Most of my dogs were cocker spaniels; one was born in the kitchen and never understood why, if she wee'd there when she was tiny she couldn't just carry on doing so. Sometimes I'd overlap a young dog with an old one that had become incontinent, so they got mixed messages. Then I had a whippet who, from the minute she came to my house as a puppy till the time just before she died and was struggling to walk, never once had an accident in the house. The latest whippet, alas, is one that will go for months without having an accident and then we have a couple of weeks of puddles. Like, now. Mind you, whippets hate rain [when will it ever stop raining, I ask myself] so she may be loathe to go out. My first dog was a cocker who went blind at quite a young age. She was so confused about not having access to the rooms that she's been used to that I resolved to always keep my dogs in the kitchen where, if they had accidents, it wouldn't matter. She used to bark in the night, not knowing day from night. Went to the vets about it and he gave her some valium; as I was about to leave he said to me 'by the way, it's for the dog..not you'....