Angela Rayner - 3 homes now

I havnt read all the posts, but struggle tounderstand why Angela Rayner is being credited with three homes.
Every MP gets accommodated if they live a distance from the HoC. At the rate Labour is being constantly criticised, it’s likely she and her party will vacate these properties at the next election. .
Her northern property went in a divorce settlement. There will be many MPs with two or more properties so why pick on AR unless it’s because she is working class and proud, which she has absolutely every right to be.
She has done well despite a very difficult start in life. After 14 years of the Tory boys from Eton and similar it makes for a refreshing change.

Allira

^PoliticsNerd Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM^.

Doesn't his wife come from a wealthy background and didn't he make money before he became an MP?
Or did he acquire those homes since he became an MP?

I don’t know. Did he make the same claims as AR and the LP re second homes?
I’m not defending RS, just wondering if his policy opposed his practice.

PoliticsNerd

Norah

PoliticsNerd Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM.

Many people invest excess money in homes. Well done them.

I'm curious to see proof of AR's home transactions.

My mind can be changed -- by facts.

If I wanted to see your proof of your home transactions, would that be OK Norah?

There are proper ways of doing this, via the Standards and Intererest Committee. Allegations should be reported to them, not a newspaper. If that were the right way to do it should be possible to report our taxes, etc, in a newspaper, with no redress if they get it wrong. That is how Angela Raynor is being treated.

You, by being part of a democracy, agree to power being held by everyone through an elected government.

No, you may not see our proper records.

HMRC certainly see our records, ascertaining taxes are proper.

PoliticsNerd

Norah

PoliticsNerd Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM.

Many people invest excess money in homes. Well done them.

I'm curious to see proof of AR's home transactions.

My mind can be changed -- by facts.

If I wanted to see your proof of your home transactions, would that be OK Norah?

There are proper ways of doing this, via the Standards and Intererest Committee. Allegations should be reported to them, not a newspaper. If that were the right way to do it should be possible to report our taxes, etc, in a newspaper, with no redress if they get it wrong. That is how Angela Raynor is being treated.

You, by being part of a democracy, agree to power being held by everyone through an elected government.

I did say proof. I was wrong. I'd like to read of a proper review.

"The House of Commons Committee on Standards reviews the work of the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards, examining arrangements for the Register of Members' Financial Interests."

Norah

PoliticsNerd Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM.

Many people invest excess money in homes. Well done them.

I'm curious to see proof of AR's home transactions.

My mind can be changed -- by facts.

If I wanted to see your proof of your home transactions, would that be OK Norah?

There are proper ways of doing this, via the Standards and Intererest Committee. Allegations should be reported to them, not a newspaper. If that were the right way to do it should be possible to report our taxes, etc, in a newspaper, with no redress if they get it wrong. That is how Angela Raynor is being treated.

You, by being part of a democracy, agree to power being held by everyone through an elected government.

PoliticsNerd

Sorry that should have been MPs not politicians.

Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM. I don't remember him being castigated for this although he was when he had the electricity grid upgraded to heat his private pool.

His wife comes from an amazingly rich background.What he earned as PM was peanuts to him, no PM does it for the money.
Any politician has to be under the spotlight if there’s perceived wrongdoing/ unethical behaviour.

Casdon

Oreo

Maybe you’ve been on this site for a long time Casdon so have seen similar threads time and again?
In the nearly three years on here, I have seen a few but not many, and even newer posters won’t have, so it’s worth reading and posting IMO.
We all have our views on subject but worth reading opposite views still to see if there’s anything of value there to consider.

You’re right, I have been on here for a long time, and I’ve reached the point where I can spot people who’ve changed their user names by their views now Oreo. I remember what people have said before. I suppose leopards don’t change their spots, and it’s therefore time for me to bow out of this type of thread and only participate in those where new ground is being covered.

A peculiar comment Casdon
I really doubt you can tell anyone from their views on politics as there are only so many views possible and very many posters.
What do user names have to do with the price of fish anyway.
Your above comments sound very off to me.Maybe your having a bad day.
As I said already, new posters haven’t seen some subjects so threads are worth it, and threads on any politician of any political party who do dodgy stuff need commenting on.

I've just googled and their net worth is 651m. It's just boggling isn't it? I manage a team who work a really difficult and important job and their wages don't even cover the 2k rent I mentioned earlier.

We know the cost of everything and the value of nothing

PoliticsNerd Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM.

Doesn't his wife come from a wealthy background and didn't he make money before he became an MP?
Or did he acquire those homes since he became an MP?

JaneJudge

I can't really disagree with you PoliticsNerd as I understand the hypocrisy and I also know Angela gets a bad press, mainly because of the mere fact she is working class and northern. It still doesn't make having spare homes acceptable or normal. It's just how I feel

I like Angela Rayner and admire her for what she has achieved. However, she is proving to be no different than most politicians when they become MPs. Perhaps the rules need changing if she is breaking none, but it is certain bewildering and galling to most ordinary people how they all manage to get rich so quickly.

PoliticsNerd Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM.

Many people invest excess money in homes. Well done them.

