Gransnet forums

News & politics

If you want to understand the techniques Farage uses ...

(207 Posts)
PoliticsNerd Wed 06-Aug-25 13:35:54

...you might be interested in this visual "long read".

www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPqwiwQ68Lw

It would be great if those who watch it give their view. Obviously those who don't want to watch already have plenty of threads running. Many thanks.

Teazel2 Thu 07-Aug-25 16:54:46

Chocolatelovinggran

I repeat, Teazel, what will Mr Farage do , if he is " given a chance"? How will he control our borders?
Lots of rhetoric, not much thought through, costed policy. If he has a wonderful plan, please share it with us. I'm sure that a government of any persuasion would be happy to implement a proven, well researched tactic
You might not like what he has in mind for Education, Health Provision, or Defence... but he doesn't talk so much about these subjects.

The government could do worse than listen to him! On another thread there was mention of a youtube clip by the blackbelted barrister. Please listen to that for some suggestions of what can be done, in answer to your question. Also you do come across as quite fierce, we are all entitled to our opinions.

Chocolatelovinggran Thu 07-Aug-25 16:46:59

I repeat, Teazel, what will Mr Farage do , if he is " given a chance"? How will he control our borders?
Lots of rhetoric, not much thought through, costed policy. If he has a wonderful plan, please share it with us. I'm sure that a government of any persuasion would be happy to implement a proven, well researched tactic
You might not like what he has in mind for Education, Health Provision, or Defence... but he doesn't talk so much about these subjects.

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 16:36:14

MayBee70

There was a poll on one of the news programmes the other day which showed that most people seemed to think that the number of illegal immigrants was far greater than legal ones. They had no idea of the true figures.

We really do seem to be leaving in a post-truth world.

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 16:34:50

PoliticsNerd

Teazel2
I have watched it, what a load of rubbish. Nigel is not creating a feeling of crisis, there is a crisis! He is also a brilliant orator and debater, his maiden speech in the HoC was brilliant. What a load of absolute tosh from an obvious left wing bias.

And there we have it! Exactly what they aim for.

Exactly! Job done here - on to the next one!

PoliticsNerd Thu 07-Aug-25 16:30:13

Teazel2
I have watched it, what a load of rubbish. Nigel is not creating a feeling of crisis, there is a crisis! He is also a brilliant orator and debater, his maiden speech in the HoC was brilliant. What a load of absolute tosh from an obvious left wing bias.

And there we have it! Exactly what they aim for.

MayBee70 Thu 07-Aug-25 16:19:52

There was a poll on one of the news programmes the other day which showed that most people seemed to think that the number of illegal immigrants was far greater than legal ones. They had no idea of the true figures.

Teazel2 Thu 07-Aug-25 16:11:51

growstuff

GrannyGravy13

growstuff it is not just classic Farage though is it?

The boat crossings are on virtually every news bulletin along with newspapers along with digital media.

The current government particularly the Hone Secretary are also focusing on this topic.

That's not surprising. The UK has very biased media and Farage has loud voice. Just because it's headline news doesn't mean that it's the most important issue facing the country. What it means is that the government's spin doctors and PR teams aren't doing a very good job.

It is classic Farage and all the people who are falling for his rhetoric.

Its not a question of falling for his rhetoric, which is a patronising statement. Its a question of this and previous government failing to control our borders. Nige may not be the answer but he deserves a chance and can be no worse than what has gone before. I know there are a hard core on here who scoff but everyone I speak to in everyday life is really fearful of what is happening.

MayBee70 Thu 07-Aug-25 14:40:11

I have been told that he and Reform are funded by climate change deniers and people involved in offshore investment ( happy to be corrected about this). So I don’t see how he is going to help working people. If only he used his gift as an orator to do good things.

Boz Thu 07-Aug-25 14:36:26

The problem is with chucking them out, as it is almost impossible to entirely stop them coming.
Twice to-day on MSN have I heard the perceived necessity to modify the rules of the ECHR.. Farage will go down that road. He also is targeting the young,white disaffected male who are, we are told, is ready for a fight.

Chocolatelovinggran Thu 07-Aug-25 13:26:19

Whether it's a crisis or a problem, as I said previously, I think that we would be foolish to think that Mr Farage et al have any ability to tackle it : talk about it, absolutely, but actual workable solutions, sadly not
If there is an excellent idea waiting to be implemented, I have yet to hear it from Mr F, although I am happy to acknowledge his skill at rhetoric.
Does Mr Farage pay tax in Britain?
I understood that his main residence is elsewhere - Belgium, or..?

MayBee70 Thu 07-Aug-25 12:24:27

Saltyspec

No use beating about the bush, many ordinary working people are also concerned at the influx of undocumented potentially criminal economic migrants. When we are borrowing to pay interest on earlier loans and the economy is failing it makes no sense to increase the national debt by importing problems

That’s what it is. A problem. And no one is saying that it isn’t a problem. But it isn’t, as Reform make it out to be, a crisis.

LizzieDrip Thu 07-Aug-25 12:15:47

Growstuff hear, hear to your posts👏👏👏

I suppose we’ll just have to be content with our heads in the sand … until someone can tell us what ‘the crisis’ actually is🤷‍♀️

Galaxy Thu 07-Aug-25 12:15:37

I think it is too late growstuff, I am exceedingly pessimistic about it. The labour party in my view has moved more and more to a party of the middle class, perhaps it was Blairs fault after all.

