity that bullet missed the angle and only got his ear. Cant believe that I actually wish that someone had shot him , but then I wouldnt consider it murder in his case but PEST CONTROL1111

ViceVersa Mon 27-Jan-25 14:07:16

Totally agree with that, Annma. Access to safe, legal abortion is healthcare. It's as simple as that.

Wyllow3 Mon 27-Jan-25 14:07:13

AuntieE

Well, we knew this would happen, didn't we? I mean Trump has made himself very clear on this issue.

Those of us who are not US citizens cannot do anything about this.

We can waste our time condemming it, or point out that it is odd that a society that still has the death penalty ( at least in certain states) finds it acceptable to force children to be born who were conceived during rape, incest or by parents knowing that they suffered from a serious hereditary illness, to say nothing of those doomed to a deprived childhood as their mothers cannot afford to support them.

Why not leave the US to solve its own internal problems, and concentrate on tidying up our own backyards?

Or make our views known considering the new American international policies that spell disaster?

This report is 9 months old, but it shows that US anti abortion groups are alive and active in the UK, funding groups and campaigning, including contact with UK MP's

www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/06/extreme-us-anti-abortion-group-ramps-up-lobbying-in-westminster

Annma Mon 27-Jan-25 13:56:48

Safe abortion should be a human right.The right wing evangelicals in some of the backward US states are taking things back to the dark ages. A woman should be in control of her own body, not be at the mercy of bigoted politicians and judges,mostly men.The hypocrisy of Trump and his ilk beggars belief.A lot of women are going to die unnecessarily.

missdeke Mon 27-Jan-25 13:38:19

Handmaids tale comes to mind.