Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

What do you think to this?

(22 Posts)
Witzend Fri 20-Feb-26 15:02:52

I’ve seen this a few times lately - is it me, or should it be ‘What do you think OF this?’

‘To’ this sounds all wrong to me!

Patsy70 Fri 20-Feb-26 15:08:12

I agree with you.

teabagwoman Fri 20-Feb-26 15:12:19

I agree with you too.

Fallingstar Fri 20-Feb-26 15:15:42

Is it an Americanism?
Have heard it but not very often.
It sounds wrong.

argymargy Fri 20-Feb-26 15:36:32

American, of course. Don't get us all started!!

RosiesMawagain Fri 20-Feb-26 15:53:08

Not American, Northern.
"I don't think much to it" could come straight out of Coronation St.

BlueBelle Fri 20-Feb-26 16:13:08

I must admit that’s what I would say what do you think of this

keepingquiet Fri 20-Feb-26 16:24:32

RosiesMawagain

Not American, Northern.
"I don't think much to it" could come straight out of Coronation St.

I agree- we say this up here and don't care what other people think to it!

Oreo Fri 20-Feb-26 16:45:27

I think both versions sound ok and could be correct.

argymargy Fri 20-Feb-26 16:48:20

Oooh yes I stand corrected! Apologies to all Northerners. I don't and wouldn't say it - I'm happy to hear it in a proper northern accent. smile

Cabbie21 Fri 20-Feb-26 17:03:54

I might say either but I did live in Yorkshire for many years

Fallingstar Fri 20-Feb-26 17:06:56

Well am originally from North Lancs and they don’t say this, must be a Yorkshire thing. No wonder they lost the war of the roses 🤣

BlueBelle Fri 20-Feb-26 17:21:17

Well I ve never lived anywhere near Yorkshire I mEast Anglia and that’s what I would say ‘what do you think of this’ sounds right I think ‘to’ sounds ok as well I might even say ‘what do you think about this’

Patsy70 Fri 20-Feb-26 17:28:37

My apologies to all the Northern grans on GN.

Oldnproud Fri 20-Feb-26 17:29:45

Cabbie21

I might say either but I did live in Yorkshire for many years

Same here, on both points.

AuntieE Sat 21-Feb-26 13:54:18

I have never heard what do you think to this, so it must surely be a very localized dialect form.

I was brought up to say either what do you think of this, or about this. In the west of Scotland you can think on something, too. Especially in the usage I was think on what you said, where thinking on conveys that considering theother person's opinion,.

Scribbles Sat 21-Feb-26 15:43:44

I can't see anything wrong with either form and suspect I've probably used both at different times without ever giving the matter any conscious thought.

BoggledMind Sat 21-Feb-26 23:37:14

I'm from up north and may well have said it at some point.

I also say "What do you think to this?" and "What do you think about this?"

crazyH Sat 21-Feb-26 23:47:20

What do you think of this ?
What do you think about this ?
Never heard anyone ask ‘What do you think to this?’

RosiesMawagain Sat 21-Feb-26 23:49:31

keepingquiet

RosiesMawagain

Not American, Northern.
"I don't think much to it" could come straight out of Coronation St.

I agree- we say this up here and don't care what other people think to it!

Thank you- I felt I was a voice in the wilderness!

Nannee49 Sat 21-Feb-26 23:58:47

It's Yorkshire but doesn't it perfectly illustrate how it's not always Americanisms or text speak or yoof slang which change language but can be regional stuff spoken locally for years now becoming widespread through social media.

crazyH Sun 22-Feb-26 00:14:29

There isn’t much to it ! I’ve heard that