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:53:11

Saltyspec

growstuff

Saltyspec

No use beating about the bush, many ordinary working people are also concerned at the influx of undocumented potentially criminal economic migrants. When we are borrowing to pay interest on earlier loans and the economy is failing it makes no sense to increase the national debt by importing problems

Are they concerned about immigration in general? Do they actually know what percentage of the population the "boat people" represent?

I reckon it’s both now. The boat people are a tiny but very visible portion, and fears are evoked because they are undocumented. More generally there was an expectation of more integration and less criminality than has been the case, there have been higher numbers than can be coped with, wages have therefore been kept down, and we see for example, drs and nurses being imported while our own newly qualified can’t obtain posts. These things bring the unrest that is now increasing. But the govt don’t see it and try to stop the unrest rather than resolve the issue

Doctors and nurses aren't undocumented. There's more behind doctors' not being able to obtain posts than immigration. Is there evidence that immigration keeps wages down rather than filling gaps which other people won't touch?

The whole immigration issue needs sensible discussion, but fears have been whipped up to a frenzy. You have also forgotten that there are some groups, including neo-Nazis, who are very happy to see the unrest, have been involved and are responsible for fuelling the fires. You're whistling in the wind if you think Reform has any solutions.

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:47:27

GrannyGravy13

growstuff it is not just classic Farage though is it?

The boat crossings are on virtually every news bulletin along with newspapers along with digital media.

The current government particularly the Hone Secretary are also focusing on this topic.

That's not surprising. The UK has very biased media and Farage has loud voice. Just because it's headline news doesn't mean that it's the most important issue facing the country. What it means is that the government's spin doctors and PR teams aren't doing a very good job.

It is classic Farage and all the people who are falling for his rhetoric.

Saltyspec Thu 07-Aug-25 11:45:56

growstuff

Saltyspec

No use beating about the bush, many ordinary working people are also concerned at the influx of undocumented potentially criminal economic migrants. When we are borrowing to pay interest on earlier loans and the economy is failing it makes no sense to increase the national debt by importing problems

Are they concerned about immigration in general? Do they actually know what percentage of the population the "boat people" represent?

I reckon it’s both now. The boat people are a tiny but very visible portion, and fears are evoked because they are undocumented. More generally there was an expectation of more integration and less criminality than has been the case, there have been higher numbers than can be coped with, wages have therefore been kept down, and we see for example, drs and nurses being imported while our own newly qualified can’t obtain posts. These things bring the unrest that is now increasing. But the govt don’t see it and try to stop the unrest rather than resolve the issue

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:44:20

Thank you for the reply Saltyspec. I know you didn't claim that the government has it in for pensioners, but some posters have claimed it, but I just don't see it.

I see a weird kind of virtue signalling here. Pensioners complain about the loss of WFA (understandably - nobody wants to lose a benefit) and justify it by talking about those pensioners on low incomes.

I am one of those pensioners. I live on the state pension plus some housing benefit (which I obviously don't see because I pay it straight to my landlord). Yes, I missed having an extra couple of hundred pounds in my bank account just before Christmas, but I didn't starve or freeze last winter. It really wasn't a huge disaster.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 07-Aug-25 11:40:15

growstuff it is not just classic Farage though is it?

The boat crossings are on virtually every news bulletin along with newspapers along with digital media.

The current government particularly the Hone Secretary are also focusing on this topic.

Saltyspec Thu 07-Aug-25 11:37:59

growstuff

Saltyspec

As a coal miner’s daughter I was shocked when the Labour Government’s first act was to stop the Winter Fuel Allowance for pensioners on about £11k a year, that was certainly not in line with Old Labour principles

It's now been restored. £200 a year is a far cry from the claims some people make about targeting old people - unless you have any other examples.

I know, and had they put that level in originally there would have been far less outcry. The allotment building business will also affect many pensioners and those pensioners on low incomes are certainly feeling the high energy and food inflation. But I don’t think they are targeting pensioners particularly, they just don’t understand or value the views of ordinary working people

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:37:20

Galaxy

It is also a growing disconnect between the political class, and the working class in particular.

I acknowledge that. What do you think could be done about it?

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:36:36

The immigration crisis is classic Farage and proves the point of the OP.

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:35:56

Saltyspec

No use beating about the bush, many ordinary working people are also concerned at the influx of undocumented potentially criminal economic migrants. When we are borrowing to pay interest on earlier loans and the economy is failing it makes no sense to increase the national debt by importing problems

Are they concerned about immigration in general? Do they actually know what percentage of the population the "boat people" represent?

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:34:24

LizzieDrip

Teazel2 clearly my head is in the sand.

Perhaps you could help rid me of my ignorance and tell me what exactly ‘the crisis’ is.

Ha! Let me know where you are and O'll be round with my bucket and spade. Well, I would be round, except my head is stuck in the sand too.

Saltyspec Thu 07-Aug-25 11:33:27

No use beating about the bush, many ordinary working people are also concerned at the influx of undocumented potentially criminal economic migrants. When we are borrowing to pay interest on earlier loans and the economy is failing it makes no sense to increase the national debt by importing problems

growstuff Thu 07-Aug-25 11:33:00

The OP was about Farage's rhetoric, not about his policies. Do people recognise them?