Gransnet forums

News & politics

Nothing but nothing, can excuse Israel breaking the cease-fire in Gaza

(535 Posts)
Claremont Tue 18-Mar-25 18:43:30

- without warning, in the middle of the night- in the middle of Ramadan.

NOTHING.

Anniebach Sun 23-Mar-25 10:05:35

According to Lebanon Health Ministry. According to
Gaza Health Ministry

Wyllow3 Sun 23-Mar-25 10:01:05

Meanwhile thousands gathered again yesterday in Tel Aviv:

"In Israel, several thousand protesters took to the streets of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem on Saturday, blocking key highways across the country in a demonstration against Netanyahu’s government.

The immediate trigger for the anger was the government’s attempt to dismiss Ronen Bar, the head of the internal security agency, a move described as an attempt to undermine Israel’s democratic system, but the prime minister’s decision to shatter a two-month-old truce in Gaza with waves of lethal airstrikes has also fuelled the demonstrations.

Forty freed hostages of Hamas captivity and 250 family members of Israeli soldiers and civilians still held in Gaza signed a letter on Friday calling on Netanyahu to halt Israel’s renewed military activities and return to the negotiating table in order to secure the release of the remaining 59 hostages who are still in the territory. In a letter sent to the prime minister, they warned that failure to do so would condemn the living hostages to death.

“This letter was written in blood and tears,” the text reads. ‘‘It was drafted by our friends and families whose loved ones were killed and murdered in captivity and who are crying out: ‘Stop the fighting. Return to the negotiating table and fully complete an agreement that will return all of the hostages, even at the cost of ending the war’.”

Information on these in long article in theGuardian yesterday
www.theguardian.com/world/2025/mar/22/israel-strikes-southern-lebanon-amid-calls-for-end-to-endless-war

Wyllow3 Sun 23-Mar-25 09:56:35

Was the response proportional or wise?

The strike on a building came after Israel carried out dozens of airstrikes in Lebanon on Saturday, its most intense aerial assault on the country in four months. In total, six people were killed, including a child, and 28 injured, according to Lebanon’s health ministry.

The wave of Israeli airstrikes was triggered by the launching of three rockets from Lebanon by unknown groups, which were intercepted by the Israeli air force.

In a statement on Saturday afternoon, Hezbollah denied any involvement in the rocket attacks and stressed its commitment to the ceasefire agreement. It added that Israeli claims that it was behind the strikes were “merely a pretext for continued attacks on Lebanon”.

A variety of Palestinian factions, as well as other armed groups, operate in southern Lebanon and not all are under Hezbollah’s command. Both the Israeli military and the Lebanese Ministry of Defence said it was investigating who could have fired the rockets.

The Lebanese army said it found and dismantled what it called three “primitive rocket launchers” in south Lebanon after the rocket fire towards Israel. Pictures released by the army showed fragments of bombs and three wooden posts dug into the earth, seemingly used in the launching of the rockets.

Lebanon’s minister of defence, Michel Menassa, said the country was “continuing its diplomatic, political and military efforts to ensure Lebanon’s sovereignty”

(guardian news)

Granniesunite Sun 23-Mar-25 09:50:35

Anniebach

Are there bombs which only kill women and children?

Scoring points at the expense of the dead. Not a good look.

Parsley3 Sun 23-Mar-25 09:44:47

Anniebach

Are there bombs which only kill women and children?

BBC News - Air strike kills top Hamas official in Gaza
www.bbc.com/news/articles/cq5zxe5l58go

Clearly not and here is some proof. Why are we not seeing the damage being done to Israel by the rocket attacks?

Anniebach Sun 23-Mar-25 09:39:33

Are there bombs which only kill women and children?

Parsley3 Sun 23-Mar-25 09:35:37

No proof of anything then?

Anniebach Sun 23-Mar-25 09:15:00

Is there proof Israeli bombs are aimed on women and children?

