Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Inaccuracies in books

(106 Posts)
Sparklefizz Fri 18-Jan-19 13:13:44

I have just finished "The May Bride" by Suzannah Dunn which is the story of Jane Seymour, but Dunn has written an historical novel and given the characters modern day speech, so characters comment on a pregnant woman's "bump", or say things like "he's a decent bloke", and "Time to grow up, sunshine!" Aaaaarrrgh. It drove me mad and I had to force myself to finish the book but I won't be reading any more of hers.

It seems I am to have no respite because I have just started "The Heart's Invisible Furies" which has annoying errors as Farmor15 mentions above.

paddyann Fri 18-Jan-19 12:29:22

The new Mary Queen of Scots film having the tow queens meet and giving Mary a Scottish accent when she grew up in France .I know its not a documentary but there are those who will believe every word...like they did about Wallace ...when wee Mel Gibson played the man who was a tall person.
The other film that really annoyed me was My Sisters Keeper where they changed the ending and spoiled the story .Why do they do this?

BlueBelle Fri 18-Jan-19 12:11:23

I loved The long white cloud series I don’t think I m observant enough to notice things like that I just get lost in the story probably says more about me than the author I do think I d notice about decimal money though

sodapop Fri 18-Jan-19 12:05:28

Yes and spelling errors or the use of incorrect words. Spoils my enjoyment of the book.

Jalima1108 Fri 18-Jan-19 12:03:07

I find it extremely annoying too!
Some of the obvious mistakes you have pointed out are ludicrous - don't these authors do any research at all?

I started reading a book called In the Land of the Long White Cloud set in the early days of New Zealand. It has some modern-day American expressions in conversations in the book which just spoil it for me.

I've abandoned it in favour of a terrific book written by one of our very own Gransnetters!

Farmor15 Fri 18-Jan-19 11:56:55

Does anyone else get distracted when reading novels by mistakes? Not spelling or grammar errors but mistakes about the past. I know authors of fiction can alter some things for the sake of the story, but I'll give some examples of things I've read recently that I found annoying:

In an historical novel by Ian Mortimer he described a workhouse in 1740s England - workhouses didn't start till 1800s. In the same book, the main character was going to a cinema in 1942 - and the sign said "Screen One". To my knowledge, this term only started being used in 1970s/80s when the multiplexes started.

I'm now reading "The Heart's Invisible Furies" and while I'm enjoying it, and realise it's a kind of fantasy novel, it still annoys me that 50 pence pocket money was being given in 1959, when it would have been 10 shillings.

When I find these kind of errors, I look at the author profile, and usually find they are relatively young, so writing about times they haven't lived through.

I think this just means I'm a pedant, but can't help it!