Gransnet forums

News & politics

New asylum rules

(221 Posts)
Iam64 Mon 17-Nov-25 20:57:11

The link concludes for various reasons the figures will overstate the numbers with settlement who claim benefits.

As Casdon reminds us, those seeking status aren’t allowed to work.

Im not disputing the level of anxiety, even anger, being expressed about the continuing increasing numbers of people seeking asylum. I find it worrying that those seeking sanctuary are being dehumanised

Casdon Mon 17-Nov-25 20:10:06

Data from the Department for Work and Pensions show that 112,000 people with refugee status were claiming Universal Credit in December 2024, equivalent to 66% of the adults with refugee status.7 hours ago
migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk

This is unsurprising as they are unable to work.

Primrose53 Mon 17-Nov-25 20:04:07

Iam64

Is that people with settled status Primrose? Those seeking refugee status don’t get UC

I’m sure you’re aware that doctors, engineers, dentists will surely enter by application through legal routes. I’ve known doctors, nurses etc given settled status. One former teacher became a very good foster carer

migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/commentaries/how-many-refugees-receive-benefits/#:~:text=Data%20from%20the%20Department%20for,the%20adults%20with%20refugee%20status.

Iam64 Mon 17-Nov-25 19:58:39

Is that people with settled status Primrose? Those seeking refugee status don’t get UC

I’m sure you’re aware that doctors, engineers, dentists will surely enter by application through legal routes. I’ve known doctors, nurses etc given settled status. One former teacher became a very good foster carer

Iam64 Mon 17-Nov-25 19:55:05

Thanks Wyllow for expressing a less polarised, negative view on the proposals.
I’m liking Mahmood in her new role. It seems obvious to the majority, that those in the majority are in despair about the extent of immigration and asylum seeking. No doubt people fleeing wars will seek and gain asylum

Denmark has a left leaning government. People pay high taxes for good public services. It’s what I’d like to see here. It’s working in Denmark ……

Primrose53 Mon 17-Nov-25 19:54:54

Dept For Work and Pensions announced today that 66% of refugees are claiming Universal Credit!!

That blows the theory right out of the water that they are all supposed to be Doctors, Engineers, Dentists and other very qualified people.

David49 Mon 17-Nov-25 19:50:58

Fine in theory but when it happens I will believe it.

StripeyGran Mon 17-Nov-25 19:37:24

Bridie22

Jewellery and wedding rings will not be removed goverment says.

How kind. So they are not going to rip the wedding ring off somebody and melt it down.

Bridie22 Mon 17-Nov-25 18:32:04

Jewellery and wedding rings will not be removed goverment says.

StripeyGran Mon 17-Nov-25 18:17:41

Kandinsky

I admire her for trying to tackle this problem, but too many snowflakes in this country who’ll try and stop her at every turn.
Happens all the time.

Care to elaborate? Who are these ( so called ) snowflakes?

Taking jewelry will go down well with some I suppose.

vintage1950 Mon 17-Nov-25 16:56:15

I am appalled by the proposals and have written to my MP to say so.

Wyllow3 Mon 17-Nov-25 16:38:25

I'm listening to the ideas and the discussion on them. I'm not going to leap to immediate judgment, as there is much to unpick.

Clearly some measures are needed.

But it is worth mentioning that some human rights measures are going to be re-visited in terms of "Terms and conditions".

We shouldn't assume as some seem to above all measures are hopeless and not worth undertaking, for what is the alternative? Leave matters as they are?

Neither should we assume that all is lost in terms of those who come and make good in the country. If you assume that, you have missed the clear mentions of the continuing rights of people to apply for work and study visas.

Frenchgalinspain Mon 17-Nov-25 15:11:06

"If a government believes a country is safe and they have not lived or travelled thoroughly in that country; perhaps they should live in that country for 1 year, and then see if it is safe for those seeking Asylum" ..

Such horrorific measures slashed upon desperate peoples and their children.

There are so many types of labour that could be a justified means of living in Asylum in another country, be it The U.K. or The European Union.

Spinnaker Mon 17-Nov-25 15:09:17

It'll never happen while we're hamstrung by ECHR. Just wish this/previous governments would grow some balls regarding this issue.

StripeyGran Mon 17-Nov-25 15:04:44

Enver Soloman, I heard him today. He was very measured in what he said and it made sense.

Calendargirl Mon 17-Nov-25 14:59:14

The CEO of the Refugee Council, can’t recall his name, thinks it won’t work.

In the words of Mandy Rice Davies ‘Well, he would say that, wouldn’t he?’

Kandinsky Mon 17-Nov-25 14:54:00

I admire her for trying to tackle this problem, but too many snowflakes in this country who’ll try and stop her at every turn.
Happens all the time.

TerriBull Mon 17-Nov-25 14:07:35

In the finer detail, I believe in line with Denmark, it's been suggested the removal of jewellery. I don't like the idea of taking highly personal items such as wedding rings, or even religious symbols or personal keepsakes/heirlooms that would seem wrong to me.

Primrose53 Mon 17-Nov-25 13:55:18

It will never work because lawyers will say their countries are not safe. They will be fighting over each other to represent these people.

Oreo Mon 17-Nov-25 13:50:42

If our government deems it safe I should think, since we’re the ones giving asylum.

Mollygo Mon 17-Nov-25 13:46:28

^Under the plans, asylum seekers will be returned home if their country is deemed safe, most will have to wait 20 years to apply to settle permanently, with deportations sped up when claims are rejected.
I’d like to know,
Who decides when and if a country is safe?
What do you think.