Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Tonight’s portrait artist of the year…

(61 Posts)
MayBee70 Wed 19-Nov-25 21:05:55

No words really shock

foxie48 Sun 07-Dec-25 18:49:51

I watched the final episode this afternoon and although I wouldn't have picked Chloe as the winner (Kate was my favourite) I really enjoyed watching the process, relationship etc with HR and began to understand the judge's choice. tbh I thought the portrait was really interesting and the likeness much better than I had seen on the internet. Well done Chloe and I think Hannah Fry is ace, such a brilliant role model for females!

LadyGracie Fri 05-Dec-25 15:15:14

I don’t think the final portrait was a great likeness to Hannah Fry who is very attractive and that didn’t come through for me.

I’d rather a ‘proper’ portrait, but each to his own.

Luckygirl3 Fri 05-Dec-25 09:44:50

I loved all her previous paintings/prints, but was less impressed by the final portrait.

PaynesGray Fri 05-Dec-25 09:40:06

Good point. Chlöe’s paintings on aluminium were very popular with the series sitters. People in the public eye, used to seeing themselves on acreen and in photos, are perhaps looking for something striking and different.

The three judges are always looking to push the boundaries of what art is. In choosing Chlöe they chose a young, innovative, experimental artist who perfectly matched the sitter Hannah Fry.

I enjoyed the whole story of the two women, both from working class backgrounds and sharing a love of mathematics; how Chlöe lives in a shared and supportive household of other creatives; how the two women don’t live very far from one another iin London; the immediate rapport between the two and how, as a scientist, Hannah wanted to learn and be involved in the process of making the art, not just to be a passive sitter.

This is the first monotype to join the Royal Society’s historic collection of original portraits, with other techniques including a linocut of developmental psychologist Professor Uta Frith by the author Mark Haddon and a terracotta bust of scientist Dame Miriam Rothschild by sculptor Marcus Cornish. It joins the society’s most recent commissions including Sir David Attenborough by Jonathan Yeo and Dame Jocelyn Bell Burnell by Stephen Shankland. It is also the Royal Society’s first commission of a female sitter by a female artist.

royalsociety.org/news/2025/12/hannah-fry-portrait-sky-arts-portrait-artist-of-the-year/

Red was the obvious colour to chose. A print artist has to work far more quickly than a traditional artist would, to be able to capture the print before the paint dries so we should forgive any imperfections in the work. Although I’m not keen on the rather skeletal left hand, it’s a good facial likeness, captures Hannah’s delicate necklace depicting her daughters’ initials, shows the patterning in the vibrantly-coloured chair she sat in at home and the casual pose and manner she adopted throughout the process.

I really like it. Good series.

MayBee70 Thu 04-Dec-25 18:56:19

I think they chose an artist that would gel with the sitter ( something that possibly has been the case in previous seasons). Although I wasn’t overwhelmed by the commission portrait I could see the reason for choosing the artist and technique used. I think the picture she did of her flatmate was excellent. And all of her previous portraits were the ones chosen by the sitters so maybe they’re better seen ‘ in the flesh’.

foxie48 Thu 04-Dec-25 16:50:05

I preferred Kate's. The monoprint of the boyfriend was so much better than one that Chloe did in the final but Kate's portraits of her daughters were beautiful. I agree that the judges seem to look for something different each year!

JamesandJon33 Thu 04-Dec-25 16:18:36

Well what did you all think to the winner. I admired her work ethic but thought her ‘portrait’ missed the mark somewhat. As portraits the other two were better and I particularly liked Kare’s. Why do the judges always go for the ‘different’ whether there is a likeness or not?

Sarnia Sun 30-Nov-25 10:27:26

Mary Berry must be having nightmares over a couple of those paintings. I know artists see things in their own way and style but surely a portrait ought look like the sitter. My daughter came into the room when I was watching it and asked who it was.

foxie48 Fri 28-Nov-25 18:51:20

MayBee70

I love the expression on the dogs face. I can only assume that all of the artists are allowed to finish off their paintings. Maybe they’re allowed to use photos and grids because of the time constraints?

