Gransnet forums

AIBU

I hate Chicken soup

(31 Posts)
surfingsal Fri 11-Apr-25 15:13:43

My husband loves homemade chicken soup, so every now and again I will make a large batch , I hate the smell it makes me feel sick and I find the whole process long winded but I know its his favourite and the fact he says it is nicer than his mothers is a nice compliment .
Today was the day I thought I could open all the windows to get rid of the smell , so after simmering the chicken etc for most of the morning it was all cooked and ready to strain, shame I forgot to put the dish underneath the sieve ! most of the soup went down the drain before I realised what I had done, I think there is enough for a couple of bowlfuls , I didn't know whether to laugh or cry !

lixy Fri 11-Apr-25 15:18:39

There are words that I keep in reserve for exactly this kind of situation. My aunt used to say ‘I’m just going out for a bit of Anglo-Saxon therapy’ and disappear into the garden shed.

I hope you managed to say a lot of them very loudly without anyone overhearing! and that it helped.

welbeck Fri 11-Apr-25 15:20:30

Why don't you just buy some good quality ready made chicken soup.
Hide it in the fridge and add a few onions or carrots or spices.
Would he really notice the difference.
It would save you all that labour and the smell.

Old saying
Any fool can be uncomfortable in the jungle.
The trick is To be comfortable.

Greyduster Fri 11-Apr-25 15:34:55

My DH could never stand the smell of chicken soup cooking either. It ranks second in my top five “last meals on earth”, just below fish pie, which he couldn’t stand either. And home made chicken broth/soup is extremely good for you, so you are catering for his health too😁!

JoyBloggs Fri 11-Apr-25 16:02:45

I think you are a hero making this stuff! Dare I say that 'down the drain' is the best place for all the varieties of chicken soup that I have consumed (although yours may be in a league of its own!). I do feel so very sorry for you...I'd be heartbroken after all that faff and stink. I'd definitely have cried, not laughed!

ViceVersa Fri 11-Apr-25 16:04:57

Oh, I love making chicken soup - in various varieties! I just love making soup full stop, in fact. And homemade chicken soup is very good for you - it's not known as Jewish penicillin for nothing.

M0nica Fri 11-Apr-25 16:05:10

You can buy ready made fresh chicken stock in some supermarkets. Buy that and then just add the extras.

Your DH could of course make his own chicken soup, and you could go out on the days he makes it.

JaneJudge Fri 11-Apr-25 16:13:06

I’ve done this before too 😊

surfingsal Fri 11-Apr-25 16:16:12

M0nica

You can buy ready made fresh chicken stock in some supermarkets. Buy that and then just add the extras.

Your DH could of course make his own chicken soup, and you could go out on the days he makes it.

I have tried that in the past , the look on his face after one spoonful said it all ! I think the smell of the simmering Chicken is preferable to letting him loose in the kitchen .

whywhywhy Fri 11-Apr-25 16:27:15

I also hate the smell of chicken soup. Yuk!

Shelflife Fri 11-Apr-25 17:46:29

I have done the same with a seive! 😂

Labradora Fri 11-Apr-25 18:32:59

Me too ! I don't like chicken soup bit unlike you I don't have to prepare it.
You're a hero for doing it. Lucky your OH appreciates it.

Dottydots Fri 11-Apr-25 18:34:23

Yes, I've done the same and boy didn't I scream out.

Witzend Mon 14-Apr-25 09:56:54

Shelflife

I have done the same with a seive! 😂

I’ve done it with a colander. So mad at the waste - all that gas while simmering the carcass, too! I use the stock in various dishes, not just soup.

foxie48 Mon 14-Apr-25 13:15:56

I don't make chicken soup but I do make stock. I use an Instapot using the pressure cooker function but I let it go cold before removing the lid and straining it. That greatly reduces the smell and also the cooking time.

Cabbie21 Mon 14-Apr-25 13:56:55

I’m not keen on chicken soup but sometimes have just blitzed leftovers from a slow-cooked chicken casserole and eaten it as soup, reheated in the microwave. Hardly any smell.

Oreo Mon 14-Apr-25 14:03:14

ViceVersa

Oh, I love making chicken soup - in various varieties! I just love making soup full stop, in fact. And homemade chicken soup is very good for you - it's not known as Jewish penicillin for nothing.

👍🏻
Nothing like homemade chicken soup for the body and soul.

Oreo Mon 14-Apr-25 14:04:45

I do feel for you surfingsal losing the soup after all that work.
A senior moment, and we all have them.

Primrose53 Mon 14-Apr-25 19:06:59

I did this as a young bride cooking our first Xmas lunch. Cooked and sieved the giblets and pushed the cooked carrots and onions through it too. Then realised I hadn’t put my jug underneath and it all went down the plug hole.

AuntieE Thu 17-Apr-25 15:10:16

Can't he make the soup himself? Then you could go for a nice long walk, shopping trip or anything else while he cooks and airs the kitchen.

Catterygirl Thu 17-Apr-25 23:12:52

I love homemade chicken soup especially if I have a cold. Understand where you’re coming from though as hate the smell of cinnamon cooking and have to leave the room.

leeds22 Mon 21-Apr-25 14:12:37

Thought it was just me who couldn't stand the smell of chicken soup.
Love the Anglo-Saxon therapy idea.

DianaLouise Mon 21-Apr-25 14:18:21

not sure where you live but in this area we have a small Jewish population and Waitrose stocks brands called Osem and Telma which is vegetarian but tastes similar to chicken soup. add some dumplings and he wont be able to tell the difference.

Greciangirl Mon 21-Apr-25 14:53:18

Yorkshire Provendor Chicken and Vegetable soup.
Available in most supermarkets is absolutely delicious.

I couldn’t make it the same.
It’s really nourishing.

Try it. You won’t regret it and maybe get Dh to try and save you the trouble of making it from scratch.

Thisismyname1953 Mon 21-Apr-25 15:49:20

I’m not bothered by the smell of chicken soup cooking , but what I can’t stand is the smell of cheese cooking . My granddaughters favourite meal is macaroni cheese and if I walk into the kitchen and it’s in the oven then the smell sends me straight out again .