Gransnet forums

Relationships

Are all families like this? (The women keep contact)

(34 Posts)
JackyB Mon 23-May-16 11:56:32

In my DH's family, we regularly get together with all the cousins and spouses. The address list and the e-mailing is all done by the wife of one of his cousins.

On my side of the family, there is a first cousin once removed of mine who lives in America - it is his second wife who can tell us all the family gossip.

When skyping with DS and DiL, he just sits there and she tells us all the news.

It seems to be the usual thing that once you marry a man, you are expected to remember all his family's names, birthdays, and organise visits and Christmas card lists, while he is still struggling to work out what great-aunt or even a nephew is.

Do others find that it's the women who keep the family together like that, even when it's not their own blood relations?

Wendysue Thu 26-May-16 01:08:12

My deepest sympathies, Battersea. (((Hugs)))

Newquay Wed 25-May-16 21:43:06

Oh Battersea?

baNANAGran3 Wed 25-May-16 18:36:48

Absolutely!

alchemilla Wed 25-May-16 14:50:13

Horses for courses? I made sure I did the Christmas cards with my DH which kept him in touch with friends. I organise the sports teams, dinners etc. But as for keeping family together, my uncle is the driving force for a disparate family with a non-funeral/marriage get together this year. However this is partly because he feels he's the paterfamilias. I also suspect FB replaces the normal glue for those under 35.

Daddima Wed 25-May-16 10:48:28

My granny, on hearing that a mother or grandmother had died, would always say, " Ah, that's another home without a heart".
I think if there are daughters they're likely to have a more " family" mindset than sons.

lefthanded Wed 25-May-16 10:33:04

As the youngest of four brothers (3 surviving) I feel particularly qualified to comment on this thread. One of my brothers lives about 3 miles away, one about 230 miles away, and the family of my late oldest brother also over 200 miles away. I don't feel (and never have felt) any need to maintain contact with my brothers on a social level. I have not seen the brother who 3 miles away since Christmas and the one who lives "Ooop North" I haven't physically seen for about three years. It is not that we bear each other any animosity - simply that we move in different orbits.

I know that each of them is only a phone-call away. If I needed either of them I would ring them and I know that they would come to me. Likewise if they needed me, they would ring.

My wife, however, keeps contact with her three sisters-in-law, so the family contact does flow through her. Interestingly, she also keeps contact with her own cousins, 2nd cousins, and some "cousins" whose actual relationship is so tenuous that she can't even tell me exactly what relation they are!

So to answer the OP's point, yes I think it is a gender thing.

Witzend Wed 25-May-16 09:11:16

I think it's very common. My dh is one of several boys, and they had never bothered about birthdays cards etc. anyway, so I didn't have to either, except for his parents. There was always a lot more contact and communication in my girl-heavy family. I used to feel sorry for my lovely MiL sometimes, I think she was so glad to have someone to discuss new kitchen curtains with, who might actually be interested!

Battersea1971 Tue 24-May-16 17:09:01

If it was left to my husband nobody would receive a birthday or Christmas card.
He died two years ago and in spite of that I wish he was still here!!

mintsmum Tue 24-May-16 14:11:20

I can remember my father refusing to read letters from his brother or sister. He'd say to my mother "you read it and tell me what they say....".

pollyperkins Tue 24-May-16 11:49:47

Interesting! I do all the birthday and Christmas cards for family and put them in front of my husband to sign, like others! Also we have regular extended family get together from time to time, and it is ALWAYS the women (me, DiL, nieces etc ) who organise, although the men are happy to attend. But my daughter does Christmas cards, thank you letters (for presents to baby) etc to her family and he H does it for his, which surprised me. However she says she buys them and nags him to do them!

Irenelily Tue 24-May-16 11:12:18

I'm sure it is the women who keep the network going and remember all the birthdays! My second husband never remembers his children's or grandchildren's birthdays! I just get the cards and put them in front of him to sign!
I was an only child of parents youngest of their families after a gap, I hardly knew their families. In fact a cousin's wife turned up from Canada when my children were small and put me in touch with a cousin who was 23 years older than me - and we had a great friendship. I have 4 children and we are spread out but phone, email, text, FaceTime and get together when we can - a Big Birthday AND a wedding for 2 meet ups in July - hooray!

Dee Tue 24-May-16 10:54:19

My Sil's mother died tragically 18 years ago when he was 21 and his brother 16.
Their father now has a new partner and she has not taken over the mum's role in keeping everyone together (I'm not judging her for that, why should she?).
The result is that my SiL, who lives away from the rest of the family, is practically cut off most of the time. His mother was the emotional conduit for the family as I am for mine.
My daughter feels very hurt on his behalf because she feels his family don't value or care for him, he's a truly lovely man who lost his family when he lost his mum.
I do my best to warmly welcome him and include him in our family do's but I can never be his mum.
Conversely, when my DH died suddenly two years ago both his brother and sister, who live miles away from me, were wonderful. They include me in all family events and treat me like their sister. As an only child that means a lot. My MiL brought her sons up to be emotionally intelligent, caring men. I like to think I did the same with my son.

dorsetpennt Tue 24-May-16 10:36:27

It's always the way. I did for the family, buying birthday and Xmas cards and gifts. Signed said cards etc. My DIL does it too. I'm the holder of the family photographs and memorabilia and when I die I will pass that onto my DD. I think women are more emotionally interested in family things then men are. Not a criticism just that's the way it is.

