Hear, hear, anno.
Gransnet forums
AIBU
Texting birth announcements
(104 Posts)When my daughter was expecting her baby, we had agreed that her husband would phone us when the baby had arrived. This arrangement superseded others. We had started with me being asked to be the second birthing partner (much to my surprise as I had never expected to be involved), with the expectation that I would be sitting outside the labour ward and invited in as soon as was practical once baby had arrived. This changed as they decided to opt for a home birth and decided they wanted the privacy - totally understood (and quite relieved). In the event, baby was 17 days late and when yet another text arrived on my mobile my first thought was 'Who else is pestering to see if baby has arrived yet?'
I was therefore surprised and shocked to find a text FROM MY DAUGHTER announcing the arrival of her newborn. It was quite formally written ' Proud to announce' - with the full name and weight of the baby and the paragraph ended with 'congratulations grandparent' - so a text that was sent to all grandparents (I am divorced from her father). A second paragraph informed me that there had been some complications (didn't say what) and she was not yet on a visitor ward and SIL would phone later to update about visiting.
I responded by texting back amazed congratulations and ended with saying 'Now rest!' - hated the sterility of this - and then the wait began for more information. Hours ticked by, during which my mind was racing ... the fact that she had the baby in hospital meant things had gone wrong as she was planning a home birth ... the fact that there were 'complications' and she wasn't yet on a visitor ward and needed monitoring - I began to wonder if she had had to have a caesarean ...
It was a long time before I got more information. She had had a bad time and lost a lot of blood, but a 'normal' birth. I had waited 6 hours before texting her husband to say could I visit briefly as I was so anxious about her and then another hour before she rang to say 'Yes, come up.' (I live an hour/15 mins away).
I have balanced this with husband not wanting to leave her side, but can't help feeling that stepping outside for a few minutes and having an actual conversation earlier would have allayed a great deal of angst. I also know I was probably extra anxious because I have lost a daughter and I had a very difficult first delivery and was at risk myself and I had been very fearful for my DD as she is same build / height etc. and baby was not in a good position ...
I know that as a couple they had gone through the mill - however, perhaps this is a suggestion, rather than a complaint - I just don't think a text was the right way to be informed ... a phonecall would have been so much more helpful.
It has taken me four weeks to articulate this - I just think I was so shocked and stressed by how it all unfolded. If there is another baby one day, I think I need to ask SIL to phone next time!
GS2 was born at about 9.30pm but I didn't find out till the following morning. SiL couldn't get a phone signal at the hospital and by the time they got home at 2.30 am they thought we would be in bed asleep (True!) I took GS1 home at about 8am and found both of them in bed with GS2 I had presumed she must still be in the throes of a protracted labour but he had popped out in a couple of hours.
We are really spoiled aren't we by good communication systems! When my mum had my brother in the 60s she was in Africa so family in UK (including me at boarding school) had to wait for an airmail letter!
I think a text would have saved time..sent to all in one go... when the new family were in a bit of a tizz following a stressful time.
I was lucky to be with DD2 for her first baby but DD1/SiL sent a text when their babies arrived. I was in hospital when DD2 had 2nd baby and got the news at next visiting time!
I really recommend you try hard not to dwell on the style of how the news was communicated but focus on the joy of having a lovely new grandchild and do not jeopardise future fun and happiness over a decision made at a stressful time for the new parents.
Dear all,
I think I have been 'cured' of any sense of 'dwelling' with what made me sad, thank you.
Lots of empathetic and sensible advice, from a variety of perspectives. That is when GN is at its best. There is clearly a breadth of opinion about what is or is not reasonable.
I think I will always belong to the camp that does not see a text as good communication, but depending on circumstances I can see that for some it would be very valuable. So much depends on circumstance.
Signing off from this for good now. 
DH always prefers a 'phone call, no matter what. He doesn't understand "mobile" 'phones. Often if I text him or ring him when he's out, his 'phone is in the kitchen. On the other hand, I'm "down" with the kids, texting and whatsapping and I rarely speak on the 'phone. It's the way of things now and it's no use fighting it.
I wonder if "the camp that does not see texting as good communication" is the same camp that will not see whatever technology that replaces texting as good communication, and the same that would rather have a had a person visiting with news than a letter, and rather a letter than a telegram, and rather a phone call than a message via facebook or text?
Basically, it's a way of whining, a way of saying you (that's an impersonal you; I'm talking about an idea now, nor any particular person) want something different from what you have been given.
Some people are never happy, always focussing on what they dislike about the means of communication instead of on the actual meat of the message. In its worst forms I regard this as a kind of emotional blackmail, a method of trying to exert control over how other people behave.
Before texting came in, it was "They couldn't be bothered coming to visit me, they just phoned"
I think that texting is an excellent way to communicate, but only when the sender is able to express themselves clearly. Unfortunately a lot of texts are quite ambiguous, and can cause confusion, amongst other things.
