Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

All creatures great and small.

(59 Posts)
Grandmajean Sat 18-Sept-21 14:27:25

Love it. Streets ahead of the earlier one. Thought Robert Hardy was way over the top. Think all the actors are excellent but Helen is a bit annoying. I think James is "nicer" than she and he could do better. Talking about fictitious people here.

Boz Sat 18-Sept-21 13:33:09

Much better than the old version, which was good but seems dated now. The new James Herriot is believable unlike the suave Christopher Timothy with the wrong accent for a Scot!
Helen seems real not a "bisto" mum like all the other characterisations in the past.
The script is well-written and the scenery shots wonderful.

A 5 star hit.

Jaberwok Sat 18-Sept-21 13:26:14

Have given it another try but its no good I don't like it at all, but then I was addicted to the Robert Hardy, Christopher Timothy version. Mrs Hall is far too young, and the other characters just don't ring true. Won't be watching it again.

aggie Sat 18-Sept-21 11:48:24

James was ok , but in some shots he seemed to have lipstick on ?

Kittye Sat 18-Sept-21 11:32:59

Loving all the characters except James for some reason. Much preferred the Christopher Timothy version.

ginny Sat 18-Sept-21 10:56:36

I love it too.

helgawills Sat 18-Sept-21 10:51:17

Real feelgood programme, loved it. Visited the Practice at Thirsk during our visit to Yorkshire in June.

Aveline Sat 18-Sept-21 09:50:35

This programme is done so well. I've got it recorded as a treat for later. Full marks to all concerned.

travelsafar Sat 18-Sept-21 09:42:53

I watched the new series last night on catch up, everything i thought it would be, humour, and nostalgic with an easy story line. This kind of program leaves me with a nice warm feeling inside.