Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

This horrific news story was just beyond belief

(125 Posts)
Allira Tue 26-Nov-24 20:05:15

On the evening news was a report about a baby, a child, who had been found in a drawer under a bed where she had been kept by her mother for three years.
The child was malnourished, had never seen the light of day, her limbs deformed.
Other children living in the house were unaware of her existence.

A visitor to the house heard her crying and she was discovered when a social worker visited. She is now with foster parents, receiving the care, love and medical attention she needs.

The mother has been sentenced to prison.

I wept when I heard this and can barely type this without weeping. Police officers were weeping in court.

How could this happen in this country in the 21st century?

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4gz1dv8ly2o

petra Tue 26-Nov-24 22:48:13

Look at the year she was born, 2020. How many other horrors were not seen because of covid.
I doubt if her birth was ever registered.
She’ll get her comeuppance in prison.

Allira Tue 26-Nov-24 22:51:03

petra

Look at the year she was born, 2020. How many other horrors were not seen because of covid.
I doubt if her birth was ever registered.
She’ll get her comeuppance in prison.

Of course.
There are many awful stories about child abuse during that time, when children could be hidden away.

JenniferEccles Tue 26-Nov-24 22:59:45

What a truly horrific story this is.
Such cruelty is unbelievable.

In my opinion this ‘mother’ should have been given a much longer prison sentence, although I realise judges are bound to a certain extent by guidelines.

Has anything about the family’s background been revealed yet?

annodomini Tue 26-Nov-24 23:09:15

The report I read said that the little girl had never been registered. I suppose that the poor child has never even had a name?

SueDonim Wed 27-Nov-24 00:47:34

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Could she maybe (hopefully) have little to no memory of this time in her life? One can only hope so.

The wee mite may have no memory of it but deep psychological damage will have been done, of abandonment and attachment disorder.

I just couldn’t understand what I was reading, at first, it seemed so outlandish. Did the child never cry? Did she never climb out of the drawer when her mother was absent? The social worker said she thought her own face was the first the child had ever seen apart from her mother’s.

It’s just hideous, as is Sara Sharif’s terrible death. sad

sharon103 Wed 27-Nov-24 01:13:39

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Heartbreaking. Beyond belief. Cruelty of the most wicked kind.

That's what I thought ordinarygirl. Surely the other children would have heard crying.
What a wicked mother she is.

nanna8 Wed 27-Nov-24 06:57:17

I feel sick reading this and I hope the ‘mother’ ( creature) is never, ever allowed to look after any children again. I hope they throw the book at her and she gets what she deserves in jail.

Allsorts Wed 27-Nov-24 07:02:57

I haven't read it as its too much. No good saying lessons are learnt because they are not.

ferry23 Wed 27-Nov-24 07:15:17

I had to read the report on this twice as I truly believed I'd misunderstood it the first time. My brain simply couldn't process the information I was being given.

Tragic. I wish every good fortune upon that child and that she now continues to be able to live in a loving, caring family.

NotSpaghetti Wed 27-Nov-24 07:24:39

It was her partner who discovered the infant, surfingsal
He wasn't allowed upstairs alone so presumably didn't live there.

BlueBelle Wed 27-Nov-24 07:48:33

It’s so tragic all round because the other children will lose a mum to jail There doesn’t seem to be a dad in the picture The mother must have some huge mental health problems surely no one of sound mind could conceive it was alright

The child will be ok she will recover and have little memory unless there is a lot of press reports for her to see when older

I cannot imagine how it could be that no one went upstairs how the other children never ran into the bedroom or heard the poor little thing whimpering or crying It appears the bathroom was upstairs as the partner ran up to the toilet Had no one used the bathroom and heard anything in three years it’s all so weird !!!

Lovetopaint037 Wed 27-Nov-24 07:55:29

Unbelievable! Heartbreaking! Strange situation with the partner not being allowed upstairs and then taking three years for him to find her. I was born in 1941 and I have snap shot memories of war time. Shelter, hiding under a table,being evacuated with my mother even the wallpaper on the bedroom wall. I’m hoping that the time under the bed will remain buried as it was a continual existence with little stimulation.The partner must still be in a state of disbelief. Anyone connected with that case must have trouble sleeping.
.

escaped Wed 27-Nov-24 08:18:24

It's awful. It's too cruel for me to even think of scenarios. I hope the child recovers from the ordeal.

