This thread is close to my heart having downsized two years ago to a new but familiar area. I have now really understood how even a carefully thought out change still brings losses and some sadness along with joys and benefits. Like PPP we sold our home and bought a bungalow - a project. Why? For future peace of mind, in acknowledgment that one of us will be alone one day so a manageable space for one person, to release some cash, to live somewhere it felt easy and safe to leave empty for holidays - to do it while fit and active.
It has been fun and also jolly hard work. We have made it our own and are very comfortable. Before the move we researched. We have the huge benefit of a regular bus service to our local town and also the coast, another easily accessed bus into the nearest city, local shops that are a few minutes walk away as is our GP surgery.
Our choice was to go for a managed development, we have our own garden with flower beds for me to tend - but grass is cut for us so no worries when we are away. The management fee was a concern, but overall we decided for peace of mind it was worth it - the fabric of the bungalow is maintained, windows are cleaned, grass is cut and I feel totally safe here. The sadness didn't really come until the renovation was finished and then the newness of it all felt alien, as did being away from my professional life. DH hasn't felt it in the same way, perhaps a female thing. I've worked through it and just about come out the other side. There is much to enjoy. Access to the coast, the more relaxed feel, no worries about the building, our kind, friendly and funny neighbours who always have time to talk or help, more time to be 'us'. If I feel sad, and I still do at times, I try to distract myself, it usually works. I have begun voluntary work and started to put down roots in this new area. Again, good to do it while fit and active.
Parting with 'things' was easier than I had believed for me. DH found it harder with a garage full of 'stuff'. We got there, I let my heart lead. I kept what mattered, even if I didn't understand why it mattered.
Apologies for the length of this. Luckylegs I wouldn't dream of telling you what to do, but hoped the flavour of our experience would help in some way. Good luck with your decision.