Lupatria Tue 24-May-16 10:34:39

my family is fairly spread out now so we don't keep in touch. all the "older generation" as in parents, uncles and aunts aren't around any more and we've lost touch with cousins a very long time ago.
i've also almost lost touch with my sister and her family - my choice as she behaved rather badly when my parents died - we only send birthday and christmas cards.
my brother will be moving permanently to america next month and marrying a lovely american lady so the only way we can keep in touch is via skype or viber. i'm not in touch with his son [must look on facebook to see if he's still there] but i do keep in touch with his daughter and family.
the only member of my ex-husband's family i'm in touch with is his sister and that's only exchanging christmas cards.
quite frankly some of my family i wouldn't choose at all - a couple of my friends are closer than family these days!

Lilyflower Tue 24-May-16 10:27:57

Keeping the family together is what women do. I still organise all the meetings and visits we have with my DH's oldest friend and his family. I also bought his mum's and aunt's birthday and Christmas presents when they were alive.

My daughter is a feminist and quite feisty about women's independence. However, she was horrified when her dear BF forgot his mother's birthday and his dad phoned him with ire and disappointment. She knew that she was the one who was really getting the blame.

The dear men out the bins out. And we do all the rest.

silverlining48 Tue 24-May-16 10:22:41

I am married to an only 'child' with no family. I too have no family and our eldest daughter lives abroad. Our youngest here but busy with her life. I would give a lot to have a loving family to see and hear their news and attend inevitable weddings christening and other family occasions. My friend has a large close knit family and tells me it isn't always easy, but she wouldn't change it for the world,. at times I do envy her.

granjura Tue 24-May-16 09:42:51

I remember my dad often asking my mum (who had a full time job + long commute) 'Have 'we' written to my sister (who lived in Long Island NY)'- and mum sarcastically replying 'yes, 'we' have'...

obieone Tue 24-May-16 08:13:15

Yes. Never realised it before but definitely yes.

PRINTMISS Tue 24-May-16 07:36:53

OH! yes, it is always the women who are in touch, and keeping everything going. I wonder why that is? Perhaps it is because if women get together they will generally chat about their families and what is happening, whereas the men seem more inclined to talk about the latest football scores or sport. The men I know that is.The ladies talk, is of course much more interesting.

Synonymous Tue 24-May-16 00:11:03

When MIL died her family died. sad

merlotgran Mon 23-May-16 23:20:14

Yes, apart from my younger brother who always keeps in touch regarding anything and everything. My older brother leaves everthing to his wife and calls it, 'leaving it to the girls' which I find disparaging but DH reckons it's because she likes to be in control hmm

I do all the 'keeping everyone together' in our immediate family and long may it last grin

Wendysue Mon 23-May-16 23:09:29

Well, I'm in the States, so I don't know if what I'm going to say applies to the UK as well or not. But here, in my day, most of the women/wives played the role you ladies are describing. But even back then, I knew of a few couples who divided the social tasks (invitations, birthday cards and so on) "in half," so to speak, with her taking care of her side and him taking care of his. And nowadays, I've noticed a lot of the young couples follow this "yours/mine" policy, including my own DDs and SILs, though they don't follow it as rigidly as some.

Jacky, your cousins in America may still do things the more traditional way. But they're in our generation, yes? So that may not reflect what's going on over here among the young.

Then again, I notice that despite the yours/mine stuff with cards and so on, my DDs seem to know more about their DH's relatives than their DHs do. So maybe that part hasn't changed even here in the US, LOL!

Newquay Mon 23-May-16 17:45:39

Yes same here-if I didn't organise it, it wouldn't happen.
Years ago I gave DH a pile of different greeting cards to sign-Suppose I thought he'd read them! So DD2 got a card signed by Mum and John (not Dad!). She thought I might have something to tell her. . . .
Frequently on my way out to choir I say, will you ring your sister? And the same with his brother in Oz-DH just wouldn't think to ring.

morethan2 Mon 23-May-16 17:29:44

If it wasn't for me, my husband would have no contact with his family at all. So I do think our generation of women are the glue that hold things together. I'm not sure if that will carry on in the next generation though. I think the dynamics of family life have changed. Family members move away for work. So seeing each other is sporadic and that loosens the tie that binds us. looking back to my childhood the whole family were in daily or weekly contact. Thats less so now for a lot of families. It's amazing how we humans adapt to an ever changing world. At times I look on in awe at how this generation of women have such fast moving lives with very different expectation and values. I'm not sure I would have coped.

Marmark1 Mon 23-May-16 16:44:26

Yes,the women.