Gransnet forums

AIBU

So many questions being asked!

(46 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

tanith Fri 17-Jul-26 16:26:42

Is it just me or am I imagining something that is just simple curiosity? Just hope they aren't fishing for information?

Whitewavemark2 Mon 20-Jul-26 12:49:18

I’m sure if someone was keeping a record, there would be quite a profile being built up about individuals.

It does seem a bit odd

Cossy Mon 20-Jul-26 12:51:19

I too find it odd, but have probably replied to some!

Cossy Mon 20-Jul-26 12:55:46

Ooops just replied to one today! So have others 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Shel1951 Mon 20-Jul-26 13:08:09

Some are so silly I don't answer, but I have answered a few, my passwords are so random even I often don't remember them and have to keep resetting, I do enjoy gadgets folk find good,recipes,easy ways to do things(my favourite) and so I feel I should contribute something

Farmor15 Mon 20-Jul-26 13:14:04

The answers can be quite interesting, but if the OP asking the questions came back on thread to comment or engaged in other threads it might help us believe they were genuine.

MawsRosie Mon 20-Jul-26 13:15:14

I wonder if somebody is trying to set a new record for the most threads started in two weeks?

Alwaysoptumistic Mon 20-Jul-26 14:21:38

The question re height was posted on Reddit today at roundabout the time it was posted on here. 🤔

MawsRosie Mon 20-Jul-26 14:25:12

So are you suggesting copied?
Lack of original ideas?

Alwaysoptumistic Mon 20-Jul-26 14:28:48

MawsRosie

So are you suggesting copied?
Lack of original ideas?

Could be a bot/ai. It's a strange question to ask. I am baffled by the questions the poster is asking

Dickens Mon 20-Jul-26 15:26:35

Sago

The previous threads were asking where your dog slept, what can you see from your window.

It was verging on creepy so I did report it.

I think this is less sinister but a little odd.

... if I were intent on burglary - that's the kind of information I'd probably want to know... hmm

Retread Mon 20-Jul-26 15:31:28

Perhaps GNHQ is using a bot to "stimulate discussion". 😌

LilyGransnet (GNHQ) Mon 20-Jul-26 15:40:55

Hi all,

We do understand why some of you have raised concerns, and we’ve taken a look at the threads. At the moment, though, we can’t see anything that would justify us taking action.

The posting style may feel a little unusual to some, but asking lots of questions is not, in itself, against the Talk guidelines. The threads are prompting decent discussion, and users can choose whether to join in or simply ignore.

Of course, if we saw any evidence of trolling especially inappropriate attempts to gather personal information, or any other breach of the guidelines, we would review it. At present, we haven’t seen anything to suggest that is happening.

We’ll continue to keep an eye on things, and do keep reporting your concerns no matter how small, as we're always happy to take a further look.

Charleygirl5 Mon 20-Jul-26 16:00:34

I personally don't like the questions asked, so I ignore this thread.

Dickens Mon 20-Jul-26 17:21:08

I've asked Google AI about these posts asking lots of questions. Here's the response. You can choose how you respond smile

Your community's instincts are spot-on. This is a very common, widespread phenomenon across social media platforms, and your skepticism is entirely justified.While you do not need to panic, you should definitely remain cautious and alert.

Why These Posts Exist. These seemingly innocent prompts are highly engineered, serving two main malicious purposes:

Security Question Mining: Questions about your childhood home, your first pet, or your mother’s maiden name match common account recovery questions. Scammers cross-reference these public answers with your profile to hack your bank or email accounts.

Never Answer Literally: If you want to participate in the conversation, give fake, humorous, or highly generic answers.

Check the Profiles: Click on the names of the posters. Brand-new accounts?

Of course, if these questions are from regular posters, then I don't see any harm. I haven't looked, these ??? posts don't interest me as they are not 'participatory'.

Does the OP ever respond and thank people for their contributions, or engage with them?

MawsRosie Mon 20-Jul-26 19:11:25

Well I think we should ignore all these random questions unless CrazyUSA comes back to tell us WHY (s)he is bombarding us with questions and contributes to a discussion.
It’s not enough to wind us up like tin soldiers and watch us go.

Dickens Mon 20-Jul-26 22:52:40

MawsRosie

Well I think we should ignore all these random questions unless CrazyUSA comes back to tell us WHY (s)he is bombarding us with questions and contributes to a discussion.
It’s not enough to wind us up like tin soldiers and watch us go.

Well I think we should ignore all these random questions unless CrazyUSA comes back to tell us WHY (s)he is bombarding us with questions and contributes to a discussion.

Well, I asked the OP that question on one of the many threads-asking-questions.

I didn't make any accusations - just simply asked what was the purpose of asking numerous ?s.

I did get a reply, but not from the OP... another poster appears to have taken issue with the fact I asked!

The many posts may be completely harmless, but Google AI warns to be cautious about the responses and information you decide to share. I think that's quite legitimate, and sensible.

SpinDriftCoastal Tue 21-Jul-26 08:01:26

When I think what AI can do now sweeping information etc, I would be very reluctant to take part. I belong to a group for mindfulness and once a month we get a set of questions to answer i.e. How are you feeling today? Once I put the set of questions into Co Pilot and gave it all the instructions to answer my PDF. It did the job so well, I felt redundant! Be very careful!

Crumbly159 Tue 21-Jul-26 08:14:00

Sago

The previous threads were asking where your dog slept, what can you see from your window.

It was verging on creepy so I did report it.

I think this is less sinister but a little odd.

That sounds very sinister, never mind simply creepy.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 21-Jul-26 09:14:13

I find all these random inane questions bizarre.
I never respond.
Don’t see the point.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 21-Jul-26 09:48:50

Then you’d be better off saying ‘hi, I’m lonely. Would anyone like to chat?’
🤷‍♀️

Much better than saying ‘what size shoes do you wear?’.