I'm curious to see proof of AR's home transactions.

My mind can be changed -- by facts.

I can't really disagree with you PoliticsNerd as I understand the hypocrisy and I also know Angela gets a bad press, mainly because of the mere fact she is working class and northern. It still doesn't make having spare homes acceptable or normal. It's just how I feel

Sorry that should have been MPs not politicians.

Just for context Rishi Sunak and his wife together own four houses spread across the UK and the US, worth an estimated £15 Mn. I imagine this was true when he was PM. I don't remember him being castigated for this although he was when he had the electricity grid upgraded to heat his private pool.

JaneJudge

I haven't read the thread but I'm a labour voter who is disappointed with her. No one needs more than one home and holiday lets and buy to let have caused all sorts of problems in the UK. I understand people may become accidental landlords if they cannot sell an inherited home but the problems holiday lets cause in coastal communities is awful. Buy to let has presented its own problems. To rent a 3 bed semi detached family home where I live is over £2,000. How are people affording to live

Most politicians have two homes. One comes with the job.

It appears that Angela Raynor is in exactly that position and that a third property she owned/part-owned(?) while in a relationship, went to he ex partner on the resolution of that partnership.

What has she done wrong?

RosieandherMaw

I am sick, sick, sick of the “great and the good” - , people in positions of power, who set themselves up to make decisions which affect ALL our lives and are found out to have their noses in the trough- think duck houses, off shore funds, camper vans, free designer clothes even specs, dodgy deals with Arabs/Chinese, fiddled expenses (often to family members bets to “keep it in the family”) now second /third homes.Who do they think they are?
I don’t care what their political persuasion, they all seem to be in it for what they can personally line their pockets with.

I agree with this too. It appears to be the same within big organisations too. It's utterly depressing

Well most human beings are pretty similar Allira. How are you expecting politician to be different?

I haven't read the thread but I'm a labour voter who is disappointed with her. No one needs more than one home and holiday lets and buy to let have caused all sorts of problems in the UK. I understand people may become accidental landlords if they cannot sell an inherited home but the problems holiday lets cause in coastal communities is awful. Buy to let has presented its own problems. To rent a 3 bed semi detached family home where I live is over £2,000. How are people affording to live

Lathyrus3

Ahem.

Like to point out that on Saturday I posted that I had changed my view from of Angela Rayner😬

Some views are polarised and some whose views will never change under any circumstances; however, there are some who agree that most politicians are the same of whatever party and yet others who say they have changed their views.
😁

Ahem.

Like to point out that on Saturday I posted that I had changed my view from of Angela Rayner😬

Allira

Views aren't that polarised, though, Casdon.

There are a few who will defend Ms Rayner simply because she is Labour and there are a few who will castigate her because she's Labour.

The majority, I think, are just fed up of politicians in general and some, like me, are disappointed because we hoped for something better with a Labour Government but one after another is proving that wrong.

They are polarised on a thread that set out to attract the small number of like-minded people on GN who felt the same way.

This is not showing anything other than a proportion if GN posters agree with misleading right-wing newspaper content.

Maybe it's easier to be objective if there aren't any partisan allegencies to any one political party. I've voted for the two main ones at different junctures, pretty much regretting my decision soon afterwards. Whilst I don't regard all politicians as flawed, some are good people across the political spectrum, but they often remain on the back benches. I'm often dubious about those who want power a bit too much that's often a pre requisite to a downward slippery slope. The disappointment in the immediate aftermath of a general when the electorate become aware of rank hypocrisy is the first nail in the coffin in the loss of public confidence, compounded by "we haven't done anything wrong" Fools!

Oreo

Maybe you’ve been on this site for a long time Casdon so have seen similar threads time and again?
In the nearly three years on here, I have seen a few but not many, and even newer posters won’t have, so it’s worth reading and posting IMO.
We all have our views on subject but worth reading opposite views still to see if there’s anything of value there to consider.

You’re right, I have been on here for a long time, and I’ve reached the point where I can spot people who’ve changed their user names by their views now Oreo. I remember what people have said before. I suppose leopards don’t change their spots, and it’s therefore time for me to bow out of this type of thread and only participate in those where new ground is being covered.

Allira

Views aren't that polarised, though, Casdon.

There are a few who will defend Ms Rayner simply because she is Labour and there are a few who will castigate her because she's Labour.

The majority, I think, are just fed up of politicians in general and some, like me, are disappointed because we hoped for something better with a Labour Government but one after another is proving that wrong.

That’s it exactly.

Maybe you’ve been on this site for a long time Casdon so have seen similar threads time and again?
In the nearly three years on here, I have seen a few but not many, and even newer posters won’t have, so it’s worth reading and posting IMO.
We all have our views on subject but worth reading opposite views still to see if there’s anything of value there to consider.

Views aren't that polarised, though, Casdon.

There are a few who will defend Ms Rayner simply because she is Labour and there are a few who will castigate her because she's Labour.

The majority, I think, are just fed up of politicians in general and some, like me, are disappointed because we hoped for something better with a Labour Government but one after another is proving that wrong.