Gransnet forums

AIBU

Oxfam

(31 Posts)
kircubbin2000 Fri 17-Mar-23 09:49:56

I wonder how many thousands were spent producing the latest revolting, virtue signalling ad that could have been spent helping children.

Caramme Mon 01-May-23 15:21:33

The vocabulary thing is laughable and Oxfam deserves to be derided for that and many other reasons. I no longer give to any of the big charities as I don’t trust any of them, though I will donate through DEC in the wake of terrible disasters. Nor do I ever donate to just giving pages. I support our local hospice whose income slumped to dangerous lows during the pandemic.

Grammaretto Mon 01-May-23 16:12:07

When Oxfam began it was the Oxford Committee for Famine Relief, based in Oxford, started by Quakers. All well and very good
That was back in 1942 to address the famine in Greece caused by the blockade by Axis and to persuade the British government to allow food through.
It was successful and grew. Other charities followed suit and became even bigger.
The charity turned business became the way forward

Our local Oxfam shop was the last in Scotland to remain entirely run by volunteers. It no longer is. There's a manager now
You make more money if you run a charity as a business than you do by relying on local goodwill.
Spend more to make more.
I support our local branch. It's the best and only department store in our town!
I donate and buy. I buy greetings cards, knitting wool and needles, curtains, toys,

This whole PC thing sounds demented though. confused

biglouis Tue 02-May-23 12:39:40

Like another poster upthread I do not donate to any of the "big" charities and their tasteless national appeals. I do donate through the DEC if there is a big disaster somewhere like the earthquake in Turkey. The one exception is that I do donate to St Dunstans (a charity to help disabled veterans which is part of the British Legion) as they helped my parents a lot.

Witzend Tue 02-May-23 13:07:00

For well over a year my dd was working for an NGO in post-earthquake Haiti, when the ‘abuse’ was going on. I have used inverted commas because she was quite convinced that what it virtually always amounted to, was the use of adult prostitutes, which she said were ‘everywhere’ and were only too keen to get the money. Even before the earthquake, unemployment (she told me) was running at 60%. But although it was rife, prostitution was officially illegal in Haiti.

She was not at all sure why Oxfam was singled out, since she said workers from every NGO - including the most supposedly holy and virtuous - were using prostitutes. A friend of hers, working for a household-name NGO (not Oxfam) had complained to her immediate managers that male co-workers who shared her accommodation, were bringing prostitutes in.

The response was, ‘If you don’t like it, find somewhere else to stay.’

I might add that she’s worked in post-disaster zones in various different countries, and has said that among male NGO workers, often of every nationality under the sun, use of local prostitution is not at all uncommon, and in most countries is not illegal. Anyone inclined to deplore such use, she said, might do well to remember that the men are working far from home, often for very long periods, and frequently in extremely difficult conditions, which people sitting comfortably at home probably can’t begin to imagine.

Pigma Tue 02-May-23 17:14:19

I will never, ever give a single penny to Oxfam. Many years ago I was involved through the local council in Oxfam holding a big event in our city in the north. They travelled up and down by train, all in first class carriages, they booked out blocks of rooms and suites in the best hotels, many of which were unused, they booked and paid for conference venues in many hotels and conference centres. again many not used. They booked and paid for caterers who were not used and much food was wasted. The total waste of money was sickening but so was their ‘so what?’ attitude and no attempt made to save any money by being more careful and organised. I was totally ashamed to even be involved with them and they’ve not had anything from me since, nor will they.