Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

All Creatures Great and Small

(65 Posts)
JenniferEccles Thu 17-Sept-26 14:16:06

We have a new series starting tonight (17th September) for those who love this gentle portrayal of Yorkshire vets. Hurray!
9pm Channel 5.

posset Fri 18-Sept-26 16:53:43

I've enjoyed all the series, it is a bit of feel-good therapy, although as others have mentioned - it is difficult to keep up with the dialogue, but that's just my inefficient lugs!

polnan Fri 18-Sept-26 15:51:14

for me, it is lovely, better than all the murders and bad stuff on tv

Aveline Fri 18-Sept-26 15:12:53

I definitely prefer the new series. The characters, their clothes and the sets are so authentic. It's not a documentary not us it necessarily repeating the books as written. It's just taking the stories on and developing them further. Wonderful TV viewing.

Ray82 Fri 18-Sept-26 15:01:09

I too prefer the first series.Any remake with new characters and actors always disappoints.The same with all the remakes of Jane Austin and so on.

AweSum72 Fri 18-Sept-26 14:51:53

Im with you Cossy I loved the original so much I cant 'get into' the new one they have done a great modern job of it tho but so many memories and episodes from the original i still remember.

LadyGracie Fri 18-Sept-26 14:47:32

I’ve watched all the series and read all the books, simply because Alf Wight was our vet when we lived in Topcliffe only a few miles from Thirsk.
It’s not as good as it used to be it’s a bit too ‘sweet’ for me.

I love to live in Yorkshire again.

Sadgrandma Fri 18-Sept-26 14:44:20

Many years ago a smart businessman sitting opposite me on a train was reading a book and every so often he would burst out laughing. I noticed he was reading All Creatures Great and Small. Curious, I bought the book and became an avid James Herriot fan. I can’t wait to introduce my DGD to the books, she’s a great animal lover but a bit young for them yet. I loved the old TV series but equally enjoy the new one. I think the trick is to enjoy them all separately . The new series is different but still very enjoyable.

pigsmayfly. Fri 18-Sept-26 14:40:06

Well I love it from the moment it starts to the moment it ends….

Essexgirl145 Fri 18-Sept-26 14:38:36

I'm with Cossy and Olivebranch, the original was wonderful and reflected the era perfectly, the new one does'nt reflect the era at all.

glammagran Fri 18-Sept-26 14:35:01

WelshPoppy

I love it and tend to prefer it to the original which I have watched several times. I read the books as a young teenager which I thoroughly enjoyed but am aware that tv series rarely stick to the books they are adapted from religiously.

I read the books in my teens but can’t say I particularly remember them.

glammagran Fri 18-Sept-26 14:34:03

For some reason I absolutely love this program as does my DH. It’s a long way from what I would normally watch. It’s pure escapism from all the horrors of modern life. I never watched the original of ACGaS or of Poldark but I enjoyed the version with Aidan Turner very much.

WelshPoppy Fri 18-Sept-26 14:31:03

I love it and tend to prefer it to the original which I have watched several times. I read the books as a young teenager which I thoroughly enjoyed but am aware that tv series rarely stick to the books they are adapted from religiously.

JuBut Fri 18-Sept-26 14:29:01

You can't spell

Lesley60 Fri 18-Sept-26 14:21:14

I’ve just gone to record it for later but it just says behind the scenes

esproson Fri 18-Sept-26 14:17:59

Love it love it 😍

CarrotTop Fri 18-Sept-26 14:17:44

I have mixed feelings about ACG&S. As a schoolgirl, I was desperate to go to veterinary college. My dad was old school: "Expensive education is wasted on girls, what's the point of it when all you'll do is get married and have kids," etc, etc.
My secondary school was no help - girls did Biology, boys did Chemistry & Physics, and never the twain shall meet.
Between them all, I didn't get to vet college. Instead, when I left school, I got a job as a trainee nurse with a local vet practice (loved it). The vet retired, I was out of a job and couldn't find another like it.
The odd thing is that, one Christmas, Dad gave me Herriot's book, "I thought you'd like this, you were always animal mad." It was the only book he ever gave me (I was a committed bookworm, btw). Weird.
When I watch ACG&S I get a lump in my throat for what might have been.

Deedaa Fri 18-Sept-26 14:13:32

I'm another one who doesn't like the new version. It's nothing like the books, which is a shame because Samuel West is such a good Siegfried.

The remake of Poldark was just as disappointing. I'm sre the actress who played Demelza was very good, but she didn't have the ethereal quality that Angharad did. And Robin Ellis will always be the only Ross.

Harris27 Fri 18-Sept-26 14:08:59

Absolutely love it. We were fortunate to be in the area when they were filming in the earlier months. The cast are so friendly and the place of the fictional darrowby was lovely. Love it! Just what we need.

Uschi Fri 18-Sept-26 14:02:57

I could not continue watching it. It’s the first time I have seen it and I thought it was absolutely dreadful. I agree with Helena that the dialogue was too fast and I noticed that everybody was manically smiling at each other. I’ve lived in Yorkshire and that’s not how folk behave! I’m a fan of the books and the old series was a much better interpretation of them.

DrWatson Fri 18-Sept-26 13:59:39

For Jennifer, and "no farm animals" - the episode had several references to changing times.

For Olive - same comment, the previous one went through the war, now they will have to adapt (as much of the country had to).

This version of the show scores over the original in that the Housekeeper has a brain and a voice.

Olivebranch Fri 18-Sept-26 13:47:14

The original series were much better, many more animals although I’m dubious about the methods of filming them— were they sedated?
New series far too modern— it’s suppose to show us how things were in the past.

helena Fri 18-Sept-26 13:40:36

I did enjoy it, BUT, being hard of hearing, I found that I struggled to keep up. They all speak far too fast, so reading the subtitles was tricky..

JenniferEccles Thu 17-Sept-26 22:54:10

I’m delighted this series is back but this first episode was certainly not one of my favourites.

Unusual for them not to have any farm animals to treat.

I hope it picks up.

MartavTaurus Thu 17-Sept-26 22:35:23

Surely that cat Alfred wasn't real, was it?

Grandma70s Thu 17-Sept-26 22:12:53

I would enjoy it if it weren’t for the actress who plays Helen, Herriot’s wife. For some inexplicable reason, I can’t stand her.