Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Mastermind misery

(135 Posts)
GabriellaG54 Mon 14-Jan-19 21:31:49

Did anyne watch the risible performance of England cricketer Monty Panesar on a recent Mastermind programme?
Not only did he perform miserably in his specialist subject (Sikh religion) but his general knowledge was zero, in fact, less than a 5 yr old.
An absolute disgrace, given that he was born and bred in Luton.
Talk about being insular...
Your thoughts?

Anniebach Tue 15-Jan-19 08:32:09

Hell bells, it’s a game of ‘windup’ , not ‘bitter lemons’ .

BlueBelle Tue 15-Jan-19 08:12:11

Why do I get a picture of bitter lemons when you post Gabriella how difficult it must be to always be so superior how can you bear to talk to us minions who may think a mans name defines where he hails from ( your judgements would have great fun with my surname)

MawBroon Tue 15-Jan-19 08:03:07

I was merely informing the (possibly) uninformed that, being born and bred here, his knowledge of the country he was educated and lived in fell woefully short of even basic standards

Thank goodness for the informed
Where would the great unwashed be without them?
As for insular?
No man is an island, entire of itself - not even Luton
.

cavewoman Tue 15-Jan-19 07:54:18

Gabriella Could you define the meaning of the word insular?

ffinnochio Tue 15-Jan-19 07:38:16

Never heard of the chap until this thread.

kittylester Tue 15-Jan-19 06:51:27

confused

Anja Tue 15-Jan-19 05:51:55

GG are you trying to tell me who I can and cannot speak to on this thread?

Because I assure you, the likes of you won’t shut me girlie. I

Jalima1108 Tue 15-Jan-19 00:17:43

Rabbit in the headlights then.

merlotgran Tue 15-Jan-19 00:16:50

He had a good education and a degree in computer science so I'm surprised he couldn't make a better fist of it.

Jalima1108 Tue 15-Jan-19 00:14:54

He's quite famous and played for England so I don't know why we wouldn't have heard of him.
Does that mean someone with a non-British sounding name is assumed to be a foreigner then?

That would include some of my family grin

GabriellaG54 Tue 15-Jan-19 00:13:54

* was not enraged, not but enraged.

GabriellaG54 Tue 15-Jan-19 00:12:20

Eloethan
Ignoring your last silly sentence, I was but enraged rather 'gobsmacked' that someone who has travelled more broadly and had a wealth of experience in the eye of Joe Public and the media, could know so little about the wide-ranging general knowledge questions.

GabriellaG54 Tue 15-Jan-19 00:03:32

MawBroon
I mentioned Luton because not everyone on here has heard of him and, given his name, might assume he had lived most of his life in another country with little knowledge of the UK.
I was merely informing the (possibly) uninformed that, being born and bred here, his knowledge of the country he was educated and lived in fell woefully short of even basic standards.

Jalima1108 Tue 15-Jan-19 00:00:17

We do seem to have a lot of celebs doing this for charity recently, some winning not very large sums for their chosen charities. Are they paid to do this, how much does production cost? Far more than goes to the charity I expect.

It's all a bit Pointless..

Eloethan Tue 15-Jan-19 00:00:06

I've seen several contestants on Celebrity Mastermind who have done very badly on their specialist subjects and general knowledge. Why does it so enrage you that this particular person's performance was very poor and why do you describe it as "insular"? I imagine there are many people "born and bred in Luton" - and other towns - who have equally poor general knowledge.

There is, in my opinion, a rather unpleasant undertone to your post.

merlotgran Mon 14-Jan-19 23:56:07

There are humpty dumpty programmes available that celebs can go on to raise their profile money for charity. Mastermind is not live so even with editing they're not going to put themselves in the best of lights.

Maybe their agent is holding a gun to their heads?

Jalima1108 Mon 14-Jan-19 23:53:27

Perhaps people from Luton have exceptionally high IQs, MawBroon?
Or a high level of general knowledge?
Perhaps Monty let the side down for Luton.

Jalima1108 Mon 14-Jan-19 23:51:05

I saw him on Question of Sport and thought he did OK (well, he knew more than me!) grin

Perhaps he just froze - or they were just the 'wrong' questions.
How often do we watch such programmes and think 'how can they not know that'? But perhaps nerves get the better of some people.

Jangran99 Mon 14-Jan-19 23:36:31

Anja smile

MawBroon Mon 14-Jan-19 23:36:24

was zero, in fact, less than a 5 yr old
An absolute disgrace, given that he was born and bred in Luton.

What relevance does being born in Luton have? confused

merlotgran Mon 14-Jan-19 23:33:21

I agree that there have been some risible performance recently. I can't remember each individual celeb but when they scored badly on their specialist subject we thought maybe they'd redeem themselves with general knowledge.

Nope!

I actually think it's an insult to the charity they're supporting.

GabriellaG54 Mon 14-Jan-19 23:25:12

Anja
Can't Jangran99 think for herself or does she need a prompt from you?

BlueBelle Mon 14-Jan-19 23:06:15

My goodness what a harsh and judgemental post Gabrielle some people just go blank when asked questions and maybe aren’t as fast as you don’t be such a miserabke so and so
Those are my thoughts

Anja Mon 14-Jan-19 23:00:27

Ignore her Jangran

Anja Mon 14-Jan-19 22:59:17

You think Monty was bad? Poor fellow looked like a rabbit caught in headlights.

Did anyone see Shaun Ryder’s performance a few weeks ago. He looked and sounded drunk. Yuk!