I think it's generally accepted that many portrait artists use photos and grids give the artist an easy way of getting proportions exactly right and IMHO if the proportions are even slightly off, it's impossible to get a good likeness. (not that I'm in any way an expert!) I love to see how different artists start and how they use different media.

MayBee70 Fri 28-Nov-25 18:22:40

I love the expression on the dogs face. I can only assume that all of the artists are allowed to finish off their paintings. Maybe they’re allowed to use photos and grids because of the time constraints?

foxie48 Fri 28-Nov-25 08:17:45

I think they commented that the dog was a better likeness than MB!

MayBee70 Thu 27-Nov-25 21:58:33

This is it…

MayBee70 Thu 27-Nov-25 21:45:08

One of the finalists showed her painting on instagram after she’d spent an extra hour and a half on it and it’s lovely ( it’s the one that was a great painting of the dog but Mary’s face looked a bit unfinished). I’ll try to find a way of showing it on here.

foxie48 Thu 27-Nov-25 18:06:54

I sat and watched it this afternoon and yes, I also think the best three went through. Sadly some of the artists had a bad day at the office, but it happens. I do a bit of portraiture, I do it very badly, have a pretty rubbish technique but I do at least try to ensure my painting is recognisable as the subject. Some today, definitely missed the mark.

MayBee70 Thu 27-Nov-25 17:28:13

MollyNew

Having watched the semi final it seems to me that the judges might have regretted some of their choices. There were some very disappointing portraits but I think the best 3 went through to the final.

Thankfully the best three got through At least two of the others were dire! And yet I thought that standard, in general, had been pretty good this year. It’s just that the judges seemed determined to choose the worst ones. I feel sorry for the sitters having to try to say nice things about revolting caricatures of themselves.

silverlining48 Thu 27-Nov-25 16:34:41

Despite not knowing much about art, much to my surprise, I picked the winning three.

Wyllow3 Thu 27-Nov-25 16:26:15

JamesandJon33

*Wyllow3*. Have you not noticed that some of the contestants hardly raise their head to look at the model. The boy who does the drawing has his nose about 2 inches from his work, and he never looks up. He is drawing from his phone.

I definitely dont approve of that. Its not just lazy, its missing the point altogether.

Sueinkent Thu 27-Nov-25 16:16:19

All electronic devices should be banned. End of.

MollyNew Thu 27-Nov-25 16:13:09

Having watched the semi final it seems to me that the judges might have regretted some of their choices. There were some very disappointing portraits but I think the best 3 went through to the final.

JamesandJon33 Thu 27-Nov-25 16:06:52

Wyllow3. Have you not noticed that some of the contestants hardly raise their head to look at the model. The boy who does the drawing has his nose about 2 inches from his work, and he never looks up. He is drawing from his phone.

Maelil Thu 27-Nov-25 14:58:49

gall

Luckygirl3 Thu 27-Nov-25 14:56:22

I've just caught up on the programme today. I liked the one on aluminium board, but one of the finalists was very wooden.

JamesandJon33 Thu 27-Nov-25 13:37:14

She got into the last three again last night, with her cartoonish painting of Mary Berry. Honestly.!!!

Wyllow3 Thu 27-Nov-25 00:13:52

And some students chose to use grids and left bits in as part of the picture. It depends what you are trying to say.

Wyllow3 Thu 27-Nov-25 00:11:55

Can anyone dig out a picture to comment on? Generally I dont need my portraits to be visually representational, it's what it conveys over all about the person that matters.

I also agree it's OK to use a mix of photos and the person in front of you in situations like this. It doesnt necessarily mean you get a "flat" portrait at all, it's a "point of reference" that can be helpful.

On my Art BA/MA we didnt use photos, but it was a small, quiet room where we could fully concentrate on the subject.