Gransnet forums

News & politics

A general election (democratic eh not like Hamas) is taking place in Israel on Tuesday next week.

(228 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 25-Oct-26 13:04:42

Israel has lost patience after nearly 80 years of terrorism and attacks from neighbouring states.

They are getting nothing but abuse whatever they do and never see fair reporting about the behaviour of their opponents.

They may as well completely absorb Gaza and the West Bank and evict any who don’t like it.

Those Arabs who stay and give up on violence will then have much improved futures compared to that on offer from Hamas.

In my opinion.

Wyllow3 Tue 27-Oct-26 17:41:31

FriedGreenTomatoes2

This small video helped shape my support for Israel.

Taken from a debate at Oxford union by a Jewish woman who attended Cambridge.

Anyone dispute her account of events? She did her homework that’s for sure.

youtu.be/VtrcRlBWnMk?is=rj-1zG1DIiNdANTe

Yes I did watch it FGT.

What you appear to be unaware of is a whole number of respected scholars who are speaking out and telling a completely different tale

Its not adequate to watch and take just one source as "truth

There are whole numbers on the internet, this is just one.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiYDGmhnWqY

News and Politics does not "require" uni level arguments, but if you are going to do so, then its wise to check out other views too

Wyllow3 Tue 27-Oct-26 17:44:10

It's also normal that that speaker at the Cambridge Union debating society had a speaker following, with counter views. Did you search?

Wyllow3 Tue 27-Oct-26 17:48:32

I've also returned to your video and noticed:

we don't have a date she spoke

we don't have her name

The person posting the video is not the speaker and has edited the video (there is a bit missing out) for their purposes

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 17:56:08

News and Politics does not "require" uni level arguments, but if you are going to do so, then its wise to check out other views too

Honestly I do love how some posters think that those of us who are more right leaning don’t read/ watch anything that doesn’t coincide with our political biases. 😁

To be honest I think it’s a bit insulting to assume that this is the case.

Maremia Tue 27-Oct-26 18:04:10

Very relevant points Wyllow.
Not holding my breath until they are addressed.

Wyllow3 Tue 27-Oct-26 18:08:40

You said clearly you had watched just one video, and that had helped you make up your mind.
Nothing to do with you being right wing at all.

Its not in "chat" and its not a trivial issue nor a personal attack on you ..... you not only posted it but sought to remind us and re-draw our attention to it.

If a left winger posted one short video and said it had been of key influence to them

then tbh other left wingers would say, hang on a moment, we have no name, no date, and its been edited.

Cossy Tue 27-Oct-26 19:19:09

FriedGreenTomatoes2

As in so many things in life we shall have to agree to disagree.

That’s fine. I’m happy to agree to disagree and I also completely agree we do see things differently.

I’m absolutely sure though that both of us would dearly love to a peaceful end to all of this thanks

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 20:50:50

Indeed Cossy 🤞

Polls are now closed.

Maremia Tue 27-Oct-26 21:01:26

And soon we will know.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-26 21:12:10

I guess if Netanyahu is indeed ousted then he will be joining Bolsonaro in the USA - the home of the corrupt, warmongering and law breaking politicians.

MG55 Tue 27-Oct-26 21:15:51

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Appeasement has been tried and it doesn’t work so victory for Netanyahu please. The West needs his strength.

Oh my goodness! His strength? The West needs peace not war.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 21:19:44

His strength at keeping Hamas at bat aided and abetted by Iran.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 21:21:44

Have you seen the UK news today? Iran recruiting and organising that attack on

Maremia Tue 27-Oct-26 21:23:01

Too close to call says The Guardian

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 21:24:22

posted too soon -
the RAF Fairford terror plot?

PollyEsther Tue 27-Oct-26 21:25:21

It will have to be a coalition of some sort, so it depends on the deals going on behind the scenes.

Maremia Tue 27-Oct-26 21:28:43

And apparently it can take months.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 21:30:19

Anyway - Nice to see the only democracy in the Middle East in action.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 27-Oct-26 21:33:43

Maremia

And apparently it can take months.

But I assume we will know pretty soon if there is no overall winner? What happens during the interim? Hopefully the killing and maiming will cease - or least for the duration, - or does the warmonger remain in post until the new formation? God forbid.

Maremia Tue 27-Oct-26 21:40:40

It's only a democracy if all citizens have equal rights. Otherwise, it's called apartheid.

PollyEsther Tue 27-Oct-26 21:54:20

Whitewavemark2

Maremia

And apparently it can take months.

But I assume we will know pretty soon if there is no overall winner? What happens during the interim? Hopefully the killing and maiming will cease - or least for the duration, - or does the warmonger remain in post until the new formation? God forbid.

I believe Netanyahu stays until a new government can be formed.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 22:47:37

According to Channel 14, Netanyahu, Likud, and the right-wing coalition are at 61-62. Despite all the spin about the opposition and the Arab parties and Likud, the largest party, lost votes, etc., if this holds the government effectively won re-election. We will know shortly.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 27-Oct-26 22:56:50

Maremia

It's only a democracy if all citizens have equal rights. Otherwise, it's called apartheid.

Remind me how they and who are permitted to "vote" in Iran?

PollyEsther Tue 27-Oct-26 23:09:16

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Maremia

It's only a democracy if all citizens have equal rights. Otherwise, it's called apartheid.

Remind me how they and who are permitted to "vote" in Iran?

That's irrelevant. Nobody is suggesting that Israel should adopt a system like Iran.

Maremia is right. The rights of minorities have to be protected in a democracy. Otherwise the majority could vote to annihilate the minority. In a country such as Israel where many people vote along religious lines, Arabs are at a permanent disadvantage.

PollyEsther Tue 27-Oct-26 23:11:25

FriedGreenTomatoes2

According to Channel 14, Netanyahu, Likud, and the right-wing coalition are at 61-62. Despite all the spin about the opposition and the Arab parties and Likud, the largest party, lost votes, etc., if this holds the government effectively won re-election. We will know shortly.

Channel 14 is biased. The BBC is suggesting the Eisenkot bloc has a slight lead.