The development of technology that enhances communication is a good thing. It also raises expectations, which is not necessarily a good thing, when those expectations are not met.
I honestly cannot remember how I received the news of the birth of any of my grandchildren. I have no mobile connection where I live, the Internet is unpredictable - we have a land line though which is a little more constant.
Time zones also impact.
What I'm trying to say is that from my perspective, the concept of having instant information about the major life events of any of my family is close to zero.
The thing is, I just know that my adult children have my best interests at heart, and will contact me as and when.
Of course the immediate period after especially a difficult labour is time for the new parents and their baby. And the thing about a text is that it can be sent to more than one person. The proud Dad is better to be with his wife and baby than out in a hospital corridor disturbing people with his mobile phone!!
I was looking after the DGSs when DD went into hospital shortly after midnight to have number 3. SIL sent a text and picture to the other granny and me simultaneously a very few hours later. We were then on the phone to each other, of course, and SIL came home mid morning to shower etc.
My point? He was totally evenhanded with both sides of the family, we got to see DGD or a picture of her and her mummy a very short time after she was born, and they had those first precious hours together.
We are not the most important people in their lives, even if they are to us. You learn this with your first grandchild and if you think back, Twas ever thus.
When DGS was on the way we left DD with SIL in the hospital because things seemed to be going very slowly. We then spent many anxious hours waiting to hear if the baby had arrived safely and didn't hear anything. When we phoned the hospital we were just told that things were progressing and as we were staying in a nearby hotel decided to go to bed, sleep and walk along to the hospital first thing the next morning. When we arrived we found a very poorly DD who had spent two hours in surgery and was still completely 'out of it', DGS sleeping peacefully and SIL's parents sitting smiling in DD's room; they had been there since the crack of dawn.
So I think a text letting all the grandparents know at the same time was probably a good idea Imperfect27, fair all round.
I would have been upset too. DD and son-in-law didn't ring me for hours after my first grandson was born. I was quite upset at the time. Still am when I think about it, even though I know they would have both been quite overwhelmed with it all. I think as mums, we get very emotionally involved. So our feelings are quite raw at the time.
I was more upset when the midwife sent DH home because everything had gone quiet with my labour, saying I would be transferred to the main hospital the next morning and induced. DS arrived suddenly in the middle of the night but the midwife 'forgot' to phone DH and let him know. It was only when I said that the next morning that I was surprised DH hadn't been in to see me that she 'remembered' she hadn't phoned and told him he was a father (again).
Well, I wasn't 'more upset' actually, because I was more upset about DD when she had DGS. 
I totally agree that there is absolutely no need for rudeness . Seems to me that there is more and more of it these days when people post . I often wonder if it's because it's all just online and would they dare be so brave to say these things to your face ?
GS1 was expected just after Christmas. Arrived by caesarean in emergency circumstances late one night in mid-October. Living in central London they could be quickly at a well equipped hospital. Neither mother nor baby were out of danger for several hours and days respectively.
The first I knew was when SiL rang me next morning. He must have had a harrowing night. I was 100 miles away and don't drive. I went to see them the following day, the baby's chances were improved from the initial 50-50 by then.
Until reading this thread it had not occurred to me that he might have phoned me sooner. I am content that he did the right thing for everyone in very difficult circumstances. We were all just so thankful that a bad situation ended well.
I'll never forget seeing that tiny fragile baby for the first time. By his due date he had even been at home in time for Christmas.
How different things might have been in a different century or continent.
I don't think our adult children have the slightest idea how absolutely visceral our responses are to knowing that they are in trouble, whether a health problem, an emotional upset, an accident, a financial issue or whatever. It is only when they become parents themselves and experience the same levels of anxiety, even fear, combined with a terrible sense of helplessness about their own children's troubles that they begin to understand. I can't speak for all my own generation but I was certainly oblivious of how much anxiety my parents suffered at my hands until my infinitely precious absentdaughter came along.
Very true absent. I look upon my relationships with my M and F through a new lens now - changed again with the advent of grannydom,
Sometimes a 'to the point'comment it is just the thing you need to make you reflect on your own opinion/point ...like smelling salts when people fainted!
Personally, I like letters written with a quill and ink and hand delivered by a smartly attired footman.
Texting is now the most popular form of communicating.
Could the footman be changed to a fireman? 
This post was a big learning curve for me and I did value being made to stop and think even if I didn't always appreciate the method ...
I think all my angst came out of the history of losing my DD2. I think that is what it was - deep anxiety that put me off kilter for a while.
If someone texted me with important information or news I would probably never know for weeks, the DC got exasperated then gave up 
Yes, grannydom does make us look back on our relationship with our DP through new eyes.
Yes, you may have a fireman ( no extra charge.) 
Worry can make us all go out of kilter at times.
absent I think they are always on our minds to a greater or lesser degree whereas it is not the same for them - their own DC will be the ones on their minds.
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »
