Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Marie antonette on bbc2

(65 Posts)
notgran Sat 31-Dec-22 10:12:05

I have been to Versailles 3 times the first in the very early 1970's. It had no furniture and the walls etc were mostly painted in a magnolia sort of paint over the stucco. It was obviously being refurbished after the war and any beautiful parts were not open to visitors. However I remember being shocked at the Guide's commentary which was of course anti-royalty and full of how terrible the ordinary folk were treated before the revolution. So different from tours around National Trust places in the UK, when nothing negative was ever said about the aristocracy. My abiding memory is of the description of the toilet arrangements and the smells everywhere which made me want to never visit the Palace again, it was so repulsive a story. However in the 1990's and about 8 years ago I did go and what a beautiful place it is. I didn't bother with the Guided Tour though and hilariously there was a huge queue for the public toilets outside and the Toilet Attendant for whatever reason selected me and a couple of other ladies to an inside toilet that was very grand, clean and sweet smelling. How could she know grin

Grandmadinosaur Sat 31-Dec-22 10:09:17

Whitewavemark2

I enjoyed it for exactly what it was. Pleasant time to spend an hour. Loved the costumes.

Same here.

Joseanne Sat 31-Dec-22 10:08:09

Not much different from Emily in Paris!
Enjoyed both for what they are.

biglouis Sat 31-Dec-22 10:06:48

Being female, foreign, extravagant and largely ignorant of state matters she was blamed for the considerable failings of the French royal family and Government, and suffered greatly at the end of her life

This is fair comment. She is one of the historical figures who has always fascinated me and I read quite a lot about her in the past. In fact (like many young women of her time) she was so ill educated that she could barely write her name on the wedding certificate without blotting it!

There is no authoritative record of the "let them eat cake" remark. At her infamous show trial (wher she was accused of debauching her own son) she is known to have defended herslf well and won over many females in the audience. The guilty verdict was a foregone conclusion.

Fleurpepper Sat 31-Dec-22 10:01:18

I wonder if it will portray her love affair with Count Fernsen of Sweden.

volver Sat 31-Dec-22 10:01:03

Did you watch it at all, eazybee? It was very sympathetic towards her.

Leaving her mother, being transported to the border, being dressed as a French princess, a Prince who wasn't ready to marry, the whole court watching them get into bed. Not sure what they were throwing at them though confused. Anyone know?

Whitewavemark2 Sat 31-Dec-22 09:58:28

I enjoyed it for exactly what it was. Pleasant time to spend an hour. Loved the costumes.

eazybee Sat 31-Dec-22 09:57:07

Very little of it is true and based mostly on the scurrilous slander circulating about Marie Antoinette during her life time. Being female, foreign, extravagant and largely ignorant of state matters she was blamed for the considerable failings of the French royal family and Government, and suffered greatly at the end of her life.

volver Sat 31-Dec-22 09:56:49

I think it is "just" a play. There have been goodness knows how many versions of the Marie Antoinette story over the years. This one was entertaining and not too far removed from reality.

Fleurpepper Sat 31-Dec-22 09:54:02

volver

Its a play folks, not a docu...

Oops, sorry Fleurperpper wink

Well yes- and no! If it is just going to be a 'play' then fair enough.

Aveline Sat 31-Dec-22 09:25:30

I saw episode one and really enjoyed it as a drama. I'm looking forward to bringing more episodes this afternoon.

volver Sat 31-Dec-22 09:24:20

Its a play folks, not a docu...

Oops, sorry Fleurperpper wink

Fleurpepper Sat 31-Dec-22 09:23:09

Was really looking forward to watching first episode last night- but thought it was dreadful. Sorry.

Will try and watch second episode, as I have done some work on her history, bur so far, so not good.

Sparklefizz Sat 31-Dec-22 09:19:10

I started watching it last night and will finish the first episode this afternoon. Beautiful costumes and settings, I agree.

travelsafar Sat 31-Dec-22 01:00:59

Have been binge watching this new series on catch up. I'm finding it a really good series, beautiful clothes and decor as set in Versaille....excuse spelling mistakes please. It is also a very good story line and if its based on truth, things I didn't know. If you like period drama I would highly recommend. 😊👍