TerriBull Wed 27-Nov-24 08:57:24

The sad thing is lots of children born with cleft palate have it operated on if that's the reason behind keeping her hidden. What a horrifying start poor little girl hope she receives the love and care she needs for a happy childhood from someone else.

Iam64 Wed 27-Nov-24 08:58:20

BlueBelle I wish I shared your belief this little one will recover. Her basic physical, emotional and developmental needs were completely neglected for the first 3 years of her life. With good loving care she can make the strides being reported, beginning to understand that her cries will be responded to for example, and learning to walk and eat food, to communicate. But that extreme neglect of her needs will mean life long emotional and physical needs.
It’s almost impossible to believe she survived.

Allsorts - what lessons do yiu think can be learned here. This was a hidden pregnancy and hidden child, the authorities seem to have had no idea of her existence, in fact it seems only the mother knew.

Sara Sharrif needs her own threads but like other posters, I can barely read the trial reports.

Jeanathome Wed 27-Nov-24 09:01:45

I wonder why we let this stuff into our heads? I am guilty of this.

We match it up with our own experiences and can not comprehend things.
Perhaps we look for reasons, somebody to blame, retribution.

Cossy Wed 27-Nov-24 09:07:00

Jeanathome

I wonder why we let this stuff into our heads? I am guilty of this.

We match it up with our own experiences and can not comprehend things.
Perhaps we look for reasons, somebody to blame, retribution.

This is a horrific story, but it’s important to report and for us to read as this maybe our neighbour, our sister or even our partner!

I’d always report any suspected abuse, it’s not neglect it’s abuse.

Jeanathome Wed 27-Nov-24 09:28:14

Trust me Cossy, I'd be first in line to ring the appropriate services if I suspected something was wrong.

Allira Wed 27-Nov-24 10:06:08

Did she never climb out of the drawer when her mother was absent?
SueDonim, I think the drawer was pushed back under the bed when the mother had dealt with her. It's a wonder she didn't suffocate, it must have been like living in a tomb.

JenniferEccles yes, the sentence was far too lenient imo. I hope there is an appeal and it is increased so at least this woman never has the chance to come out whilst she is of childbearing age.

Iam64 you are right, the experience will have changed her perception of normality and have caused psychological damage.
I can remember things from when I was two.

Allira Wed 27-Nov-24 10:07:20

Cossy

Jeanathome

I wonder why we let this stuff into our heads? I am guilty of this.

We match it up with our own experiences and can not comprehend things.
Perhaps we look for reasons, somebody to blame, retribution.

This is a horrific story, but it’s important to report and for us to read as this maybe our neighbour, our sister or even our partner!

I’d always report any suspected abuse, it’s not neglect it’s abuse.

No-one could report anything as no-one knew of her existence.

The mother carried on life as normal.

Allira Wed 27-Nov-24 10:09:07

Jeanathome

I wonder why we let this stuff into our heads? I am guilty of this.

We match it up with our own experiences and can not comprehend things.
Perhaps we look for reasons, somebody to blame, retribution.

I wonder why we let this stuff into our heads? I am guilty of this.
The problem is, once seen or heard it cannot be unseen or unheard.
I woke in the night thinking of this child's suffering. Then it's difficult to go back to sleep because your mind goes on to other cases.

Granmarderby10 Wed 27-Nov-24 10:17:40

I noted that the child was born in 2020. That year was a black hole for many issues to vanish into was it not?

Fartooold Wed 27-Nov-24 10:19:28

I too believe this poor little soul may not remember her appalling treatment but it is known that children who are even removed at birth still can be traumatised. I read somewhere that babies miss the heartbeat of the birth mother and also her voice!
Hopefully her life will improve.

keepingquiet Wed 27-Nov-24 10:23:54

How was this child eventually discovered?

Although extreme, having had a grandchild born in Covid this story does not surprise me...

So many children left in horrible circumstances and we may well find a few more stories like this, but hopefully not so distressing...

Jeanathome Wed 27-Nov-24 10:25:00

Allira

Jeanathome

I wonder why we let this stuff into our heads? I am guilty of this.

We match it up with our own experiences and can not comprehend things.
Perhaps we look for reasons, somebody to blame, retribution.

I wonder why we let this stuff into our heads? I am guilty of this.
The problem is, once seen or heard it cannot be unseen or unheard.
I woke in the night thinking of this child's suffering. Then it's difficult to go back to sleep because your mind goes on to other cases.

It's hard being a human sometimes.