Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

The Singapore Grip. Oh dear.

(23 Posts)
grannyrebel7 Thu 17-Sept-20 20:26:06

Couldn't stand the father and daughter. Not really fussed on any of the other characters either tbh.

Jane10 Tue 15-Sept-20 15:01:25

Try reading the book. JG Farrell was a terrific author and died young sadly.

ExD Tue 15-Sept-20 14:54:01

I'm keeping an open mind and getting to know the characters first, so I'll give it a few more 'goes'.
I had an aunt evacuated from Singapore during the 2nd world war (soldier's wife) and although she didn't talk about it much, some of the scenes rang true. She didn't look back on her time there with any sense of enjoyment.
She's dead now and so can't enlighten me as to it's veracity - but I think the programme's intended to be OTT.
(I recorded it, so I'll watch it again to try and work out the characters.)

Callistemon Tue 15-Sept-20 14:51:39

Oh! As I didn't recognise Jane Horrocks so she must have done something right grin

I think that if I watch it as a slightly malicious parody of colonial life in Singapore I will enjoy it.
Presumably all will change soon in an alarming and frightening way.

Calendargirl Tue 15-Sept-20 14:41:49

I watched it on catch up, wondered whether to bother after reading GN reviews, but didn’t think it was too bad. Could follow the story.
Charles Dance was good, Jane Horrocks over acted as always, she seems to be the same whatever part she’s in, I just see her as an ageing Bubbles, if that’s the right name from Ab Fab.
Thought Miss Chiang was beautiful.

Callistemon Mon 14-Sept-20 21:12:33

Just watching it and we're taking it as it is meant to be - a parody of pre-war colonialism.

I don't think it's meant to be taken at face value.
David Morrissey is rather OTT but perhaps believable as a pre-war trader in Singapore.

richly absurd

Don't take it seriously - yet.

Teetime Mon 14-Sept-20 18:52:31

I quite enjoyed it.

EllanVannin Mon 14-Sept-20 18:51:40

It's part-filmed in Penang but overall it's somewhere in Malaysia.

EllanVannin Mon 14-Sept-20 18:50:13

I thought it was a special handshake grin
It could well be as it gets going. Obviously something iffy with the Chinese girl. I'll see what next week brings.

Calendargirl Mon 14-Sept-20 18:01:52

It sounds like another name for a designer bag.

?

Callistemon Mon 14-Sept-20 16:59:46

Did the scriptwriters understand that it was meant to be satirical?

merlotgran Mon 14-Sept-20 16:49:25

mrswoo

We gave it to the second ad break and then gave up. I thought the acting was hammy and I got the impression that the actors were just going through the motions. It's a pity because, on paper, it looks like it should've been perfect Sunday evening viewing. But oh dear, it's a definite no from me.

I couldn't get my head around the dreadful acting either. Some familiar talent there but at times it sounded like an am dram production in the village hall.

Unless it's supposed to and I'm completely missing the point! grin

Callistemon Mon 14-Sept-20 16:14:26

The Singapore Grip is a satirical book about events following Japan's entry into the Second World War by invading South East Asia and swiftly occupying Singapore. The story centres on a British family who control one of the colony's leading trading companies. The title derives from a slang phrase for a sexual technique also known as Pompoir or Kabzah

"A brilliant, complex, richly absurd and melancholy monument to the follies and splendours of Empire, " wrote Hilary Spurling for the The Times Literary Supplement.
In 2015, Akshita Nanda, writing for The Straits Times, chose ten novels which describe Singapore in the past five decades, The Singapore Grip among their number.

A synopsis of the book and two reviews - has the TV adaptation made a hash of it?

Callistemon Mon 14-Sept-20 16:10:26

I've recorded it but it doesn't sound like another Tenko?

JenniferEccles Mon 14-Sept-20 16:01:18

Oh I don’t want to put anybody off if you fancy watching it.
It was just my opinion and we are all different aren’t we, but I was so disappointed considering how many good quality dramas we have had over the years.

Other’s views though do confirm what I thought.

mrswoo Mon 14-Sept-20 14:39:48

We gave it to the second ad break and then gave up. I thought the acting was hammy and I got the impression that the actors were just going through the motions. It's a pity because, on paper, it looks like it should've been perfect Sunday evening viewing. But oh dear, it's a definite no from me.

Jane10 Mon 14-Sept-20 14:17:14

It's true to the book which is good but the characters are not likeable nor were they meant to be. I find this time in Singaporean history painful. Such awful things happened. Such miscalculations and dangerous errors by the British. The Japanese were so cruel and terrifying. This story is pretty accurate. JGFarrell wanted to highlight the colonialism.
Charles Dance was perfect in the role though - but he always is!

MerylStreep Mon 14-Sept-20 13:49:00

I gave it 15 mins !!! Awful.

Pantglas2 Mon 14-Sept-20 13:46:19

I was going to get this on catch up but might not bother.....or maybe wait til next Sunday and do both together, sometimes it clicks then.

merlotgran Mon 14-Sept-20 13:43:34

I'll keep going because I was underwhelmed with A Suitable Boy and then ended up loving it.

Not holding out much hope though.

travelsafar Mon 14-Sept-20 13:41:01

I found myself checking my phone during this programme which indicates to me it at the moment it is .........boring!!

Luckygirl Mon 14-Sept-20 13:40:28

Radio Times reviewed it badly, so I did not watch it. I definitely won't now!

JenniferEccles Mon 14-Sept-20 13:31:55

Did anyone watch this last night?

I was pleased to see we had a period drama for the next few Sunday nights, but I was left completely bemused and very disappointed.

Is it supposed to be a comedy or a take-off of period dramas?

I thought the acting was dire, very stilted and not one of the characters was believable to me.

Yes it’s only the first episode and some programmes do need time to get going, but I won’t bother with this again.