Gransnet forums

Webchats

Michael Mosley blood sugar webchat Thurs 10 March 1-2pm

(160 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 25-Feb-16 13:01:22

UPDATE: Catch up on our webchat with Dr Michael Mosley further down on the thread.

Join Dr Michael Mosley on Thursday 10 March 1-2pm, when he'll be answering your questions on his new book The 8 Week Blood Sugar Diet. With an estimated weight loss of 14kg in 8 weeks, the book is suitable both for those at risk of raised blood sugar levels, and those who simply want to lose some weight - and keep it off. Add your questions below and don't forget to join us on 10 March for the answers.

Dr Michael Mosley, author of the bestselling 5:2 Fast Diet, reveals a game-changing approach to one of the greatest silent epidemics of our time - raised blood sugar levels.

The food we eat today, high in sugar and easily digestible carbohydrates, is not only making us fat, but is putting us at risk of type 2 diabetes, strokes, dementia, cancer and a lifetime on medication. More than a third of adults in the UK now have raised blood sugar levels and most don’t know it.

In this timely book, Dr Mosley explains why we pile on dangerous abdominal fat and shows us how to shed it, fast. He demolishes common myths, such as the claim that steady weight loss is always better than rapid weight loss and that those who lose weight rapidly will inevitably put it back on.

Buy your copy of The 8 Week Blood Sugar Diet on Amazon.

WilmaKnickersfit Fri 11-Mar-16 23:12:45

MargaretX Michael said most of the research into the effects of intermittent fasting has been carried out on mice. This is backed up by information published in 2013 on the NHS website here. This is an extract

Is there any evidence intermittent fasting increases lifespan?

There is quite a wide range of work on the effects of IF on combating the effects of ageing, but almost all of these studies involved either rats, mice or monkeys. One big problem with studies in animals – particularly rodents – is that they are only expected to live for a few years. While this makes them ideal subjects for longevity studies, carrying out similar, more useful experiments in humans, requires decades-long research to gain credible results.

I don't understand why you mention the fruit fly study, or eating a 300+ cal snack. confused

durhamjen Fri 11-Mar-16 23:06:35

I know, Anya. I read it. Ages ago.
My point was that it was vegetarian.
Have you checked?
Actually, it said no meat, no fish, no dairy, but the French onion soup had beef stock.
So it's not exactly way off, is it?

Do you think the first thing Michael Mosley asked was if he could add meat and fish?

Anya Fri 11-Mar-16 22:30:29

The reason other foods were not permitted was to control exactly the calorific value of the food being eaten in the simplest way possible. It isn't that other foods can't be eaten but for the purpose of that experiment it was necessary to hold as much constant as possible.

So your quip about MM not taking 'notice of it' is way off.

Anya Fri 11-Mar-16 22:23:38

Jen The Newcastle diet experiment for your information.

Under close supervision of a medical team, 11 people who had developed diabetes later in life were put on an extreme diet of just 600 calories a day consisting of liquid diet drinks plus 200 calories of non-starchy vegetables. They were matched to a control group of people without diabetes and then monitored over eight weeks. Insulin production from their pancreas and fat content in the liver and pancreas were studied.

MargaretX Fri 11-Mar-16 10:09:14

I was told by my doctor that if I feel my blood sugar level falling to eat a boiled sweet or a lump of sugar. If taken in time the levels become normal and you dont have to splurge on a 300+ Cal snack.
I've been doing that for 20 years and am not fat ( to use an old fashioned word)
The bit about restricting calories to lengthen life were experiments on flies. They only have a few days of life and were happy to live a day longer, but these kind of experiments are not suitable for humans.
If Mr Mosley bases anything on these then it shows he is concerned about his bank balance and not his patients or followers.

Lyndyn Thu 10-Mar-16 20:16:10

My blood sugar count is one off pre diabetes, a rise of 5 points in 5 months. I am not overweight, my BMI is in the middle of the 'right' weight band and my waist measurement is half my height!

I exercise regularly and consider myself to eat a healthy diet, little meat but chicken, fish and vegetarian meals. Alcohol is a 1/2 bottle of wine a week.

Since 2001 we changed our eating habits considerably and have stuck to it.

My father had type 2 later in life and he wasn't overweight either, so my Dr thinks it is most probably genetic.

