Gransnet forums

Pets

Poo Bags-A Contentious issue

(45 Posts)
Diggingdoris Fri 21-Feb-25 10:57:42

After a walk round the countryside I counted over 50 poo bags left in trees or on the ground, which made me wonder, 'What did we use to do before doggy poo bags came on the market'?

Then that leads to the argument -should we stop using poo bags and let nature work it's magic?
How can we stop this litter?
More bins required I think, but will the council pay for them to be emptied?
I know there have been discussions about this in the past, but when I searched GN suggested I start a new thread.

ViceVersa Sat 22-Feb-25 10:41:01

Responsible dog owners, even without their dog, are the ones you sometimes see pull out a tissue when they sneeze, and find it’s a poo bag!
Oh yes, many a time I've done this - or gone into my pocket to find a pound coin for the shopping trolley and pulled out poo bags! grin

Marmin Sat 22-Feb-25 10:09:24

I avoid street walks with either of our dogs as the bigger issue is food related litter dropped and discarded by people. Trying to remove a half eaten pieces and packets of food from my dogs' mouths is far more prevalent than dog excrement.

Mollygo Sat 22-Feb-25 09:22:45

We pick our dog’s doings up and put them in a bin or bring them home. Even though there are plenty of poo/litter bins near us which are emptied by a man in a pristine white truck, some folk still leave it unbagged.
My funniest dog poo story?
We live at the top of a hill and people walk their dogs past the end of our garden. When one exhausted dog owner began to walk away from their dog’s poo, the sound of our dog barking, and us looking out at her caused her to turn back and walk up the path where she very apologetically asked if we could lend her a poo bag as she had come out without any.
We gave her a handful as a gift, not a loan and mentioned the bin at the end of the road.
Responsible dog owners, even without their dog, are the ones you sometimes see pull out a tissue when they sneeze, and find it’s a poo bag!

escaped Sat 22-Feb-25 09:20:04

Excuse the graphic description, but I also walk 2 large dogs, (who do large poos!), and I usually fill 3 bags. If I'm stopping at the Mill for coffee and cake, I don't take the bags in with me, but leave them on a branch where the walk veers left over thd bridge. I then go back for them later. It's the best I can do given the situation.

LovesBach Sat 22-Feb-25 09:03:00

Iam64

I have 2 dogs, I always pick up and carry the bags till I see a bin. No bins means I bring the bags home to go in my own black bin.
There need to be more bins. In my village we have a band of volunteers who litter pick. They’ve set up numerous green plastic bin bags on a hoop holder. They’re emptied frequently. Despite this, like everywhere else we have dog owners who don’t pick up.
My pet dislike are the ‘professional’ dog walkers who drive to our park, open their van doors and let 6-8 dogs run onto the grass . No one can pick up after 8 dogs as well as keep an eye on them as they race about. I’m a grump and would ban anyone walking more than 3 or 4 dogs and insist dogs on leads in parks

Then we are both 'grumps'. I feel sorry for the collection of dogs - sometimes about eight - being dragged along, large and small, with the tinier ones desperately trying to keep up and keep out of the way of much bigger animals. Those who do this are not dog lovers - they are running a business and the dogs are a commodity. Sadly people often feel as 'Skydancer' does - they perhaps begin to get annoyed with the dogs, but we all have to 'go', and they don't have the advantage of a bathroom. The truth is that with dogs, the problems are invariably at the other end of the lead.

ViceVersa Sat 22-Feb-25 09:00:13

It's not the fault of the dogs, it's irresponsible owners. On the other hand, dogs don't drop litter, fly tip or leave needles or other drug paraphernalia lying around. Give me dogs over humans any day of the week.

Shelflife Sat 22-Feb-25 08:59:31

I don't have a do but I do love dogs - long story! It is the height of responsibility to leave bags if dog poo hanging on trees or hedgerows - why on earth would anyone do that - disgusting behaviour.
Dogs can be trained to ' get busy' in their own gardens. If that is not possible for whatever reason , use a poo bin or take it home and pop it in the non recycling wheelie bin . It's not difficult!

Skydancer Sat 22-Feb-25 08:53:20

It’s vile. It’s everywhere. Disgusting. Why on earth are there so many dogs everywhere I go!

Sadgrandma Sat 22-Feb-25 08:51:17

We have a dog poo bin on a verge near our house. Sometimes when it’s full people leave their bags on top of it or on the ground nearby.This is disgusting. Why can’t they take it home or find another bin?

