Gransnet forums

Style & beauty

Designer handbags vs high street

(120 Posts)
minimo Thu 03-Dec-15 12:41:40

One of my DILs always uses a designer handbag (I think she has about 3). She does buy them in the sales and can afford them so I don't begrudge or judge her or anything BUT, can they possibly be worth it? There are such lovely handbags on the high street, but she says it's as much about the name as the quality (which apparently is much better). What do others think? Have you ever owned a designer bag? Would you - if money wasn't an issue of course?

Synonymous Sat 05-Dec-15 01:07:37

No I would never bother with 'designer' anything just for a name and I am very uninterested in what anyone else thinks about my purchase if I am content with it. I will buy something lightweight and with all the bits and bobs I consider necessary and I always buy to please myself.
My DH considers himself and our bank balance to be truly blessed! grin

Teacher11 Sat 05-Dec-15 06:36:33

I have a beautiful Radley bought by my husband and daughter for my birthday. I use it every day and love it as the design is good and the leather lovely. I a, not sure I would have dared spend that much on myself though I might have got one in a sale. My daughter works in the city and says high fliers there are very judgemental about clothes, shoes, bags and so on. She bought herself a Mulberry in the sale last year at a price which made me gasp. Still, she earned the money! I am not sure what I think. It's shallow to value 'stuff' but nice things do give one pleasure and clothes and accessories do make a statement to the world. Sadly, the way human nature is, a smart woman will always be treated better than a shabby one. My bag is part of my 'armour' .

thatbags Sat 05-Dec-15 10:23:34

One can be smart without having 'designer' possessions.

That is not a negative comment about designer products. It is a comment on the fact that smartness is not dependent on designer products.

thatbags Sat 05-Dec-15 10:28:05

Hear, hear, synonymous. If anyone were so rude as to comment on my lack of designer possessions or to be obviously judgmental I'd simply dismiss them (silently, mentally) as twats. They must know this, surely?

No-one ever has, btw. It must be the "don't dare or I'll (figuratively) bite your head off" look in my eye wink

I think it's sad that people mind so much what twits and twats think of them. We should teach our children to rise above such nonsense.

varian Sat 05-Dec-15 13:17:11

The idea of "designer" anything is ridiculous. All bags (and all consumer goods) have been designed by a designer.

I would never wear anything with a logo or visible label. If these designers want us to be a walking advertisements they should be paying us.

Deedaa Sat 05-Dec-15 22:05:12

Money can't buy you style. You've only got to remember the photo of what's her name from Eastenders wearing head to toe Burberry including the baby buggy. I believe their sales dropped right off after that one.

If you've got an eye for colour and proportion you can look good on very little money.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 05-Dec-15 22:27:02

She as wearing the buggy? confused

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 05-Dec-15 22:33:28

Some bags can look spectactularly good in posh shop windows. The really expensive ones. Wouldn't buy one. You need the clothes to go with them. High heels and tight skirts.

Deedaa Sun 06-Dec-15 20:58:08

No not wearing the buggy, though I bet she would have done if she could tchgrin

Neversaydie Wed 24-Feb-16 01:59:05

I always buy Radley bags-half price in Bicester village. Average about £150. Usually a birthday present .But have never thought of them as 'designer'. I only really use one hand bag at a time They last 2-3 years of daily use . Current one 'goes' with my best coat, as did the last one .I'm sunk if they stop making the colour (maybe I should stock pile ...) . I also have a Radley purse (bought by DDs two Christmases ago. Hideous price but I love it. )
I have a small Kipling, nylon(?) rucksack-y type bag for travelling But I hate that gorilla and have cut it off .
And two non- descript cross -body bags, ditto.
Plus three evening bags .
Bought a lovely leather bag from a 'factory'(hand made) in Venice once Had my initials in and everything . Was sad when it died .

I would love a Mulberry

mumofmadboys Wed 24-Feb-16 08:02:01

I have a Bridge handbag. I have had it for 7 years now and use it every day. I still love it.

NonnaW Wed 24-Feb-16 09:41:42

My stepdaughter has several designer bags, including a Mulberry. I remember shopping with her once, going round Harvey Nics looking at all the bags. I looked at some Marc Jacobs bags which DH said to buy if I wanted but I couldn't justify the cost. We then went to Vivieene Westwood where she paid about £650 for a bag. Two shops down she gazes at a dark green Mulberry (£900 - eek!) and even went in to look at it. Still, she works hard for her money, and if that's what she wants to spend it on I wouldn't begrudge her. Her fiancé just shrugs.

Stansgran Wed 24-Feb-16 13:12:58

Digressing a little I've just read a lightweight but charming story about a woman who is mugged in Paris. Her handbag is dumped and someone finds it and tries to track down the owner from the contents. It's called the Red Notebook and it was a cheapo on kindle by Antoine Laurain.

Lavande Wed 24-Feb-16 13:56:52

Alima, same here with the Kipling bags. The gorilla key rings are given the younger grandchildren.

I used to buy leather (not bothered about designer labels) but I now prefer lightweight, practical and roomy enough to carry an Ipad when traveling. Size also matters so that my handbags need to Ryanair compatible.

Grannyknot Wed 24-Feb-16 15:42:58

Digressing a bit - but, I think the whole "designer label"thing is one big rip-off. In December last year I came across a Kickstarter project by two young Spanish men. In their pitch they said that all sunglasses are produced by just two manufacturers and they would prove it by matching a well known brand for quality, appearance etc. Long story short, for an investment of just 15 euros I got two pairs of very smart, strong sunglasses that look just like Raybans. Including soft and hard cases.

Willow500 Thu 25-Feb-16 13:16:44

I have a handbag fetish I think smile I don't possess a designer one but have a lot and seem to be constantly on the look out for the one ideal bag which doesn't lose all my possessions in the bottom but is big enough to get all my stuff in. The former is too heavy to go shopping with but the latter won't hold my phone and purse etc. I see a lot on the shopping channel and wonder who would pay £200 plus for a bag - I don't think I would even if I could afford it. This week I found one in a drawer upstairs I paid £6 for in Primark so have the essentials in it and now have that in a bigger bag so I can take it out and put it in a shopping bag if I need to. Then of course we now need to have shopping bags with us as we don't get carriers any more so that's a whole new lot of bags to collect 'sigh' confused

Lavande Thu 25-Feb-16 18:31:53

Don't despair Willow500 I have bought several shopping aka Tote bags from the Folksy.com website for myself and as gifts. There are hundreds to choose from. I like this website because it enables small, often home based enterprises to display their products to a wider customer base.

Willow500 Sat 27-Feb-16 11:15:11

Ooh going to take a look at that site Lavande :-)

BeadyJanet Sat 27-Feb-16 11:38:54

I nearly always buy my handbags from a cheap and cheerful market stall but am getting a bit cheesed off as the quality is getting worse and recently a few have zips that have broken really quickly and linings seem thin. I'd love a designer bag but would be frightened to use it everyday if it was really expensive as I'd have to save for months to afford it sad

Jayh Sat 27-Feb-16 15:24:06

I have several Radley bags only one of which I have bought for myself. I like them because they are so well designed with handy pockets for phones, passports, tickets etc. They are also good quality and I have had them for years now and they still look good. Strangely, I have never thought of them as 'designer', just well made bags that I like.
I will have a look at the folksy website now as I am looking for a backpack to take on holiday.

SGbeauty Wed 16-Mar-16 06:59:57

Message deleted by Gransnet for breaking our forum guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

Coolgran65 Wed 16-Mar-16 20:16:05

Not designer but I've just bought a Jane Shilton black leather backpack off eBay for £1.20 (plus £4 postage). If there are any scuffs they will be polished up and called character.

That's me happy.

adasg Fri 18-Mar-16 04:09:26

Message deleted by Gransnet for breaking our forum guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

Saneswap Thu 17-Nov-16 09:17:36

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

goldengirl Thu 17-Nov-16 10:06:56

I don't do designer; I'd be afraid to scuff it. As long as I can actually find things in the bag [I don't like having to root around] I'm quite content. I like shoulder bags best and my latest came from ASDA. Considering the bashing it's getting it's doing really well so I see no reason to buy upmarket. Another bigger one I use for meetings is from Tesco. I can't see the attraction for designer