Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

On the BBC News!

(7 Posts)
Wheniwasyourage Thu 20-Jun-13 22:28:05

What is the difference between broken bones and fractures, for pete's sake? When I was at medical school many years ago there was none, but possibly evolution since then has caused a change and I am missing something? Just heard a report on the news which mentioned people suffering from both. I would think that just one of them would be distressing enough for the poor souls.

nanaej Thu 20-Jun-13 23:12:24

To an ignorant lay person like me a 'break' sounds like a complete 100% break and a fracture a bit like a torn branch on a tree still partly attached!!

I am sure that is not right but in my head that's what I see!! grin

annodomini Thu 20-Jun-13 23:17:38

When I was a Girl Guide, I learnt all about the different kinds of fracture. When I was 3, I had a greenstick fracture of the elbow which is a name that really speaks for itself. Could that be what you mean nanej?

Notso Fri 21-Jun-13 07:43:54

I've aways understood that a broken bone means it's in two separate pieces and a fracture means the bone is cracked.

I'm not sure why, but a greenstick fracture sounds the most painful!

Charleygirl Fri 21-Jun-13 10:06:05

A broken bone is a fracture, there is no difference.

It is the way that it is described in medical terms, ie a surgeon will not discuss a broken hip with another doctor or surgeon but he will discuss a fractured neck of femur for example.

A "fracture" is described as "broken" in layman's terms.

Bags Fri 21-Jun-13 14:25:28

I think we can count the BBC as 'lay' with regard to these terms. I suspect whoever was using the terms was doing so as nanaej and notso describe. Medics, like other professions, have their own jargon which the rest of us can't be expected to know much about.

Leeway for lay persons, please! wink

gracesmum Fri 21-Jun-13 23:01:38

But a fracture sounds so much more impressive, just as HM never has a "cold", but a chill grin