Gransnet forums

Relationships

DIL ESTRANGEMENT

(34 Posts)
NotSpaghetti Mon 31-Oct-22 08:06:26

As to your son and his relationship with his wife, I think you may be mistaken as I've not heard of a Christian Fundamentalist where the wife is the Head of the family so I think you might be mistaken here?
Maybe ask your son to help you find a way through this. I think he has more influence than you believe. But you must be genuinely prepared to give-and-take.

Good luck.

NotSpaghetti Mon 31-Oct-22 08:02:11

I've just written a very long post here and lost it.
I can't write it again so this is brief:

Whatever you think, these are family photos. In my family that would mean mine and my husband's to choose what to do with.
You seem to have a few options...

- Continue to argue about them being yours and not get them back,
- Agree they are family photos and pay for copies so your husband can have a set and so can you.
- Agree to share them and be content with this.

I know photos are sometimes important to us but they are not worth estrangement in my opinion. The true photos are in our hearts.

mumofmadboys Mon 31-Oct-22 07:38:07

Let it go. Relationships are so much more important than things. Dont mention it again. upsetting but for the best.

PoppyBlue Mon 31-Oct-22 06:55:55

Does your son want them?

Oopsadaisy1 Mon 31-Oct-22 06:54:23

You must have the negatives?
As someone has said if they are all of your son he has access to them now, so that has to be a good thing?

You only have 2 options, to let it go or take them to court and try to get the pictures back.

stella1949 Mon 31-Oct-22 04:36:36

I'm assuming that you had prints made of them ? Personally I would let it go . It's not worth becoming alienated from her ( and possibly from your son) over rolls of film. Take a step back, and remember that relationships are more important than " things". You call your post DIL estrangement, but that will only happen if you let it happen.

Hithere Mon 31-Oct-22 03:16:33

Where does your son stand here?

The pictures may have been taken by you but it was your son in them - his image, who is the true owner?

Win15 Mon 31-Oct-22 00:39:24

I haven’t seen my gc for six months. I took them (my son and DIL) out to eat and we parted kissing and friendly. They live eight blocks from me. I contacted them a number of times; finally she answered and said they don’t owe me anything. She has my photos, and I was so good to her. I would put flowers at her back door in May from my peony garden. Never went over uninvited. I was loving.

Win15 Mon 31-Oct-22 00:35:47

I did post this situation a few weeks ago, but took it off right away. I’m really at a loss what to do about this. I documented my son’s life since birth to eighteen. I’m a somewhat professional photographer; the camera I use is a Mamiya professional roll film camera. The roll film allows you to blow up photos wall size without losing any rosolution. Here’s the problem: I went through a divorce four years ago. I took all the photos; not my spouse. He stole them (six boxes full) out of our house one day when I was at work. I have been trying to get them back for the past four years. My DIL got them in her hands telling him she was going to do a family project. He gave them to her, but said he wanted them back. She told me she had them, but was going to keep them because they are of her husband (my son). I paid thousands of dollars in film, professional processing, etc. These photos were sent out to high/end film processors-no Walmarts! They are like high end wedding photos. I asked her if I could have them back. That I would make copies of some that are her favorite. She won’t budge. She said she has every right to keep them. She has them in a hidden location, even. I thought, okay, well at least they will be safe…but if they break up, they will go with her. I really want them back. They are my memories of him growing up. I have always been loving to her, and never challenged her…but I want them. I invested years in these beautiful photos. She is a Fundamentalist Christian and her and her family have very strict beliefs and values about husbands obeying wives. He was raised Catholic, but has taken her religion. She is close to her family, but has always excluded my ex-spouse and I because we are divorced, and he came out as gay. She says he’s a sinner. What course of action can I take?