Gransnet forums

News & politics

The Budget

(204 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Wed 03-Mar-21 13:31:17

Difficult to comment yet, but the tax payer is sinking a huge amount into business - I hope it lives up to the amount of investment we are sinking into it.

MaizieD Fri 12-Mar-21 22:00:45

Too much borrowing will cause Sterling to weaken it doesn’t matter wether is QE or selling to the market.

Katie, could you please explain, preferably in words on one syllable, why 'sterling will weaken'.

The problem with QE is that many see it a not having to be repaid, they don’t realize it is included in the National Debt.

Also, who are 'they'? And why are you mangling the meaning of the word 'debt'? A debt is something owed to someone. QE is created money, not borrowed. It is not debt and doesn't have to be repaid to anyone. Why are you so desperate to make it into a debt?

The only 'debt' element of the deficit is the the money invested in government bonds and government savings instruments. People and institutions 'lending' money to the government, as they have done for centuries for the very good reason that it has been a safe and reliable place to put their money and generates and income from interest paid on the investments. It would be utterly ridiculous for the government to redeem all this. The money would just go elsewhere.

The fact is that the UK never has a surplus to repay any debt, when a loan ends another is taken out to replace it

So what are you worrying about? It's been like this for centuries...

the aim is to give our economy a boost and increase growth,

The only way this is going to happen is for the government to put a great deal of money into the economy. £billions are needed to improve every aspect of our public services and every penny spent on this will benefit private enterprises, large or small, because the government makes just about nothing in the way of resources for any public service it finances. With international trade rapidly diminishing as a result of Brexit, and very little foreign direct investment; as far as I can see, a key source of revenue for UK enterprise is going to be its home market.

growstuff Fri 12-Mar-21 23:29:27

Sorry Katie59. This is absolute nonsense. I'm fed up with trying to disabuse you of such gobbledygook because you keep repeating the same stuff. I'll leave you to it, but you might find it useful at some stage to get a respected book on macro-economics.

Katie59 Sat 13-Mar-21 11:13:34

The problem is that those who do believe the macro economic theories are making such a mess of running the country.
Or do you think that successive governments have achieved a great success in the lowest Sterling exchange rate in history.