Iam64 Sat 22-Feb-25 08:09:26

I have 2 dogs, I always pick up and carry the bags till I see a bin. No bins means I bring the bags home to go in my own black bin.
There need to be more bins. In my village we have a band of volunteers who litter pick. They’ve set up numerous green plastic bin bags on a hoop holder. They’re emptied frequently. Despite this, like everywhere else we have dog owners who don’t pick up.
My pet dislike are the ‘professional’ dog walkers who drive to our park, open their van doors and let 6-8 dogs run onto the grass . No one can pick up after 8 dogs as well as keep an eye on them as they race about. I’m a grump and would ban anyone walking more than 3 or 4 dogs and insist dogs on leads in parks

LaCrepescule Sat 22-Feb-25 07:53:12

If I can’t find a bin for the poo bag I take it home with me. The same as I would for any type of litter. There are simply too many selfish people around who don’t consider others or their environment. I believe that in Tokyo there aren’t many bins and people simply take their litter home.

Calendargirl Sat 22-Feb-25 07:30:54

Far too many people own dogs who shouldn’t.

Far too irresponsible.

Diggingdoris Fri 21-Feb-25 22:53:27

Thank you all for your comments. Glad to see you are as passionate about this as I am. I always pick up, never go out without bags. I look around when I'm collecting my dogs poo and if I see some left by a lazy owner I pick that up in the same bag. If no bins around I bring it home.
It sounds as if Germany has the right idea.

traveller61 Fri 21-Feb-25 22:16:49

Our family dog we had back in the 60’s/70’s, there were no such thing of dog poo bags. Don’t think there was any rule. But my parents used to make sure the dog went to poo in the gutter, to pull him carefully over to gutter.

lixy Fri 21-Feb-25 17:23:50

NotSpaghetti

I think people do it intending to pick it up on the way back.

There are an awful lot of forgetful people around here then!

LovesBach Fri 21-Feb-25 17:23:31

NotSpaghetti

French streets have always need hosing down - especially in Paris where "canine ejections" are everywhere (inspite of fines coming in).

tamarathiessen.com/french-letters-dog-poop-france/

I could not agree more - we stayed in one particular arrondisement in Paris some years ago, and the amount of dog poo was revolting - even in shop doorways, and people were stepping carefully around it. My OH unfortunately trod in one deposit and skidded, almost losing his balance. A serious sense of humour failure resulted, as he had to go back to the hotel, and in fact threw the shoes away.

NotSpaghetti Fri 21-Feb-25 17:17:37

escaped I have never understood this. Even in the "nicest" areas people let their dogs mess up the pavements.
There was a truck out every morning when I was there last.

escaped Fri 21-Feb-25 17:12:47

NotSpaghetti

French streets have always need hosing down - especially in Paris where "canine ejections" are everywhere (inspite of fines coming in).

tamarathiessen.com/french-letters-dog-poop-france/

Fines don't work either. It's 135 euros in the town where we have a property, plus there are lots of "help yourself" bags, but no one takes any notice. French people look at us in a surprised way when we pick up poos off the beach.

Ilovedogs22 Fri 21-Feb-25 17:05:36

Ilovecheese

You could take the poo home and let nature work its magic in your own garden.

Exactly my thoughts exactly Ilovecheese.
Once while in a local field I commented on all the dog's poo about & a fellow walker said that it wasn't an issue as the local foxes eat it!!!
Glad I'm not a particularly hungry fox. 😚

Witzend Fri 21-Feb-25 16:49:51

When we had a dog I never used specific poo bags - just a sandwich bag with a piece of kitchen roll. And I disposed of it at home.
My local park has dedicated bins for ‘dog waste’ - I’ve hardly ever seen poo bags festooning trees or shrubs. But it’s pretty disgusting when people do this.

NotSpaghetti Fri 21-Feb-25 16:46:24

French streets have always need hosing down - especially in Paris where "canine ejections" are everywhere (inspite of fines coming in).

tamarathiessen.com/french-letters-dog-poop-france/

Tenko Fri 21-Feb-25 16:00:24

Poo bags dangling from trees or just left on the ground are one of my bugbears . I’ve had my own dogs for 30 years and always clear up after them and if no bins , take it home . My current dog sticks his bum in bushes but I still pick it up .
I’m in a litter picking group and it disgusts me what people leave behind .

Indigo8 Fri 21-Feb-25 15:01:28

I once parked in a forest carpark and went for a walk. When I came back somebody had picked up an enormous pile of shogdit wrapped it in a dark red paper napkin and placed it in the centre of the bonnet of my car.

To this day, I don't know why. I did not have a dog with me, in fact I have never owned a dog. There were people taking their dogs for a run in the forest but I was not one of them.

escaped Fri 21-Feb-25 14:44:37

dogsmother

Yes and on the rear windscreen wipers?

My DD does that when she takes the full poo bags home. She doesn't want the smelly poo bags in the car with the children while they have their drinks etc.

dogsmother Fri 21-Feb-25 14:27:53

Yes and on the rear windscreen wipers?