Gransnet forums

Site stuff

Troll hunting

(235 Posts)
kittylester Tue 18-Dec-18 10:26:55

I have been told off for troll hunting to which I hold my hands up- though I wasn't hunting, I'd found one!!

Shouldn't GNHQ be troll hunting for us. Those of us that have been here a while will be instinctively aware of malicious posters generally and can report (as I was told to) but how long does it take hq to look into something and what harm can be done to unsuspecting members in the interim?

janeainsworth Fri 04-Jan-19 00:14:35

Do you mean you’re flouncing Gabriella or you’re being excommunicated?

GabriellaG54 Fri 04-Jan-19 12:29:43

Defrocked...maybe shockgrin

janeainsworth Fri 04-Jan-19 13:16:35

You don’t change Gabriellagrin

mcem Fri 04-Jan-19 13:32:04

Frock is such a Hyacinth Bucket expression, isn't it?
And you're right jane, she doesn't change!

Jalima1108 Fri 04-Jan-19 14:32:56

Can you be defrocked if you were never frocked in the first place Gabriella?
grin

Atqui Fri 04-Jan-19 16:09:38

Any relation to Jinglebellfrocks?

mcem Fri 04-Jan-19 16:14:27

How does one get frocked?

winterwhite Fri 04-Jan-19 16:36:55

What I find creepy about some of these Site threads is posters who arrive announcing that they have been 'lurking'. An unpleasant word. Of course new joiners will want to explore the forums a bit, but what would be anyone's object in 'lurking' for 'a few weeks'?

Elegran Fri 04-Jan-19 16:49:54

(Assuming that was a serious question) mcem - By being ordained as a priest/pastor. Taking on the wearing of distinctive robes and stoles is symbolic of taking on and being accepted into a life as a priest.

Looking for references online, I found this in an announcement that On Wednesday, April 22 from noon to 7 p.m. in Room 306 of Morgan University Center at APSU. "there will be on display a collection of at least 50 clerical stoles that were worn by ordained ministers who were defrocked. And the reason? Their sexual orientation."

It goes on to say "Clerical stoles are more than just a piece of cloth. A stole doesn't represent a denomination, even among the denominations that use stoles. Rather, it is an outward representation of someone who has made a lifelong commitment to serve God and others, to share the gospel of Jesus and to demonstrate the love and acceptance of Christianity.

"It is a privilege to wear a stole. It is a symbol of Jesus that rests on the shoulders of ministers and humanizes service to God and others. So imagine the emotional upheaval that occurs personally and professionally if a denomination strips that pastor of his ordained rights, responsibilities and privileges.

That process has a name. The word is "defrock" and it leaves a scar that lasts forever."
eu.theleafchronicle.com/story/life/faith/2015/04/18/stoles-defrocked-pastors-gathered-unity/25997441/

Jalima1108 Fri 04-Jan-19 19:29:17

Any relation to Jinglebellfrocks?
I wouldn't think so Atqui

Jalima1108 Fri 04-Jan-19 19:31:01

It's rather odd, as the opposite should be de-ordained, surely?

Elegran Fri 04-Jan-19 19:59:00

I think it must be rather like a soldier geting a dishonourable discharge and having his insignia publicly ripped from his uniform in front of ranks of his fellows.

GabriellaG54 Fri 04-Jan-19 23:06:41

Well, I might have had a short sermon delivered by GNHQ but it fell short of de-frocking.
I live to fight another day...hip hip hooray grinbrewcupcake

mcem Sat 05-Jan-19 10:40:23

Not entirely a serious question. The whole vestment thing is far more significant in R C and Anglican traditions than in e.g. C of S although there is of course a certain symbolism in the robes worn by ministers.

(Oh, dear. Better luck next time GG!)

Elegran Sat 05-Jan-19 11:32:09

There is a lot of symbolism in the more "high church" denominations, and the C of E is just reall the RC without a pope. The non-conformists mostly go for either plain black or no uniform at all.

Namsnanny Sat 05-Jan-19 13:22:57

Just asking....what have onesies got to do with anything? Sorry not down with the lingo!! smile

BTW has there ever been a serious con job perpetrated through GN? Something like a fraud or a vulnerable person taken in somehow?

Otherwise, some of us are in danger of making fools of ourselves by chasing ghosts! smile

BlueBelle Sat 05-Jan-19 13:43:14

We used to have one spoof poster who always asked about where to buy cheap ugg boots and onesies for her gay grandson so it became a bit of a joke to refer to fake threads using those words Nansnann

Fennel Sat 05-Jan-19 18:52:43

Namsnanny I don't understand the connection to onesies either.
As for you other question, not a serious con job (as far as I know). But on one occasion part of a thread on here was published in the Daily Mail, with the user names of a few of us.
After which some of us changed our user names.
Some people don't realise that these forums are open to general public view and reproduction.

Fennel Sat 05-Jan-19 18:54:21

ie not subject to copyright laws.

Elegran Sat 05-Jan-19 19:36:37

And on another occasion a reader (I can't imagine it was a member!) worked out where a poster was working, and passed on to their employer something that had been said, hoping to make trouble.

Anniebach Sat 05-Jan-19 19:47:58

I can remember that Elegran

mcem Sat 05-Jan-19 20:16:10

I remember that. Not sure whether she realised how unpopular she was or whether GNHQ stepped in but she overstepped the mark once too often and disappeared.
Did she jump or was she pushed!

sodapop Sat 05-Jan-19 20:39:46

Be careful, I got deleted because I mentioned that all in one garment Fennel smile

Jalima1108 Sat 05-Jan-19 20:44:21

Me too!

Although it was OK when I mentioned in a post buying them for the DGD for Christmas (which I didn't because they didn't have their size).
Nor the boots grin

Perhaps just as well, because they are apparently rather passé now, according to a young DGD!

mcem Sat 05-Jan-19 21:06:25

I find it quite sad that, as a result of the reaction to 'our' posts appearing on F B and msm, so many posters changed names and deleted profiles. I do understand why of course but it was lovely to get to know someone whose posts you found interesting.
Easily done by going to their profile, seeing pic's, discovering more about them .
It didn't seem remotely creepy or stalkerish at the time but looking back, we were a lot more naive than we are now!
Did we even think about trolls back then?