Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Poppy’s!!

(56 Posts)
Witzend Thu 22-Oct-26 10:15:56

I’ve seen it twice today!
I know I shouldn’t get worked up about people’s inability to make plurals of words ending in Y, but…🤬

Skodadoda Sat 24-Oct-26 13:56:27

MaizieD

It's not so much the inability to make plurals of words ending i Y so much as the inability to understand the difference between the 's' used to denote a plural and the 'apostrophe s' used to denote possession.

I'm afraid I put it down to the era of teaching English when anything went so long as the reader could 'make meaning' from what was written and grammar was a dirty word.

Not that insistence on learning 'grammar' for the past decade has made much difference because the 'grammar' curriculum which was brought in was highly technical and unnecessarily complex 😡

I agree with all of that.

Kitty55 Sat 24-Oct-26 13:57:47

It’s seems English is becoming a lost art.

Alison333 Sat 24-Oct-26 13:59:52

I was at primary school in the 1960s and we did have punctuation and grammar drilled into us.

I still remember 'never split an infinitive' and yet my laptop's grammar checker tells me that 'To go boldly' is wrong and I should put 'To boldly go'!

MaizieD Sat 24-Oct-26 14:14:56

I understand that not splitting the infinitive is a rule made up by Latin scholars long ago because in Latin the infinitive is never split. Which isn't surprising because in Latin the infinitive is one word. Which can't be split...

I don't know why people are apparently happy with their disregard of spelling, punctuation and grammar (SPAG). I thought the purpose of writing things was to convey information and ideas and observing correct SPAG makes what is written much easier and faster to understand.

Punctuation isn't just a series of obscure signs in random places. It gives additional information as to how a text is to be read.

But then, I'm pedant to the core grin

polly123 Sat 24-Oct-26 14:28:12

For me it is the confusion of less and fewer!

DS54 Sat 24-Oct-26 14:32:25

You can’t assume someone is using their first language or has been educated in the UK. I make huge bloopers when using my second language but usually native speakers meet me halfway.

Marmin Sat 24-Oct-26 14:49:02

As a retired english teacher used to reading these comments over the years I often wonder why the standard of mental arithmetic never seems to attract the same levels of outrage.

AuntieE Sat 24-Oct-26 14:58:02

What level of education people have is irrelevant to this discussion.

Anyone who was taught that apostrophes have two functions, namely to denote the possessive case as in John's book or to show that some letters have been omitted, as in I'll attend to this later will never put apostrophe on a plural noun .

It boils down to two things: whether this grammitical detail was considered important or not, when and where we went to school, and whether we udenstood the explanation we were given.

Magenta8 Sat 24-Oct-26 15:01:41

Being dyslexic, I live in a glass house when discussions of this nature take place.

semperfidelis Sat 24-Oct-26 15:04:57

I was trained to be a primary school teacher in the late 1960s. It was a 'progressive' course in London.
On one occasion, we were sent out to a school in Oxfordshire to see teaching which was built on creating direct, meaningful experiences for young children. A number of different activities went on in the classes such as painting, reading, number work and creative writing. If something interesting happened - say a sudden storm- children were encouraged to write immediately from direct experience about what they heard and saw and felt. This was more important than getting every item of grammar in the right place.
I never forgot how much excitment those children enjoyed at school.
In contrast, my two older grandchildren never came home with a piece of creative writing; they were too concerned about the position of the commas and fullstops in a boring homework exercise.

FranP Sat 24-Oct-26 15:05:08

My son was in a biligual school where spelling was only taught when they hit junior and chose their main language. By that time we had moved, so he wa a little behind, but that was then the govt decided that spelling was no longer important - until six years later when suddenly they put it back into the GCSE marking.
I worked with a couple of young people who would (in the days before MS Word) send me their work to be checked before publishing. A friend worked for English Nature has her name on a number of learned scientific journals because she was the one who did the same for all these clever scientists, who never had spelling in school.

Nanny27 Sat 24-Oct-26 16:23:25

I also have a Master's degree and many years experience
As an English literature teacher at A level. I hope I would never make such a mistake.
Im reading that some people weren't taught the correct placement of apostrophes when in school but surely they've had many years to work it out since. Do people stop reading and writing on leaving school?

