Gransnet forums

AIBU

KatGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 13-Aug-15 15:22:36

Why do girls want to be princesses?

Yasmeen Ismail challenges gender stereotypes we often see in products marketed to children - what is deemed an acceptable way for girls to behave, and what girls should like to spend their time doing.

Yasmeen Ismail

Challenging gender stereotypes

Posted on: Thu 13-Aug-15 15:22:36

(127 comments )

Lead photo

'Boy colours' and 'girl colours' - do they really exist?

When I was little I had a secondhand BMX bike. I was happy that I knew how to ride it without stabilisers (my sister taught me), and I relished in my independence. The boy down the road teased me for riding a "Boy’s bike." I remember puzzling over what exactly made it for boys. I was riding it, surely that was okay?

True to form I knocked at the front door of his house and told on him. I told his mother that her son was being mean and called my bike a 'boy’s bike'. She conceded and told me that as punishment he wouldn’t get his Kinder Surprise "this week". I suddenly had more pressing injustices to worry about... "He gets a Kinder Surprise every week!"

When my sister was little she had short hair and glasses. She wore dungarees and she was teased for being 'like a boy'. She begged our mother to let her grow her hair long, but (for reasons unknown) she wasn’t allowed. She put up with the cruelty of the other children, but it was hard on her. She is a Computer Scientist and has four children herself now. She is a wonderful mother.

Her two eldest are my niece and nephew. My nephew seems to think the sky is the limit when it comes to imagining his future. He would like to be a scientist, an explorer or an engineer. It changes daily, and he knows that he can do anything.

Why are we telling them that they are different and that their reading material has to be segregated?


My niece would like to be a princess. I don't mind that she wants to be a princess. It sounds great; A castle, jewels, adoration, dresses, carriages and horses. I don't mind that she wants to wear pink, and I don't mind that she wants sparkles on everything. The worry that I have is that the only reason she wants to be a princess and in pink might be because that is the main option that is presented to her.

This might not be true, but when I walk around and see aspiring princesses everywhere, I start to wonder where it's all come from. If I look to the bookstores, I can't move for books 'for girls' and books 'for boys'. Why are we telling them that they are different and that their reading material has to be segregated?

And the funny thing is, is that many "boys" books proffer achievable careers in such things as construction, engineering, and medicine, whilst there is an overwhelming amount of books for girls very focused on being a princess. But being a princess, you can only be born or marry into that.

So what is the message? Marry well? And what does that say about my niece? She can focus on dressing, acting and looking a certain way in order to meet her future prince (because, believe me, she hasn't been born into royalty). It would seem to me that her quest started when she received her first princess book. I love my niece. I am fiercely protective of her, but I need books to help me give her more options; to tell her that she is young and that the world is her oyster, and that she can do anything she wants. I don't want her to limit herself. I don't want her to say, "I don't want to be an engineer because that's for boys."

I want her to be happy and I don't want her to feel that she can't do everything she wants to do. I have full confidence that she will be fine in the future. Her parents are wonderful and will care for her and help her to be strong and smart and ambitious. I have no doubt that she will be happy, but I can't say the same for every little girl. If she chooses to be a princess then so be it, as long as that's HER choice.

Yasmeen Ismail's picture book I’m a Girl is out now and available from Amazon. Post your thoughts on the thread to win one of 10 copies.

By Yasmeen Ismail

Twitter: @YasmeenMay

Nelliemoser Sun 25-Oct-15 10:12:13

Way back in the 1950s my dads foster "sister in law" had four boys. The two yr old had said he wanted a dolls pram and Auntie Kath made sure he had one, very unsual for those days.

mischief Sun 25-Oct-15 09:40:36

It doesn't help when my daughter calls my GD 'Princess' and we now have Princess No. 2. I really don't like it but I daren't comment. I just have to wait until they all grow out of it. wink

allule Fri 04-Sep-15 12:27:25

Toys, not moths!

allule Fri 04-Sep-15 12:24:34

Sorry, toys, not moths! Should have previewed

allule Fri 04-Sep-15 12:22:23

I blame commercialism.
When our children were young, most things were unisex...clothes, bikes,moths, bedding....and passed on.
Now manufacturers have realised that if they can ensure that if a second child is a different gender, everything has to be replaced and new items bought, they make a lot more profit.

felice Mon 31-Aug-15 10:01:57

Book arrived this morning, it is great and DGS loves it already, many thanks.

Elrel Sun 30-Aug-15 23:04:54

Many thanks for the copy of 'I'm a Girl!' Looking forward to sharing it with my granddaughter - and her brother! Lovely, lively book!

Falconbird Sun 30-Aug-15 07:02:01

Thanks for the book "I'm a Girl." It arrived yesterday and it's lovely. I'm going to give it to my Gd1 who is four and just starting school. smile

thatbags Tue 25-Aug-15 19:06:44

Blackeyed, you are a breath of fresh air. Many thanks for your contributions! Think you deserve a birthday3

BlackeyedSusan Tue 25-Aug-15 18:56:54

Mine wanted to be a fire fighter and now a scientist: which is an achievement as their dad is rather sexist. understatement if of course she decides on something more stereotypically girly later that will be fine, as long as she knows she has options.

