Will you be watching the results?

I’m relieved Reform didn’t win, unsurprised that Mini Trump is spouting racist nonsense about cheating Muslims. Disgusting creep. Staff report nothing to see, why not believe them.

I’m not keen on Green policies , especially on drugs and so called sex work. Im pleased Gorton and Denton have an MP with the kind of back story previous Labour MPs had. she sounds like a fighter well aware of the growing gap between hard working people (🌞) and the wealthy. A great addition to Westminster

Andy Burnham needed there as well, though I don’t want to lose him as our mayor

Message removed as it quotes a deleted post.

sixandahalf

I don't think " Asians" are an amorphous blob. Some of them , even women, can apparently think for themselves. Amazing!

My thoughts exactly.

A disappointing, if rather predictable result. Reform didn’t have the landslide some assured us would happen, which is a relief.

Some Green policies are good, IMO, but on the whole a Green government would be disastrous, I think. They tend to seem nice people, despite their anti-feminism, but it doesn’t feel as though some of their flagship policies have been thought through.

Graphite

In related news ... later today, Farage is expected to announce that Matt Goodwin will be given the title Shadow MP.

😂😂😂

I’m afraid that Goodwin has been rechristened by some SM posters. Now known as Badloss.

His ‘concession’ speech was appalling.

Observers did see 12% of voters take part in family voting we don't know if that affected the result, probably not this time but a close result could be affected so I think should be banned.

Andy Burnham probably would have held the seat for Labour - another own goal for Starmer.

In related news ... later today, Farage is expected to announce that Matt Goodwin will be given the title Shadow MP.

I hope Labour take the lesson that tacking to the right is not the way to go.

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

David49

What were the greens offering Asians in Groton and Denton
that Labour were not?

They were offering a decent ‘working class’ candidate on a progressive policy programme against a bile filled racist and a corporate lobbyist.

I suspect that had Burnham been allowed to run he would have won it for Labour but there was so much fear of a challenge to Starmer. I suspect that this cowardly act alone lost Labour a lot of voters. Starmer will be challenged anyway..

REKA

I'll probably see it because I don't go to bed until the early hours. No idea how it's going to go. Greens seem to be in the lead with Labour and Reform jostling behind them.

I think it's a great pity that Starmer didn't allow Andy Burnham to stand. He's popular in Manchester and could possibly have won.

Time will tell!

Starmer is/was too scared of Andy Burnham to risk it. But I won’t be putting any money on the new Green MP retaining her seat at the next GE

eazybee

So there was 'family voting.' Not a term I have heard before.
The staff should have stopped it immediately.
If not, why not?

Because they say it didn’t happen. My take on it is, that there was probably a couple of instances of this - quite illegal and therefore needs addressing, but to such a low level that it barely registers.

It is just the Trump phenomenon we need to worry about.

Farage tweet: This election was a victory for sectarian voting and cheating.

Bad loser, mimicking his American hero. Ironic seeing that both men have been cheating their whole lives.

Goodwin lost to a young, white, working-class woman who can plumb and plaster. Clearly, she must be taking work away from white working-class men and that’s why the Equality Act must be abolished.

That will really stick in Farage’s craw and all the misogynists he surrounds himself with.

I agree, Maizie. A stunning result for Spencer and a heartfelt victory speech from her.

Whitewavemark2

Ladyleftfieldlover

Love how Farage is taking a page out of the trump playbook and saying there was cheating! Also love how the BBC is saying how Labour were pushed into third place yet barely mentioned the Tories in FOURTH.

Yes.

We are seeing a mini-Trump play out in real time. What a lot of nonsense it all is.

The Tories barely registered at 2%.

I’m disappointed by the Tory voting numbers, I want to see a resurgence from them, and I thought we’d see the first signs of that now, but it went the other way yesterday.

Where do you source your information please Cariad?

It's a fascinatimg take on life in a multicultural area of Greater Manchester.

David49

What were the greens offering Asians in Groton and Denton
that Labour were not?

It was clearly a protest vote, voters to the left who are angry with Labour, plus the core Green voters who went for them last time. I actually feel very encouraged by the result.

On the family voting issue, the people who are accountable are the polling station staff, because they are responsible for policing to make sure that votes are cast lawfully. Although it won’t have affected the vote by more than a few votes, it’s still important and needs to be addressed.

So there was 'family voting.' Not a term I have heard before.
The staff should have stopped it immediately.
If not, why not?

Ladyleftfieldlover

Love how Farage is taking a page out of the trump playbook and saying there was cheating! Also love how the BBC is saying how Labour were pushed into third place yet barely mentioned the Tories in FOURTH.

Yes.

We are seeing a mini-Trump play out in real time. What a lot of nonsense it all is.

The Tories barely registered at 2%.

I was posting what I heard reported on breakfast news, if ITV are incorrect I assume they will apologise and address their error.

My take on this by-election is that the electorate are willing to vote for anyone other than the main parties.

David49

What were the greens offering Asians in Groton and Denton
that Labour were not?

They didn't have to say a word to be offering them something. If you let people go up to a voting booth accompanied and cast the mans vote (whoever it is that is physically putting a cross on that paper) and if you do an election address in their language...rather than English (and even the candidate themselves does a section in it) you have conveyed the message. "The medium is the message".

Even if you literally don't say a word about "You're not expected to follow British ways and speak English" you've conveyed that message by doing those things.

The vote is a stand-in/main point for making it plain women are the equals of men in our country. Remember how hard our ancestors fought for us to be able to vote back at the beginning of the last century? The right to vote is one way to sum up "....and women are people and totally absolutely equal to men without having to do a long speech for it. The message is there in the expectation that we are the ones that cast our vote and we do it the way we have decided.

The non-verbal message was absolutely there - and will have been read and understood - and the message the Greens gave wasn't "this is our country...this is our ways....now join in and integrate and do things that way at points where it matters (eg voting and eg women fully treated as equals to men)". Instead they gave a very inappropriate message - which could easily be seen as = "men are more important", "you don't have to speak our language and adapt to our ways".

Love how Farage is taking a page out of the trump playbook and saying there was cheating! Also love how the BBC is saying how Labour were pushed into third place yet barely mentioned the Tories in FOURTH.

I don't think " Asians" are an amorphous blob. Some of them , even women, can apparently think for themselves. Amazing!

Family voting🙄

Farage is really scraping the bottom of the barrel now😱

Are we now going to have a few pages of tut tutting over a red herring?

I doubt very much if the Green candidate’s stunning 4,000 majority was the result ‘family voting’.😂

What were the greens offering Asians in Groton and Denton
that Labour were not?

A really good result. The family voting - I absolutely accept it was happening and the observers saw it . What I don’t understand is why staff didn’t do anything at the time. However the council is saying nothing was reported at the time to staff. So why didn’t the observers draw it to the stafff attention - but in the polling stations I used to use, staff would have been able to see, the booths were not out of sight

The tedious and well worn trope about Muslim families trotted out again.

Yawn.

Brow beaten? I don't think so.