Gransnet forums

News & politics

Starmer rebukes Trump

(155 Posts)
Smileless2012 Wed 04-Mar-26 19:28:27

Britain would not get directly involved in the Middle Eastern conflict without a thought through approach from the US and Israel.

Starmer said British troops are shooting down drones and missiles to protect American lives in the Middle East on our joint bases; that is the special relationship in action. Sharing intelligence every day to keep our people safe; that is the special relationship in action.

Hanging onto President Trump's latest words is not the special relationship in action.

Well done Keir.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 05-Mar-26 22:02:08

It is good to see that our closer working with Europe over defence is paying off .

The British air base in Cyprus has had a drone make a hole in one of its hangers. We aren’t talking major destruction here, but European powers have stated that they are working together to secure Europe's interests in the combat zone. So expect to see craft of various nationalities in various locations throughout this region for the duration of the war by USA and Israel on Iran . I assume there is coordinated planning as to what is best deployed where.

Casdon Thu 05-Mar-26 21:53:48

Freya5

Casdon

Whitewavemark2

I actually think that there is a lot of enthusiasm for warmongers on these threads. Provided of course that they don’t have to take part , but can sit on the sidelines snipping.

There is very little enthusiasm for diplomacy.

You may be right Whitewavemark2. Whatever people think though I’d prefer if they just gave their views instead of constantly bemoaning what they don’t like, but offering no alternatives.

Seeing as non of us are in Government, it doesn't really matter what we say, does it. Whatever alternatives from us will not be listened to. We still have freedom of speech, so are entitled to say exactly as we please.
As Ricky says" just because you're offended, does not make you right".
Again anyone who disagrees with starmer, actually a puppet of hermet and milliband, who were not elected to govern but seem to have too much clout, you class as a warmonger. Disgraceful.still expect nothing else from you and w2.

It exposes people if they don’t have the wherewithal to respond thoughtfully about their own view, or to the posts of others, so I don’t take what they say seriously, that’s all Freya5. I’m sure most don’t care about that, but as you say we are all entitled to our view, including me.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 05-Mar-26 21:52:29

Maremia

At least he's not in the Epstein Files.

Nor has he ever cosied up to the Russians.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 05-Mar-26 21:48:14

Why has the task of protecting our soldiers and their families on Cyprus has fallen to France, Greece and Spain?

It’s a national embarrassment.

Maremia Thu 05-Mar-26 21:44:32

At least he's not in the Epstein Files.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 05-Mar-26 21:42:42

Starmer is unable to lead his Cabinet, let alone the Country. Cometh the hour, cometh the man? So much for that aphorism, Starmer has proved it wrong!

Oreo Thu 05-Mar-26 21:30:38

It makes you realise how little the UK now has for defensive purposes.We have nuclear, yes, but as we see, you actually need ships as well. Conventional weapons and manpower.
When Greece ( Greece!) and France can send ships before we can it’s coming to something.

Oreo Thu 05-Mar-26 21:27:06

Freya anyone used to forums takes jaw dropping comments with a hefty pinch of salt wink

Freya5 Thu 05-Mar-26 21:22:02

AGAA4

The ship you talk about going to Cyprus is being loaded with ammunition and will be there next week not in a fortnight.
The MOD is intercepting drone attacks on Cyprus. There are RAF typhoons already deployed

Wow that's amazing preparation.

Freya5 Thu 05-Mar-26 21:20:50

Casdon

Whitewavemark2

I actually think that there is a lot of enthusiasm for warmongers on these threads. Provided of course that they don’t have to take part , but can sit on the sidelines snipping.

There is very little enthusiasm for diplomacy.

You may be right Whitewavemark2. Whatever people think though I’d prefer if they just gave their views instead of constantly bemoaning what they don’t like, but offering no alternatives.

Seeing as non of us are in Government, it doesn't really matter what we say, does it. Whatever alternatives from us will not be listened to. We still have freedom of speech, so are entitled to say exactly as we please.
As Ricky says" just because you're offended, does not make you right".
Again anyone who disagrees with starmer, actually a puppet of hermet and milliband, who were not elected to govern but seem to have too much clout, you class as a warmonger. Disgraceful.still expect nothing else from you and w2.

Oreo Thu 05-Mar-26 21:14:16

He has terrible personal poll ratings Freya and on a purely anecdotal basis I know plenty of Labour voters who like me are beyond disappointed with Starmer.Have read the same by many posters on this forum too.