Oldnproud Sat 24-Oct-26 17:24:03

Nanny27

I also have a Master's degree and many years experience
As an English literature teacher at A level. I hope I would never make such a mistake.
Im reading that some people weren't taught the correct placement of apostrophes when in school but surely they've had many years to work it out since. Do people stop reading and writing on leaving school?

If one reaches school leaving age without being taught such things or working them out from what one has read and written during one's school years, I can't imagine that one would ever give such matters another thought unless there was a specific reason.

Im actually quite surprised that you are surprised that most people don't simply 'work it out' for themselves, just by 'reading and writing', after they have left school. grin

Romola Sat 24-Oct-26 17:24:19

Sorry if someone has said this already, but "Poppy's" is an example of the greengrocer's apostrophe.

Witzend Sat 24-Oct-26 18:44:34

crazyH

Oh Witzend - live and let live. My daughter has a Master’s and I still have to correct her occasionally- I think predictive spelling on phones and tablets is the cause .

This is pedants’ corner - we’re allowed to have a grouch.
If you’re not pedantically minded, perhaps it’s best to steer clear of this topic.

Silvertwigs Sat 24-Oct-26 18:59:02

Oldnproud Me to, secondary modern in the late 60s and early 70s. Education was just an experiment for that cohort

JenniferEccles Sat 24-Oct-26 19:09:06

How many people confuse anti-social and unsociable?

Witzend Sat 24-Oct-26 19:13:04

DS54

You can’t assume someone is using their first language or has been educated in the UK. I make huge bloopers when using my second language but usually native speakers meet me halfway.

TBH I often find that speakers of other languages have been taught better than native speakers, as to where to put apostrophes - or not - in English.

Mojack26 Sat 24-Oct-26 23:25:40

Witzend....I'm with you there!

Cagsy Sun 25-Oct-26 00:14:51

My DH is dyslexic, never diagnosed of course as he was born in the early 50s, it totally holds him back from ever trying to express himself in written language in case he’s seen as stupid. I have nephews who have the same issue but not the stigma, they hold down good jobs and one writes very creatively without embarrassment. I know which I prefer and I’d do anything to rid my DH of it holding him back.
I’m not the brightest of my peers but I was always good at English and I think that’s the only reason I passed my 11+ and went to grammar school, my DH was much better at maths, science, geography and probably would have benefitted more from that education than I did, but he couldn’t spell so of course he was excluded.

Deedaa Sun 25-Oct-26 00:27:53

I was at primary school in the 50s. Most of the children came from council estates and, being just after the war a lot were fairly deprived. Our teacher was determined that we would all learn to spell and use correct grammar so that people wouldn't think we were uneducated or common. No fronted adverbials for us but we were taught to spell, use commas and full stops, and use quotation marks and apostrophes correctly. A handful of children still followed the words in their reading book with their finger, but we were pretty literate.

Nanny27 Sun 25-Oct-26 01:22:43

Oldnproud
As we go through life, if we are reasonably well educated and literate people we notice spelling and perhaps punctuation in the course of everyday reading. I would expect to notice if an apostrophe was being used differently to my own use and begin to question.
This was my point which I can see differs to yours.

Musicgirl Sun 25-Oct-26 01:27:46

JenniRen

^I'm afraid I put it down to the era of teaching English when anything went so long as the reader could 'make meaning' from what was written and grammar was a dirty word.^

Child-centred education was a result of the Plowden Report. Correcting spelling and grammar in red ink daunted a child's imagination and could give them anxiety. Apparently.

Having a Master's degree does not excuse poor spelling.
I can remember when the ethos changed; a member of my family has a Master's (not in English) but is not great at spelling. He was at primary school in the 1960s.

Now autocorrect is to blame in many cases. It has some strange ideas.

I was born in the sixties and at school throughout the seventies and spelling and grammar were taught very thoroughly at my schools.

MG55 Sun 25-Oct-26 01:53:00

Nanny 27, you have made two errors in your comment 🙈
One missing apostrophe and one lack of a correct comma 🙈

MG55 Sun 25-Oct-26 01:55:02

Nanny27

I also have a Master's degree and many years experience
As an English literature teacher at A level. I hope I would never make such a mistake.
Im reading that some people weren't taught the correct placement of apostrophes when in school but surely they've had many years to work it out since. Do people stop reading and writing on leaving school?

The two mistakes are here if we are being pedantic 😅