Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Atheist Beliefs

(57 Posts)
Bags Tue 21-Aug-12 18:00:43

This YouTube video is lovely

It's about what an atheist believes. He wants to tell people that being an atheist does not mean that you have no beliefs. Good for him.

I agree with him on them all. It can be my Credo too.

Anagram Tue 21-Aug-12 19:51:04

Oh, all right then! I'm not arguing, anyway, I just thought Ave Maria was a bit OTT.

absentgrana Tue 21-Aug-12 19:47:13

No – appreciating beauty. One of my favourite choral pieces is I know that my Redeemer liveth and one of my favourite places is Durham Cathedral. That is not ironic even though I am an atheist.

Anagram Tue 21-Aug-12 19:44:13

Oh I see- irony?

absentgrana Tue 21-Aug-12 19:42:27

The point of the video, which should be obvious and was clearly spelt out is that just because someone is an atheist, it doesn't prevent them from having beliefs. I would imagine the choice of music served the same purpose – being an atheist does not prevent anyone from appreciating beauty.

BlueSky Tue 21-Aug-12 19:37:46

Agree on your last point Anagram why Ave Maria, a good Catholic prayer, played at my (first) wedding...confused

Anagram Tue 21-Aug-12 19:31:50

Well, I've just watched the video and it certainly didn't bring a tear to my eye - but then why should it? Most of it was just common sense. I didn't understand why they had to have Ave Maria playing in the background, though...hmm

Greatnan Tue 21-Aug-12 19:30:17

I must have been watching a different video - I didn't pick up one word of criticism or unkindness.

Ella46 Tue 21-Aug-12 19:27:44

I thought it was very moving too.

absentgrana Tue 21-Aug-12 19:25:57

I just wish he hadn't chosen that piece of Schubert which I really dislike, but then I'm not very enthusiastic about other pieces of Schubert. The words, however, were moving.

Jingle Why are you so cross about this?

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 19:25:13

I'm not staying on this thread. There's good telly on tonight.

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 19:24:38

And I didn't like the silly illustration of an angel. Looked like a xmas decoration of the light-up kind.

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 19:23:43

Actually no!

I hate that video because it's quite obviously another dig at Christianity. Why does he have to refer to his 'Atheist' beliefs. Why not just head the video 'I believe this'?

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 19:17:08

Oh, I see what you mean Ariadne. Sorry.

I'll leave this thread. I just hate that kind of stuff on you tube. Just makes me feel suspicious.

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 19:13:19

It's not often used like that though is it Ariadne?

Greatnan. hmm

Ariadne Tue 21-Aug-12 19:10:23

jingl The next slide after "charity begins at home" says "The world is my home." Couldn't have put it better myself. Everything I believe in.

granjura Tue 21-Aug-12 19:07:34

JO4 - sorry but what a daft comment. Why wouldn't it???

Thank you Bags, very moving, and every word applies to how I feel too. Wonderful smile

Butternut Tue 21-Aug-12 19:05:09

J I care for what you feel, and I care that we feel differently about B's post.
I'm pleased that many can access the internet, if it does no harm to others.
The world is my home.
To my ears, it was poetry.
x

Greatnan Tue 21-Aug-12 18:58:55

Jingle, try it on elsewhere, you are not going to get anything from me. I don't think it is forum etiquette to accuse another member of lying.

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 18:57:39

I *don't believe^ it brought a tear to your eye Greatnan.

Why would it? confused

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 18:55:43

Or he could have been under the influence of something. grin

Greatnan Tue 21-Aug-12 18:55:20

There is not much that makes me cry, but this brought a tear to my eye - I agree with every single word. Thank you, Bags, for posting this.

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 18:54:23

He's possibly a right little Hitler in real life.

JO4 Tue 21-Aug-12 18:51:13

I don't care for the saying, "Charity begins at home".

And I didn't like the smug look on the fat bloke's face at the end.

I wonder why people need to put this stuff up on the internet. Isn't it their own business, what they believe in? Why should we care? confused

You can find it all better expressed in a good poetry book.

Ariadne Tue 21-Aug-12 18:44:10

That meant so much to me. Thank you, Bags xx

Marelli Tue 21-Aug-12 18:39:48

Wherever we all end up, what a lovely world it would be if we followed this way of living our lives.