Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Has anyone else heard of being "Churched" after the birth of a baby.?

(114 Posts)
susiecb Mon 05-Sept-11 09:37:06

Jess M nnot sure about that will ask my friend who is about to start as a student lady vicar (an ordinand) she's very Vicar of dibley not sure she would put up with the sinfulness bit.

Notsogrand Mon 05-Sept-11 08:07:41

Totally agree with phoenix and Baggy.

Banning contraception is just a method of control - keep the population poor and ground down with multiple births and they'll be less likely to question the authority of the church.

You're right Baggy, it is disgraceful.

JessM Mon 05-Sept-11 07:35:16

I think this is why, Baggy, that the C of E have removed this ceremony from their prayer book (I think I am right??? anyone??) It all goes back to the Book of Leviticus that lists the hygiene laws for Jewish shepherds, thousands of years ago. They had an idea that bodily discharges could pass on diseases so all bodily discharges stood accused. It does make fascinating reading.

Baggy Mon 05-Sept-11 06:42:55

People try to cover up the old reasons for churchings in "welcome the baby" in this country because church-goers here would rightly be appalled if they knew its origins. What grumpy says at the beginning of the thread is what it was really about — the uncleanliness of reproduction. It is still like this in Africa and South America. The Catholic church still has hang ups about sex (think of the damage that is being done in less developed countries by all the claptrap regarding contraception that it indoctrinates uneducated people with) and it's no good pretending that's all in the past. It isn't. It's disgraceful.

Joan Mon 05-Sept-11 03:41:10

When I had my first in 1979 someone mentioned that I should have been 'churched' after the birth. I asked my Mum what they had meant, she told me, and we both had a good laugh about it.

When we arranged his christening (I wasn't an atheist back then) the vicar never even asked if I'd been 'churched'. He just said he loved doing christenings, and he didn't care whether the parents were churchgoers or not. We weren't.

FlicketyB Sun 04-Sept-11 20:34:42

I remember my mother being 'churched' after the birth of my sister in 1950. It was a short prayer after the christening involving my mother and the priest and my father explained that it was to thank God for a safe delivery and a healthy baby. I did not discover the alternatively reason for a longtime and assumed for even longer that that meaning for the churching had long disappeared. I certainly do not remember my mother being subject to any superstitions or exclusions before the churching.

I had my children in 1971 and 1973 and nobody, at church or within the family, even mentioned churching to me - and I was a regular churchgoer.

I was brought up a Roman catholic and still am, sort of, and I keep hearing about this fear we are meant to feel but it has completely passed me by and not only me but most of my catholic friends. I am not clear even what it is we are meant to be afraid of. Looking back to my parents and grandparents I can never remember them showing any fear of the wrath of God, even less of the wrath of the parish priest. The nuns at my secondary school were a pretty scary bunch, but not for religious reasons.

Anne58 Sun 04-Sept-11 19:00:17

This thread just re-establishes my feelings about organised religion, especially the Roman Catholic faith, which I feel is mainly founded on fear.

I have beliefs regarding a supreme being, it's the middle management on Earth that I have most problem with!

This "orignal sin" business in the Christening ceremony, ffs how can a little baby need to be "cleansed" of sin??!!!!

Sorry if I have offended anyone, I respect those who have faith, but hope (and pray, in my own way,) that they can come to some sort of rationale that fits with the doctrine of their church, as well as life as it is lived today.

nanna2five Sun 04-Sept-11 16:22:36

Yes, when I had my first baby my gran said you have to be 'churched', before the christening, and any vicar worth his salt would refuse to christen baby. Luckily the vicar was not living in the dark ages! Gran said, it would'nt havehappened in her day, she went on to be a very loving great gran!

Grumpyoldwoman Sun 04-Sept-11 16:16:58

I can see the point of discouraging visitors as today everyone wants to see a new baby in the first few days !!...and maybe husbands !!!!

After I had my 3rd baby (we had moved to Scotland by then) ..I wrote to a dear friend back in Wigan telling her that I was feeling a bit low ..but the Dr thought it might be the mini-pill he had prescribed when baby was 6 weeks old.
This friend bumped into my Mum in town ..took her for a coffee and showed her the letter, photos etc.

That night my Mum phoned and the one sided conversation went
" Your husband must be an ANIMAL, an ANIMAL....that's all I can say to expect you to ''you know'' so soon after having a baby"...and she put the phone down..me holding the receiver thinking ....'What the hell was that all about ??''...but far too scared to phone back to find out !!! shock

It was weeks later when my friend wrote and told me she had seen my Mum !!!
and the penny dropped !!!

I could write a book about my Mother ..is it any wonder I didn't have much love for her !!!??

jackyann Sun 04-Sept-11 16:00:35

This was mentioned on another thread & I definitely recall it when I was a child (early 1950s CofE).
My mother thought it very old-fashioned, because it reeked of the whole "unclean" business as you have mentioned.
Later, as a midwife & health visitor, I came across similar practices in other cultures that seemed more to stress the rest period and getting help from family. They mostly seemed more positive, although some had echoes of "keep her away from normal people" that my mother & you so disliked.
Some older women have said to me they thought it might be about keeping the husband from "bothering" the woman whilst she recovered ( a notion that does not speak well of the menfolk!)

Since then I have come across a few religious women who follow the practice of churching, but emphasising the "thanks for giving birth safely" rather than the "unclean-ness".

dahlia Sun 04-Sept-11 15:56:16

I can remember my Mum telling me about being churched, and I don't think it's limited to Catholics as her own mother was churched following my Mum's birth in 1920, and she was a staunch Protestant. Yes, it does seem an archaic principle but perhaps it was designed to give new mums a rest, as they wouldn't be expected to take part in any social occasions at this time, and presumably were also not allowed to engage in sex. Many religious rules and regulations were originally based on valid reasons, but I don't know much at all about the churching rule. As with everything, I wish I had asked more about it while the people concerned were still here to answer my questions!

silversurfergran Sun 04-Sept-11 14:44:53

Being married to a Roman Catholic I was told to be churched after the birth of my first daughter in 1961. I was so appalled at the talk of the "sin" I had participated in (what about the father then?) and the incredible medieval language of the ceremony I refused to do it after the births of my next 2 daughters.
I don't think they still do it and certainly hope not - it put me off religion for life. I always thought it was just a Catholic thing but perhaps not.

susiecb Sun 04-Sept-11 11:06:43

Yes I do know about this and my mother doing it after the birth of my sister now 48 years old.

Grumpyoldwoman Sun 04-Sept-11 10:53:28

Following the Baptism thread remined me of this.

When I gave birth to our first daughter in 1972 I spent a week in hospital (as you did then) and when she was about 10 days old I proudly set off with my new baby in her gorgeous coachbuilt Silver Cross pram to visit my mother who lived about half a mile away.

My grandma (who I adored) was staying with my Mum and the excitement I felt when I rang the door bell was immense.

Mum made a fuss of baby and as I manouvered the pram into Mum's front porch ..Grandma had a word with Mum.

What transpired was such a shock and certainly dampened my euphoric mood.

Mum said I couldn't ''come in'' beacause I hadn't been ''churched'' shock

Apparently any woman who had just given birth was ''unclean'' until they had seen a vicar to say some ''special prayers'' with you. Therefore they cannot be allowed into someones house !!!

I couldn't believe what I was hearing and went home in floods of tears. My hubby was furious and although very mild mannered really told my Mum and Gran off and no more was ever said.
I just wondered if any of you had come across this barbaric nonsense.

My daughters were horrified when I told them after they had babies shock!!!