Gransnet forums

Science/nature/environment

Trees

(14 Posts)
J52 Thu 30-Apr-26 13:08:31

aggie

Trees are essential, they lock in harmful stuff
If you cut it down you release harmful stuff, compounding the harm by burning the wood

I like trees, but if they fall on people they’re harmful as well!

fancythat Thu 30-Apr-26 12:30:47

Our trees dont annoy anyone, except perhaps for the sheep in the next field.

I am not convinced there is a single tree around that has stopped growing upwards!

The rate of growth seemed to be acceptable. Until about 15 years ago. Since then, there is nothing stopping them.
Any number of different sorts.

Georgesgran Thu 30-Apr-26 11:59:07

I like trees, I’m quite knowledgeable about the various specimens and there’s nothing like a walk through woods with my DGSs and Little Dog, but the massive sycamore in my neighbour’s garden?? My gardener says sycamores are just massive weeds - I’d take a chainsaw to it myself, if I could.
Yes, it was here when we moved, Spring ‘93, but that was 33 years ago and it’s still growing. Of course, because of its position, the only garden it shades is mine - luckily I’ve a big garden, so I can mov around to find the sun.

Tenko Thu 30-Apr-26 11:32:43

I like trees and live in an area with lots of woodland and heathland . I also live in a tree lined street which is beautiful when they’re in blossom.
I’m not a fan of leylandii , mainly because home owners don’t get them trimmed and they grow so high that it’s very expensive to get them cut back and they are a nuisance cutting out the light .
I would never buy a house with leylandii .

karmalady Thu 30-Apr-26 11:32:36

oops I had the hornbeam and whitebeam mixed. The one I can see is whitebeam, developers are told to put hornbeam in, they can grow to 90 feet

karmalady Thu 30-Apr-26 11:30:04

Very good post Rosie51 and looking at 5the plans for new builds, developers are often told to put whitebeam into the gardens as `eco` lip service. Bear in mind that these woodland trees can grow 50 feet

I can see one from my garden and it overhangs a neighbour, it is about 30 feet from my fence and will never cast shadow in my direction. The plans for my property had a hornbeam, I told the builder I would put something else in, hence the crabapple

Tizliz Thu 30-Apr-26 11:24:56

Are you saying no tree ever stops growing?That doesnt make sense to me. Perhaps it is true, however

Trees do stop growing. Redwoods reach hundreds of feet but that is unusual. If you buy a tree from a garden centre it will tell you what the average height and spread will be. If you have inherited trees then you will need to look them up.

A lime tree will average 45m with a growth of 60cm a year. Field maples - very common - grow at the same rate but only to about 20m. You can pollard them to keep under control, we had three done this year at a total cost of £600.

karmalady Thu 30-Apr-26 11:22:12

People in general do not consider their neighbours when planting trees. Often too close to a boundary fence or within spitting distance of foundations. I turned down two houses I went to look at due to leylandii growing next to boundary fences, one row had just been planted and I could just see the feathery tops when I stood on tip toe by the fence. I would have had that lovely bungalow but those they leylandii were just over 1m from the bungalow wall, I was first viewer and it was thanks but no thanks

Once upon a time I lived in historical gardens and had lovely views of the trees, especially a majestic leylandii which had been allowed to grow to its full potential, at least 60 foot high and in the distance from the properties. A massive tree and beloved by birds

I have planted 4 trees, the three apple trees are on M26 rootstocks and even if they were never pruned, will only from to around 2.8m. All my trees are at least 10 feet from boundary fences. My jelly king was grafted onto rootstock M106 and will never get taller than 4m. None of them overhand the fences

Trees are beautiful as long as they are not a nuisance

Allira Thu 30-Apr-26 11:16:48

fancythat

We may move in about 10 years.

I dont dislike them as such.

Are you saying no tree ever stops growing?
That doesnt make sense to me. Perhaps it is true, however.

Are you saying no tree ever stops growing?

I think when they stop growing up or grow more slowly they grow in girth.

aggie Thu 30-Apr-26 11:11:25

Trees are essential, they lock in harmful stuff
If you cut it down you release harmful stuff, compounding the harm by burning the wood

Rosie51 Thu 30-Apr-26 11:04:51

My only problem with trees is the ones that people will plant right next to the boundary so the neighbour has half the canopy over their garden whether they want it or not. My garden is small but very overshadowed by the enormous wild cherry tree in the neighbour's garden. Its roots suck my ground dry and it drops blossom, berries and finally leaves everywhere. Because I'm in a conservation area we can't even prune back any branches at all. If I had my way it would be law that any tree a person plants must contain the full canopy within their own boundaries. No inflicting your preference on unwilling neighbours.

fancythat Thu 30-Apr-26 11:01:58

We may move in about 10 years.

I dont dislike them as such.

Are you saying no tree ever stops growing?
That doesnt make sense to me. Perhaps it is true, however.

Allira Thu 30-Apr-26 10:59:39

But they seem to have grown so high in recent years.
And are still growing.

That's what trees do - grow!

Unless, of curse, they get diseases or are chopped down.

If you are surrounded by trees and dislike them, have you ever thought of moving to a different location?

fancythat Thu 30-Apr-26 10:53:02

Does anyone else have a "problem" with them?

I know they are great.
I know they are vital.
I know certain areas may well need loads more.

But they seem to have grown so high in recent years.
And are still growing.

We cut down two[were a danger] and used the firewood.
And it cost. Though each tree was about 8 months' worth of logs.
They needed special equipment.

I live in an area that is pretty much surrounded by trees.
Yes, I know I am fortunate as well.

Just wanted a general discussion really.
Peoples' thoughts.