Gransnet forums

News & politics

Chancellor cuts International Aid budget

(121 Posts)
ixion Thu 26-Nov-20 10:39:43

He says that, in this time of 'unprecedented crisis', he can't justify the commitment.
Do you agree?

MaizieD Fri 27-Nov-20 13:50:24

You'll love this, then, Firecracker. David Cameron named in the top ten of the world's most corrupt politicians grin

www.wonderslist.com/10-most-corrupt-politicians/

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 14:21:35

Shame on the mean mindedness of people who make this sort of statement an excuse for withdrawing help from the poorest and weakest people on this planet.

As usual misinterpreting posts MaizieD
Why?

What I said was:

The Overseas Aid Budget should be much better targeted and overseen as much of the money does get diverted from the purposes for which it was intended and disappears into the hands of corrupt officials along the way
One reason why there should be more scrutiny

Just think what that extra money could do for needy people if it was not siphoned off by corrupt officials.
Or do you think that's par for the course, acceptable?

paddyanne Fri 27-Nov-20 14:28:28

Isn't that what teh Tory government have been doing here ? Siphoning BILLIONS into the pockets of friends and family ...wonder how much will make its way into bank accounts offshore belonging to cabinet ministers and MP's ...You dont have to look abroad for corrupt politicians and NOTHING is being done about it.It has largely been ignored by the media .I wonder why that is ?

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 14:30:19

Yes, that too, paddyanne

I don't know if that is corruption or just sheer incompetence on the part of officials in some cases.

Firecracker123 Fri 27-Nov-20 14:44:39

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

lemongrove Fri 27-Nov-20 15:24:02

Probably a far left blogger Firecracker ?

MaizieD Fri 27-Nov-20 16:40:39

Just think what that extra money could do for needy people if it was not siphoned off by corrupt officials.
Or do you think that's par for the course, acceptable?

Now who's misinterpreting posts?

Did you miss the bit about some of the foreign aid being used to eliminate corruption? That corruption won't go away of its own accord so we have to deal with it?

And you're still making a mountain out of a very small proportion of the aid being siphoned off. If we didn't try to do something about it and we cut the aid, that 7% will still be siphoned off. So what has been achieved? Even less for the disadvantaged. Great thinking, eh?

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 17:14:36

I have never said that Foreign Aid should be cut.

Not only misconstruing, deliberately or otherwise, but fictonalising now.
Not for the first time, I might add.

I ask again - why?

Gwyneth Fri 27-Nov-20 17:26:34

Yes I agree with the decision by the Chancellor at this time. I also think there should be far more monitoring of the aid given to ensure it gets to the people who really need it.

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 17:30:48

It will be less anyway as it is a percentage, not a set amount.

LauraNorder Fri 27-Nov-20 17:34:04

As a percentage of GDP we would be giving so much less anyway so a slash in percentage rate is devastating for poor countries.
Foreign aid benefits all of us.
We do need to find a better distribution route so that corrupt officials don’t benefit and we do need to review our contribution to countries like China and India who have the wherewithal to look after there own.
As for charity beginning at home, if I can afford to give my children three meals a day and one for a child in need and I then lose some income now I can only afford to give to mine. Do I fed mine and let the child in need starve or do I give my children two meals a day and continue to feed the other child one meal a day?

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 17:38:43

I should clarify my post:

The amount would have been less anyway as GDP has dropped; that is without cutting it to 0.5%.

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 17:39:11

X post, LauraNorder

petra Fri 27-Nov-20 17:48:49

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Firecracker123 Fri 27-Nov-20 17:55:17

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 17:57:22

It has to be a joke?
???

MaizieD Fri 27-Nov-20 20:40:41

Callistemon

It has to be a joke?
???

The original post about David Cameron was a wind up...

lemongrove Fri 27-Nov-20 22:59:35

That was obvious Maizie once I had taken a look at the link.
Cameron isn’t on my Christmas card list ( understatement of the year) but in the top ten of corrupt politicians ! ?
The trouble is with these online rubbishy things is that some people will believe it.

Callistemon Fri 27-Nov-20 23:07:13

Like they believe stuff posted on GN.

lemongrove Fri 27-Nov-20 23:09:12

Yes, exactly so.