Gransnet forums

Chat

Why not me or my family?

(81 Posts)
Nonnie Tue 30-Apr-19 16:37:10

Well yes, it perhaps should be under Legal but that is a bit serious, although I would like to know why?

One of our DiLs has been called for jury service, which she is happy to do. However she has only been British for a very short time and so asked why none of the rest of the family have ever been called. Is it random or is there some sort of selection?

No, never been arrested, let alone convicted of anything! There is a rumour though that DH was working under cover all his life because he seems to know nothing about his 'specialist subject' grin

watermeadow Fri 03-May-19 18:44:29

I did it once. It was a very serious and responsible job and I did not try to get out of it, despite my employer’s objections, the long 2 buses journey and leaving alone my 4 teenagers and a newborn orphaned puppy.
It was a horrible case, multiple rape of young girl and we jurors were threatened in the near-riot afterwards.

crazyH Thu 02-May-19 21:19:50

I always wanted to be called for jury service . I love anything to do with law etc. But never have been called and never will, now I'm over 70.

Nvella Thu 02-May-19 21:09:50

I loved doing jury service - have been called twice. I have several friends who have never been called.

Bellanonna Thu 02-May-19 10:38:03

My daughter is about to serve for the third time

Alexa Thu 02-May-19 10:26:33

I did two jury duties. From my seat in the jury box , in my loud clear voice I had to ask the official to get a lawyer to speak up as he was an awful mumbler. The official was not paying attention and the judge had to ask the official to pay attention to my request. It was a very boring case to do with people getting lifts on a lorry which was not suited to people- carrying.

M0nica Thu 02-May-19 10:20:19

It is an illusion that how you dress decides whether you are called or not. They just come into the jurors waiting room and read names off a pre-printed list. They do not know who you are until you identify yourself.

For those who long to be jurors, be careful what you wish for. I found myself on a rather odd historic sex abuse case. The offence only just crossed the barrier of being an offence, it only happened once and despite the offender living in the same village all his life and considerable police trawling no evidence could be found of any other offence. Yet it was in court 25 years later. No doubts about his guilt and he was convicted, but it was actually a very troubling case and bothers me to this day.

Littleannie Thu 02-May-19 09:35:25

Several posters have mentioned the cut off age as 70. I'm sure I read somewhere that it has been raised to 75. Am I right?

Granny23 Thu 02-May-19 09:17:22

Like Blinko's Father, I had been advised to turn up in best business suit with severe hair up and it worked - I was rejected as a juror twice.

DanniRae Thu 02-May-19 08:18:01

I have always dreaded being called for lots of reasons and because of this thread I have found out that as I am 70 I will never be called!!
Thank you Nonnie!!

Lumarei Thu 02-May-19 07:32:38

ReadyMeals. Why? What has the culture of a person to do with the British legal system?

I am not British by culture and I feel strongly that if I choose to live in another culture I have to accept their laws AND customs. Violence towards wife and children may be acceptable in my culture but why should a British court system “understand” and be lenient? Law is law.

agnurse Thu 02-May-19 05:15:16

I would love to be called to sit on a jury as well. I took a short course in legal studies when I was in high school and found it quite fascinating.

Currently we live in Canada but are considering moving to the UK (Hubby is a British ex-pat). If we do move, I would like to consider becoming a volunteer magistrate. We do not have a magistrate's court in Canada so it is not something I can do here. (Canadian law is largely based on English common law, with the exception of Quebec which uses the Napoleonic code, but the courts are set up slightly differently.)

quizqueen Thu 02-May-19 01:04:26

I would love to have the experience of sitting on a jury but only have 4 years left ( I think the cut off age is 70). My daughter got called and said she hoped she didn't get a rape case; she did! Also, my ex-husband got called but got out of it because he was away on business.

4allweknow Wed 01-May-19 23:13:35

It is random but I believe you may be excused for various reasons eg you are in the police service, you may have some link relative to the actual crime the defendant is being tried for.

Barleysugar Wed 01-May-19 22:05:17

I am the only one in my family to have done Jury Service, & that was about 25 years ago. I found it very interesting. Would love to do it again, but regretfully too old now.!

grannydarkhair Wed 01-May-19 19:15:22

I'm in Scotland, and have been called three times but never had to actually sit. My (late) older brother was also called three times and was picked on the third occasion. It was a serious assault case, he said afterwards the photos and the evidence was horrible to listen to, and he was really upset for quite a while after it. I have a friend who has also been called three times as have both her adult sons, yet her husband has never been called once.

Growing0ldDisgracefully Wed 01-May-19 18:17:14

As said by others, it's random. I've been called 3 times, despite working in a section of the criminal justice system, which meant I was disqualified from servicing. Just as well as for part of my job I used to have to attend the local magistrates court each day, desperately having to try and stay awake each day due to the tedium!

David1968 Wed 01-May-19 17:31:17

While I've never been called, (and will be too old after 2020) both DS & DiL in USA have been called more than once. (It seems to me that there, people seem to wish to avoid jury duty, as much as possible, because it's seen as onerous and a liability.......)

Kaosbabe Wed 01-May-19 17:30:19

Been called three times, all for different courts. First only one case, second cancelled due to no cases and third at the old bailey and boss said I couldn’t be released as a particular job couldn’t be done by anyone else as colleague was on maternity leave. I find jury service very interesting.

Blinko Wed 01-May-19 15:25:35

DS1 was called when he was two years old! We said he was willing to attend but only if there was someone who could provide suitable food and change his nappy....

Other than that, DH has done it and so did my father. That was at the Old Bailey. As an ex army man, Dad turned up looking very smart with the regimental crest on his blazer and the regimental tie.

He clearly had very little in common with any of the motley defendants, as he was constantly turned down by the defence counsels.

So he never actually sat on a jury, but did plenty of waiting about at the Old Bailey.

cupcake1 Wed 01-May-19 14:21:18

Neither myself, DH or any family members have ever been called. If DH or I had been called during our working life we would have had to disclose a 'bias' in relation to our employment! We would have undoubtedly known the 'accused' and family members -we were on the right side of the law I hasten to add!! grin

minxie Wed 01-May-19 14:10:57

My sister has been called twice, years apart. She’s the only one

Tweedle24 Wed 01-May-19 14:06:12

I was exempt while working and was called soon after I retired, I had to be excused as I was caring for sick husband. I was quite disappointed actually.

PamGeo Wed 01-May-19 13:57:26

I was called once, over 30 years ago on a murder trial, I was going to be selected on a shop-lifting case first but apparently the defendant knew me so I was challenged and replaced. It was enlightening to see how others made their decisions and on something so serious, I vividly remember one young woman who felt so sorry for the defendants family if he was sent down. As far as I know, I'm the only one in my family that has been called for service.

Mycatisahacker Wed 01-May-19 13:19:47

I was called at 18 and dh at 50! I really hope my kids will get the call it’s truly fasinating.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Wed 01-May-19 13:02:18

I always thought that being selected was random - a bit like ERNIE. I've always rather dreaded it in case it was very distressing.
My dad was called many years ago and a colleague.