I can diet further but I am a size 12, and not sure this is wise or would be effective in terms of not developing type 2!
I also have osteoporosis and early onset arthritis!

durhamjen Thu 10-Mar-16 15:08:39

Another vegetarian here.

Strangely enough the Newcastle 800 calorie diet says no meat, dairy or fish, so Michael Mosley didn't take notice of it.

www.ncl.ac.uk/magres/research/diabetes/documents/StudyRecipes.pdf

WilmaKnickersfit Thu 10-Mar-16 14:54:56

Didn't get back in time, but read through the answers now. Will have a look at the website and I will probably get the book. The more I find out about this whole approach to healthy eating, the more interesting it gets. As a life long sugar addict, I need to find new ways of enjoying my food, otherwise I will always struggle.

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 10-Mar-16 14:10:55

Still. Got a nice last mention of his book in. smile

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 10-Mar-16 14:05:08

Too late. Where did he go?!!!

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 10-Mar-16 14:00:28

Is wholewheat a good carb, or does it turn straight to sugar in your insides?

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:58:44

Bye everyone, have to run. Do visit thebloodsugardiet.com , a friendly website, lots more info etc

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:57:22

"starvation mode" is a myth, or at least you have to lose a lot of weight before it kicks in. The reality is that when you lose weight, by any method, your metabolism will eventually slow down, simply because you are carrying less weight around. It is particularly important once you have lost weight to do more exericise (walk, swim, cycle) but also do strength exericises. These help maintain muscle, and muscle burns calories even when you are sleeping. In The Blood Sugar Diet i describe ways to do this.

migs

I agree with that Anya and also with the science and reasoning behind it. But...800 cals is very low and I struggle on less that about 1200 a day. I just don't see how I could cope on this for any length of time. I'm sure you get used to it eventually but I think that I wouldn't be able to cope with the first few days. I am another who gets very queasy when I haven't eaten enough and I have too much on to be able to take to my bed while my body learns to cope.

Which makes me think of another question for Michael actually

I was reading a piece by Jenni Murray about her gastric surgery yesterday and she talked about how she had tried all sorts of regimes and then as soon as she went back to normal the weight piled on because eating very low calorie for any length of time means your body goes into starvation mode and so when you eat normally afterwards it lays down fat quicker than it would have done before. Is this true? And what happens after the 8 weeks then?

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:52:25

WilmaKnickersfit

Anya I am asking about something that's not covered in the book, but it is related and he should know what I'm talking about. Although scientists found out about resistant starches in the 80s, it's only more recently that their potential has become relevant to low carb eating. Yes, the basic principle is eat less carbs, but there's ways to do this more efficiently being developed for every day eating. Michael is one of the 'faces' promoting this lifestyle. smile

I am a big fan of resistant starches. As the name implies, these are starchy foods that are more 'resistant' to being broken down and absorbed by your body. They are, in many ways, more like fibre. They pass through the stomach and either pass straight through or help feed the 'good' bacteria in your large intestine. Vegetables are a good source of resistant starch. As we recently showed on 'Trust Me I'm a Doctor" it is possible to make pasta more 'resistant' by cooking it, cooling it, and then reheating it.

pollyparrot Thu 10-Mar-16 13:49:54

I'd just like to thank Michael for giving his time to us and answering our questions.

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:48:25

jinglbellsfrocks

So, does animal fat clog the arteries, like butter, full fat milk etc?

There is mounting evidence that the sort of fats found in dairy are not harmful and may be beneficial. People who eat full fat yoghurt, in particular, seem to have lower rates of obesity and type 2 diabetes. I don't think that the sort of fat you get in a meat pie is the same as the sort of fat you get in butter. Just as there are good carbs and bad carbs (ie the sugary sort), there are good fats and bad ones. The worst sort are the transfats, mainly found in processed food. I would much rather eat butter than margarine any day

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:44:40

marissa

I am another who struggles on very low calorie diets. However I am keen to do all I can to avoid diabetes, having previously been told I was at risk of prediabetes.

If I can't follow the 800 cals a day diet what else can I do to help myself? Are there foods (other than the obvious sweets, chocolate, biscuits, refined carbs) that I should limit or cut out altogether?

