Gransnet forums

News & politics

Moving immigrants to army camps?

(153 Posts)
Mollygo Tue 28-Oct-25 18:19:30

Inverness and Sussex
This is KS’s latest idea.
What do you think?
Better than hotels?
Worse than hotels?
Why do you think he’s doing it?

Oreo Tue 28-Oct-25 18:22:09

Better late than never is my opinion.

Lathyrus3 Tue 28-Oct-25 18:26:04

I think they just need more and more accommodation. These and hotels.

Sparklefizz Tue 28-Oct-25 18:44:38

A lot of money was spent on that boat the Bibby Stockholm to equip it. Why can't that be reinstated as accommodation?

David49 Tue 28-Oct-25 19:50:59

They should be set to work to build their own hostel accommodation within a secure perimeter.

Allira Tue 28-Oct-25 20:13:15

There's nothing wrong with Army camps.
Single accommodation for single men, flats or houses for families.

I've lived in service accommodation. It was fine, could have done with a bit of updating but it was perfectly functional.
We had to pay rent, despite beliefs to the contrary.

Smileless2012 Tue 28-Oct-25 20:17:55

I agree Oreo that it's better late than never.

merlotgran Tue 28-Oct-25 20:22:57

Allira

There's nothing wrong with Army camps.
Single accommodation for single men, flats or houses for families.

I've lived in service accommodation. It was fine, could have done with a bit of updating but it was perfectly functional.
We had to pay rent, despite beliefs to the contrary.

Ditto, Allira

If it was good enough for us…..

kircubbin2000 Tue 28-Oct-25 20:37:53

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Primrose53 Tue 28-Oct-25 20:41:32

Will it be any cheaper? They’ve wasted millions already.

Trouble is the Labour luvvies will say it’s not good enough for the migrants and so it goes on.

Iam64 Tue 28-Oct-25 20:54:13

They’ve only had a year to waste millions, the last lot had much longer and spent even more
It’s a tough problem, or no doubt the Conservatives or current govt would have solved it

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 28-Oct-25 20:55:46

Can they keep up with demand though? Over 1,000 arriving every week. Still they come.

That’s a lot of beds, blankets and breakfasts to get ready….

JenniferEccles Tue 28-Oct-25 22:45:49

They need to concentrate their efforts on stopping these migrants coming in the first place, not scratching heads about where to put them when they are here.

I know it’s been said many times before but we need an effective deterrent- something like, oh I don’t know, maybe a plan in place to send them to somewhere like Rwanda.

Hang on, wasn’t there such a plan until this ghastly, useless government abandoned it ?

In the meantime ex army camps will be cheaper and if they are sufficiently uncomfortable, so much the better.

Wyllow3 Tue 28-Oct-25 22:52:35

kircubbin2000

I don't think they have a clue how to solve this. Being in camps will be no different. They will complain. The locals will complain. Girls will get raped and locals upset.

Here we go again. Being an irregular migrant means girls will get raped.

Actually I will report this, it is a vile and gross generalisation, and ask them to delete this to if they delete that.

Allira Tue 28-Oct-25 22:59:16

In the meantime ex army camps will be cheaper and if they are sufficiently uncomfortable, so much the better.

I don't know why they should be uncomfortable.

🤔

Teazel2 Tue 28-Oct-25 23:02:49

JenniferEccles

They need to concentrate their efforts on stopping these migrants coming in the first place, not scratching heads about where to put them when they are here.

I know it’s been said many times before but we need an effective deterrent- something like, oh I don’t know, maybe a plan in place to send them to somewhere like Rwanda.

Hang on, wasn’t there such a plan until this ghastly, useless government abandoned it ?

In the meantime ex army camps will be cheaper and if they are sufficiently uncomfortable, so much the better.

👏👏👏👏👏👏

butterandjam Tue 28-Oct-25 23:25:12

Cameron Barracks in Inverness was until recently, used by the MOD to house some of the thousands of Afghan families whose adults had risked their lives working for the UK armed forces in Kabul.

When the Taliban took Kabul, those people had to be evacuated to safety. Many were left behind.

Among the boat people coming to UK, one of the highest national groups, are Afghans.
.

Wyllow3 Tue 28-Oct-25 23:31:50

JenniferEccles

They need to concentrate their efforts on stopping these migrants coming in the first place, not scratching heads about where to put them when they are here.

I know it’s been said many times before but we need an effective deterrent- something like, oh I don’t know, maybe a plan in place to send them to somewhere like Rwanda.

Hang on, wasn’t there such a plan until this ghastly, useless government abandoned it ?

In the meantime ex army camps will be cheaper and if they are sufficiently uncomfortable, so much the better.

You do realise that some irregular migrants are genuine asylum seekers, some coming from horrific situations?

so you want to punish them

"if they are sufficiently uncomfortable, so much the better."

Terrific. Britain at its best. So sad people should have this attitude. and yes, I say this, as Quakers locally are involved with and help out genuine, often shattered and troubled, people.

I went to a Quaker friends house Jennifer and met a young man from the Sudan. He was 16 so had left his home at 14 as both his parents had been murdered by machetes and they were recruiting child soldiers. Yes, for real. Poor lad just wanted to be a footballer (unlikely, but understandable)

Kandinsky Tue 28-Oct-25 23:42:16

Well, our own Home Secretary has this to say……
I know that asylum hotels are an absolute blight on our communities. I know that they've been the site of huge community tensions

An absolute blight on our communities…..that’s Labours view on the issue.

nanna8 Tue 28-Oct-25 23:57:21

Why don’t they shift out some of the native British and give them their houses? 🏡 Only those with no papers, though.

David49 Wed 29-Oct-25 06:15:26

Allira

^In the meantime ex army camps will be cheaper and if they are sufficiently uncomfortable, so much the better^.

I don't know why they should be uncomfortable.

🤔

If they are uncomfortable and restricted less will see the UK as the soft option

Allsorts Wed 29-Oct-25 06:45:04

What happens when they are full. Send them back to their country of origin, only have people by legal route. How long does it take to process people, no papers, no entry. They are as usual, not dealing with the problem which is costing us billions a year. Why do they come through many countries to get here?

Calendargirl Wed 29-Oct-25 06:45:16

They will need a lot of army camps, surely?

Aren’t there 32000 in hotels? And these two earmarked ones will hold 900? 🤔

Let’s hope there are many more waiting to be used.

Otherwise Keir’s dream of closing the hotels will remain just that, a dream.

Alongside ‘smashing the gangs’ of course.

windmill1 Wed 29-Oct-25 06:49:58

A large motel on the edge of Preston has just closed to the general public in order to be allocated to migrants. So the government is lying through its teeth.

What's new?

MaizieD Wed 29-Oct-25 07:59:04

Kandinsky

Well, our own Home Secretary has this to say……
I know that asylum hotels are an absolute blight on our communities. I know that they've been the site of huge community tensions

An absolute blight on our communities…..that’s Labours view on the issue.

If she did indeed say that ‘our own Home Secretary’ is as vile as the past few tory ones.