Freya5 Thu 05-Mar-26 21:08:19

ViceVersa

nanna8

The majority support Starmer? That’s not what we’re hearing over in NZ and Oz. I think he is absolutely and unequivocally the worst PM you have ever had. Still, Im obviously in a minority.

The worst PM we've ever had? I'm not even a particular fan of his, but you're got to be joking there!

Nanna is right, as decided by most of the UK population. See the polls. Ask the person in the street.

Maremia Thu 05-Mar-26 16:47:06

I wish the others in the room, who were calling out to stop hurting him, could have done more.

Fallingstar Thu 05-Mar-26 16:36:01

imaround

That is true Maremia. The Senator and his guards broke this veterans hand while trying to eject him from a meeting after he objected to the war.

It seems nobody can protest without suffering injury or murder. Were enough people restraining the Marine, this should not have happened.

AGAA4 Thu 05-Mar-26 16:27:31

That's barbaric. What is Trump doing to the US.

imaround Thu 05-Mar-26 16:21:30

AGAA4

So.if you oppose the Trump regime you get hurt?

Or killed.

imaround Thu 05-Mar-26 16:19:06

This is just the first article that popped up with the video.

A sitting US Senator broke a US Veterans hand for opposing the war.

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/tim-sheehy-iran-war-protester-senate-b2932413.html

AGAA4 Thu 05-Mar-26 16:17:34

So.if you oppose the Trump regime you get hurt?

imaround Thu 05-Mar-26 16:15:51

That is true Maremia. The Senator and his guards broke this veterans hand while trying to eject him from a meeting after he objected to the war.

Maremia Thu 05-Mar-26 16:08:29

One USA army officer is seen on video being forced out of a meeting for objecting to the war. He tried to resist the expulsion,and from the audio, it seems his hand/wrist was broken.

imaround Thu 05-Mar-26 16:02:00

theworriedwell

imaround

thanks

Thank you to Starmer and the people of Great Briton for trying to keep our soldiers, and yours, safe.

They deserve better than to be ruled by this monster. 6 US soldiers have already been killed for this illegal war, and these soldiers can not deny orders.

Soldiers can and should refuse to obey illegal orders. Following orders is no excuse for war crimes.

I agree. Soldiers have been filing complaints for a year, but since those end with Trump & company nothing is being done. They are following the proper channels. These soldiers would end up in Leavenworth for not following orders and desertion until such time as a new Administration came in and released them.

I hope when the time comes, these soldiers do the right thing.
But it isn't so black and white, like everything else in the world. They certainly wont be refusing to get on the planes now will they? How would that work out for them I wonder?

Fallingstar Thu 05-Mar-26 15:31:52

I loathe the regime Cossy, and would like nothing more than for the Iranian people to rise up with a suitable grass roots opposition and leader, albeit that they would have had to stay underground, and if western governments then helped them get rid of the regime I would be over the moon.
Regime change is for the Iranians to initiate.
As Starmer said you can’t intiate regime change from the skies you can only drop bombs.

Cossy Thu 05-Mar-26 15:26:35

Fallingstar

REKA this war hasn’t be planned for years, the very reason it has caught everyone on the back foot is because it wasn’t planned at all. For years US presidents have favoured diplomacy with Iran for reasons we can see all too clearly now. Even Trump chose diplomacy up until a few days ago. Netanyahu has been baying for this war for years, that much is true but previous presidents would find a way to rein him in.
And if this is about regime change/helping ordinary Iranians why were those living in one of the most densely populated cities in Iran, and indeed the region, not given warning so that they could leave, as happened last year when there were strikes in Iran. They are now trapped with bombs dropping on them day and night. Seems like a weird kind of liberation to me. More like elimination.

Sadly, I agree. I see yet more unnecessary deaths. I don’t agree with US/Israeli strikes, that doesn’t mean I think, condone or agree with the regime in Iran (or many other countries, for that matter!)

Cossy Thu 05-Mar-26 15:24:37

Whitewavemark2

freya you are teaching your grandmother etc. - what you have complained about not happening is exactly what is actually happening - all of it.

The only thing the U.K. is NOT doing is pre-emptive strikes which are illegal.

👏👏👏👏👏👏

Casdon Thu 05-Mar-26 15:24:24

How many alternative realities we inhabit REKA.