In the book i suggest three different approach. The fastest is 800 calories a day. A more gradual approach is 5:2 ie 800 calories 2 days a week, eat sensibly (ie a Mediterranean style diet) for the other 5. The third approach is simply to go for a lower carb Mediterranean style diet. This means reducing easily digestible carbs, such as pasta, bread, rice, and replacing with more veg, quinoa, complex grains. The book goes into this in greater depth.

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 10-Mar-16 13:33:57

So, does animal fat clog the arteries, like butter, full fat milk etc?

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:33:27

pollyparrot

If I lose weight slowly, will it have the same effect?

Yes, it doesn't seem to matter if you lose it fast or slow, but for most people it will require substantial weight loss. There is a common belief that it is better to lose weight slowly, though this is not what scientific trials have shown nor what most of the obesity experts i have spoken to believe. The evidence is surprisingly strong that losing weight fast is more motivating, you are more likely to stick to it, and you are no more likely to put weight back on. In the book i include a big section on how to keep your weight down once you have lost it. This is tough (i speak from personal experience) but by no means impossible

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:29:53

BBbevan

I went to the doctor last week for my annual medication review. My blood sugar reading was up. Never happened before, no symptoms and no family incidence of diabeties. I was a bit shocked . Logged on to Gransnet after tea and the first thing I saw was the message about the Dr. Moseley web- chat. Read that and immediately ordered the book. It came on Saturday and I have started thr regime. Very timely for me as I refuse to become diabetic.

Do for you. It is far better and easier to knock this problem on the head before it becomes entrenched. The reason i got interested in the first place was because 4 years ago I discovered, by accident, that i was a type 2 diabetic. I lost over 20lbs (10kg) doing the 5:2 diet and have been fine since. My hero is Prof Roy Taylor, who has been doing careful research in this area for over 20 years

pollyparrot Thu 10-Mar-16 13:27:50

I've lost 10% of my body weight, albeit slowly, since a scan showed my fatty liver. I still have fat around my middle, am I right in thinking I still need to diet?

I can't do the 800 calorie diet because I suffer with acid reflux and an empty stomach makes it worse.

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:26:21

BBbevan

Just diagnosed with T2 this morning. Feeling a bit shocked as I have no symptoms.Started diet 2 weeks ago but only lost 3lb so far Help

You need to keep a very careful and detailed diary of everything you eat and drink. If you are on an 800 calorie diet then it is literally impossible not to lose at least 3-4 lbs a week

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:24:02

pollyparrot

Two questions for Michael.

I have a fatty liver, caused by having too much fat around my middle. Will your diet address this for me?

Am I at risk of having type II Diabetes?

Thanks.

The problem with abdominal fat (the fat you put on round your middle) is that it floods over into your liver and pancreas (think of a bath). We all have our own personal fat threshold where this happens. As your liver and pancreas fill with fat they become less able to talk to each other. The result is rising blood sugars and failing insulin. If you have a fatty liver then going on the 800 calorie diet i recommend in the Blood Sugar Diet will certainly help. The fat in your liver is the first to go. If you don't do anything about it then you are at greater risk of permanent liver damage and type 2 diabetes. Do go to thebloodsugardiet.com for more info. Let me know how you get on

MichaelMosley Thu 10-Mar-16 13:19:22

WilmaKnickersfit

princesspamma Mosely's latest book is aimed at pre-diabetics, those with T2 diabetes and anyone concerned about their blood sugar levels. The clue is in the title. Losing weight is not the primary reason for this book, it's lowering your blood sugar levels.

The diet dovetails with the 5:2 diet, they are not exclusive.

The primary aim, as you rightly point out, is to reduce blood sugar levels and reduce your risk of dementia, heart disease, liver disease etc etc. Unfortunately, if you do have raised blood sugar levels this will almost certainly mean losing a lot of abdominal fat. If are a pre-diabetic (blood sugars raised but not yet in the diabetic range) then losing 10% of your body weight will cut your risk of developing type 2 diabetes by almost 90%
There are lots of different ways to do this, from the turbo-charged 800 calories a day for 8 weeks approach , to 5:2 or simply a lower carb approach. I also have a detailed programme on how to keep the weight off, which involves stress reduction and exercise

pollyparrot Thu 10-Mar-16 13:18:44

If I lose weight slowly, will it have the same effect?