I don't think IABU!!
Since she came to live here she has been scared to upset him but he tried his bullying again today and she told him to get lost. I am so chuffed. 
I'm sure it won't be all straight forward and we'll have bad days again. She has been much more upbeat since too!
DD3 was the sort of person who would argue the point with anyone and stand up for people being bullied or harassed before she met the Idiot. Since she left him we have learnt some awful things about his treatment of her, mostly from her sisters or her friend, so we are thrilled to have progress!
Ethical question - how do you feel about second chance??


and there are a couple if people I'd use it for !