Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Baked Potatoes versus Jacket Potatoes?

(166 Posts)
mae13 Tue 23-Jan-24 11:12:51

I call them "Baked" potatoes but a friend calls them "Jacket" potatoes and further insists that referring to them as "baked" is a sign of being "common". Really?
Give me strength!
She IS a bit of a Hyacinth......

flappergirl Wed 24-Jan-24 07:06:28

In the West Country we always called them baked potatoes. Then the word "jacket" started to creep into the vocabulary somewhere around the late 70's.

I'm not sure if the word was imported from America or was adopted from another region of the UK. Or perhaps it was the result of a marketing ploy by someone invested in potatoes.

At first we weren't sure exactly what it meant but certainly by the mid 80's it had become common parlance amongst younger people.

Most people my age and older (I'm 67) still refer to it as a baked potato but would use the word "jacket" if ordering in a restaurant or speaking to someone younger because otherwise it causes confusion.

They are sold as "baking potatoes" and I consider this to be the correct word.

Mollygo Thu 25-Jan-24 08:58:39

I’ve just checked and our school menu offers baked jacket potatoes obviously catering for both the common and posh among us.

Esmay Thu 25-Jan-24 09:06:10

Haven't heard of this !
I think that I call them baked and I used to call them jacket , because baked has replaced jacket in every day use where I live .

If your friend is so posh - she wouldn't actually mention the word common !
Perhaps , she's half baked !

Oreo Thu 25-Jan-24 09:08:28

I call them baked potatoes, but DD’s say jacket potatoes.On menus they always say jacket, I think it makes it clearer to customers what they will actually be getting.

welbeck Thu 25-Jan-24 09:14:48

that's a point; to me baked sounds more like roasted.
but i am not a foodie . . .

welbeck Thu 25-Jan-24 09:18:54

what distinguishes said potatoes is that the jacket is left on, they are cooked entire, so you get the option of eating the jacket as well as soft inner.
so that's the selling point, i think.
those who like to eat the jackets, or are hungrier, get their money's worth.
if someone doesn't want to eat the jacket, they can just eat the inner, and leave an empty jacket behind on the plate.
and the wondrous fillings ! who could resist.

Grannynannywanny Thu 25-Jan-24 09:23:43

The baked jacket/skin is my favourite part and there’s no way I’d be leaving a tasty oven baked skin on the plate 😋

welbeck Thu 25-Jan-24 09:50:36

and filled skins used to be a menu option too.
don't see that so much now.

toscalily Thu 25-Jan-24 09:51:03

Not so tasty when microwaved, but a potato, not wrapped up in foil, skin rubbed with butter, topped with lots of cheese, (none of those mucky beans please) is a simple joy.

Cossy Fri 26-Jan-24 11:17:51

Jacket or baked is absolutely fine, baked certainly isn’t considered common in our home!

Shantygirly Fri 26-Jan-24 11:20:10

They are potatoes baked in their jackets. Your friend is a silly snob!

Mojack26 Fri 26-Jan-24 11:20:37

Well I'm common too! Baked Potato for me. If that's all she's got to worry about...???? 🤣🤣🤣

Hammo Fri 26-Jan-24 11:25:43

Clever 😂! I like that!! I also like baked potatoes 😊! Fun cheery up thread!

MBM Fri 26-Jan-24 11:45:33

I suppose your Posh friends
( Baked , Jacket )(Potatoes
Had Mink Coats on

Witzend Fri 26-Jan-24 11:52:40

Marmin

I always do three more potatoes when having baked. They go in with the leeks to make soup the next day. Makes a big difference: in a good way!

I’m trying to steer clear of bread, so I often microwave a couple of jacket potatoes to slice when cold and fry in just a film of oil, to have with e.g. scrambled egg. (Only one at a time, I’m not quite that much of a 🐷).

Growing0ldDisgracefully Fri 26-Jan-24 12:08:18

MBM would that be potatoes which had gone mouldy and growing a furry covering? 😂
We're not posh in our house - if I'm asked by my son "what's fer tea" (family phrase), my answer is "spuds"! Which means potatoes cooked in their skins and then some sort of topping on them, each according to their own preferences.
There is a preset on the microwave for 'jacket potato' but if I had to choose the term I'd more likely call them baked!
Nowadays I do them partly in the microwave to start them off, finish in the air fryer to crisp up the skins, so not sure if either of those cooking methods counts as baked?

Alison333 Fri 26-Jan-24 12:25:33

Bella23

I'm common as well we had baked potatoes yesterday They are called baking potatoes on the bag not jacketing potatoes.

Very funny! smile

icanhandthemback Fri 26-Jan-24 12:26:26

Aren't they Jacket Baked Potatoes? We shorten it to just "Jackets" in our house!

GrandmaLorna Fri 26-Jan-24 12:37:26

When on holiday in Turkey we saw a menu with "jacked potato "......so that's what they are called now!

win Fri 26-Jan-24 12:41:33

Unbelievable 5 pages about Jacket or baked potatoes, Hilarious!! Here in the South it is definitely JP for every day use, but when we discuss menus I do know some people say Baked Potatoes. I am just waiting for my JP to be ready I am looking forward to it with lashings of cheddar.

Sennelier1 Fri 26-Jan-24 12:55:04

We call it ovenpotatoes but have no problem with what other people call them. I learned the term jacket potatoes when travelling to America. Where I live baked potatoes are cooked potatoes cut in slices then baked on a pan on the hob 🤷🏼‍♀️ Who cares! Is there a social rang in potato-dishes? Because I like mash and fries too!

NotSpaghetti Fri 26-Jan-24 13:08:22

Win it's SO lovely that we can chat, disagree, exchange thoughts about potatoes 🥔 ... and still have no aggravation.

Happy day!
🌞

SueEH Fri 26-Jan-24 13:21:50

We don’t even bother with calling them potatoes… they’re just jackets. Tho I did have to explain this to an American friend recently.

missdeke Fri 26-Jan-24 13:26:57

Common as in more frequently used?

Peaches7 Fri 26-Jan-24 13:36:59

I've always called them jacket potatoes,and I am no where near posh