Ds has a harder time of choosing stuff that is not stereotypically male. He used to love pink, he chose to buy a baby from the toy shop, and his dad looked like he had chosen a dead, rotting rat filled with maggots

felice Tue 25-Aug-15 16:15:04

Looking forward to receiving the book; have sent a UK address in case the publishers do not want to send to here.

Marmark1 Tue 25-Aug-15 09:38:44

What's,I'm a girl,all about,and why have we won one.

Marmark1 Tue 25-Aug-15 09:35:00

Far north,of course the child wasn't in the room at the time.
And incidentally,in my opinion,ballet,is very physical,We laughed at my nephews antics.
Remember I told you I'm a Equalforall person.
I don't discriminate,even dislike people who do.

valleysgirl Mon 24-Aug-15 20:44:21

I have 2 friends with grandchildren who are autistic, and I just thank God that my 2 (1 of each sex) seem not to have that condition, as it seems to cause such worry and heartache. So I just don,t care if the 2 year old boy wants to wear a pink princess dress to nursery or if the 1 year old girl will want to explore Mars when she gets older, just so long as they are happy and healthy.
A colleague of mine had a little boy who only wanted 1 gift for Xmas, a pink sweeping brush. But it HAD to be pink. He was then 3 years old, and has just been accepted in Oxford University.

Live, love and say thanks every day .Nanna Val.

Falconbird Mon 24-Aug-15 20:36:49

Me too!!! First thing I've won for years. smile

rubylady Mon 24-Aug-15 20:11:01

Thank you very much for the book, looking forward to receiving it. X

WilmaKnickersfit Mon 24-Aug-15 19:57:22

Yay! I won a copy of the book! grin

marpau Mon 24-Aug-15 14:11:29

I'm sure when your niece reaches an age when fairy tales are no longer her choice of reading matter her aspirations will change ��

KatGransnet (GNHQ) Mon 24-Aug-15 12:28:27

Congrats to...

trisher
Faraway43
JaxKerr
WilmaKnickersfit
felice
Falconbird
Elrel
rubylady
Marmark1
Leticia

...who have all won a copy of I'm a Girl. Please check your emails for more info.

Falconbird Mon 24-Aug-15 06:46:01

When my two eldest sons were 6 and 7 they went to ballet classes. They also went to Ice Skating, swimming, Karate and drama because I wanted them to have fun and experiences.

The Ballet teacher said that the youngest son showed great promise as a dancer and even spoke of The Royal Ballet School in the future!!! He was a tubby little boy but she said that he would grow to be tall - she was right he is 6 feet tall. In his teens he was very supple and good at gym.

However, because the class was predominately full of little girls my sons didn't like the classes much and this wasn't helped by my fil's comments about "poofters"

The final straw came when the teacher said she would like to see the youngest boy in tights - there was no way he would go along with this - so it was goodbye ballet classes and who knows - goodbye to a successful male ballet dancer.

If my son had been a girl things would have been very different. Thank goodness times have changed and thank goodness for the film Billy Elliott.

absent Sun 23-Aug-15 20:53:11

Many years ago, some time in the 1960s, the ballet class before mine on Tuesday evenings in London was for footballers – it's a great aid to elevation.

FarNorth Sun 23-Aug-15 20:34:35

"the boy used to go along to his sister's ballet lessons".
Wasn't it just that they both went to ballet lessons?

I believe many non-british footballers use dance training as well as normal football training to improve their skills.

granjura Sun 23-Aug-15 18:03:23

Can anyone remember the documentary where they placed a baby about 9 months in a waiting room with his/her mum and then she asked someone coming into the room to look after baby whilst they went to see the doctor? Each time they changed the baby's clothes, clealy a boy for some of the times, and clearly a girl for others. There was 2 piles of toys- some clearly 'boys' and some clearly 'girls' - in each case, the way the person dealt with and reacted to, the child, spoke to them, chose the toys, etc- was totally different depending on whether said child was wearing boys or girls clothes. And on a day to day basis- it all adds up to a huge influence. Can anyone deny this?

And it is much easier nowdays for a girl to play rugby as well as do ballet, then for a boy to do ballet and play rugby- that is for sure.

Tegan Sun 23-Aug-15 17:51:44

My friend had twins, a boy and a girl and the boy used to go along to his sisters ballet lessons. She said that it was very good for coordination etc and would stand him in good stead when he played football, which I'm sure it did.

FarNorth Sun 23-Aug-15 17:20:33

Do you mean you laughed at a little boy for doing ballet? And that his dad tutted and rolled his eyes "only jokingly of course"?
If so, the child would obviously pick up that his family thought there was something odd about what he was doing. He would not feel that it would be fine to continue with that.