Oreo Sun 23-Mar-25 09:13:47

Passing house keys down the generations for 80 years is passing on grudges and hate tho isn’t it? It’s all grit for the terrorist mills.
On the subject of Gaza, if that’s what is meant by being trapped in a tiny strip of land, people interviewed say they were ‘ so happy’ living there before October 2023.With all the money poured into Gaza for so many years and international aid Gaza could have been so much better if a good government had been in charge.Old grudges and a diet of hate for all Jews is what ultimately doomed Gaza.
Donkey carts, rubble and displaced people is always tragic and even more so when their own governing body has caused it.

Parsley3 Sun 23-Mar-25 09:09:33

Anniebach

After rockets were fired by Lebanon on Israel

What damage did these rockets do? Were lives lost? Was property destroyed? Is there any proof of rockets fired?

Anniebach Sun 23-Mar-25 09:09:15

Which? a tiny strip of land or Palestine.?

silverlining48 Sun 23-Mar-25 09:01:44

Since 1948 nearly 10 million Palestinian refugees have been driven out 0f their homes and lands. Many still live in refugee camps in nearby countries close to Palestine and others spread throughout the world. Israel does not allow them any right of return to their homes. Some families have kept their house keys for nearly 80 years. Passed down through the generations. Imagine for a moment. Heartbreaking.
Anyone with any compassion seeing donkey carts among the rubble loaded with families and what’s left of their possessions off to yet another ‘safe’ place yet never is. Imagine being trapped in a tiny strip of land with no escape knowing that they and their children could be killed that day or the next , just imagine if that were you and yours.
Most people are good people whoever they are and just want to live a peaceful and safe life.
I heard a rabbi on r4 earlier who is protesting against Israel and its treatment of Palestinians saying many Jews feel the same as she does. She can see through the politics of Israel, why cant others.

Oreo Sun 23-Mar-25 08:45:41

silverlining48

It was reported that Lebanon denies they fired rockets.

Yeah, right hmm
Ever hear of Hezbollah? It isn’t the Lebanese government firing missiles all the time into Israel, it’s the terrorists.Having said that, the government has several Hez members and are scared to death by the organisation generally.

Chocolatelovinggran Sun 23-Mar-25 08:36:36

These conflicts in this part of the world have been going on since Old Testament times, Skodadoda.
The peoples of the Middle East find it difficult to live together. Only the weapons have changed.

Aveline Sun 23-Mar-25 08:35:34

Understandable

Anniebach Sun 23-Mar-25 08:06:58

1948 , birth of a Jewish state. 5 Muslim countries. Declared war on the Jews

Aveline Sun 23-Mar-25 07:43:48

I can never understand some people's surprise at the Palestinian worm turning. You can't bully people for so long and not expect a response.

Skodadoda Sun 23-Mar-25 06:40:38

silverlining48

Yes Claremont on the the West Bank Palestinians are being thrown off their own land by force, houses and olive groves burnt, many people have been killed, yet it hardly gets a mention.

This has been going on since 1948 when Israelis brutally threw Palestinians out of their homes.

Skodadoda Sun 23-Mar-25 06:35:43

Lovetopaint037

Netanyahu is pure evil. Any excuse to continue the war to save his skin.

So true; Netanyahu faces serious charges if the war ends.

Aveline Sun 23-Mar-25 06:27:06

2 arab tribes fighting

Anniebach Sat 22-Mar-25 23:23:48

They would wouldn’t they

silverlining48 Sat 22-Mar-25 23:15:52

It was reported that Lebanon denies they fired rockets.

Anniebach Sat 22-Mar-25 22:48:29

After rockets were fired by Lebanon on Israel

Parsley3 Sat 22-Mar-25 22:35:25

BBC News - Israel strikes Lebanon after first rocket attack since ceasefire
www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn4ynpzk8d8o

Israel is also attacking Lebanon.

silverlining48 Sat 22-Mar-25 17:48:01

Yes Claremont on the the West Bank Palestinians are being thrown off their own land by force, houses and olive groves burnt, many people have been killed, yet it hardly gets a mention.